#WitsPoll: 6 reasons why the SMS voting wasn't a good idea

The deadline has passed for Wits University students to vote on whether they would like the academic programme to resume next week.

Wits Vice-Chancellor Professor Adam Habib announced that students and staff would vote on the way forward after two weeks of disruptions on university campuses nation wide.

But the idea of a poll has been hotly contested by protesting students, who are now taking legal action, and have attempted to have it thrown out by the court.

The SMS voting closed at 4pm and the university asked: "Should Wits open on Mon 3 Oct subject to appropriate security protocols being in place? Reply with YES or NO. Reply is free."

Digital activist and academic Dr Colin Thakur says the decision to use SMS voting for the Wits referendum is flawed for these following reasons:

  • The uncontrolled environment means that the electoral process is not regulated by any authority.
  • Outside influences and "shoulder-browsing" could cause voters to vote in a particular way.
  • Family members and other social structures may force voters to make a particular vote through intimidation.
  • There is no guarantee of anonymity, as cellphone numbers are tied to someone's vote.
  • There is also a risk of voter impersonation, where someone would take their device and vote on their behalf.
  • There is also the potential of vote-buying to sway the outcome in a certain direction.

According to Thakur, there are several South African examples of when SMS voting has failed to be effective, such as talent competitions Idols SA and The Voice.

Listen to the full conversation from The John Maytham Show (with Africa Melane):

Read More
Township areas are tinder boxes when it comes to xenophobia - photojournalist

Township areas are tinder boxes when it comes to xenophobia - photojournalist

James Oatway says he has witnessed how quickly a peaceful march can turn into a violent xenophobic mob.

We need support structures for sports stars once they retire - psychologist

We need support structures for sports stars once they retire - psychologist

SA-born former Australian rugby player Dan Vickerman's possible suicide has raised the issue of how to cope when a career ends.

New immigration laws may hinder foreigners with working permits

New immigration laws may hinder foreigners with working permits

Immigration lawyer says now a visa in an expired passport - even if you have two passports - means you are illegal in the country.

Hit the road Panama Jacks says Port Authority

Hit the road Panama Jacks says Port Authority

The 27-year-old local restaurant, a Cape Town institution, has been told by port authorities to leave the Table Bay Harbour.

Increasing VAT by 1% adds up to R20 billion to fiscus

Increasing VAT by 1% adds up to R20 billion to fiscus

"The average VAT rate in Africa is 15.25% while the global average is 15.6%," says Mazars Tax Consultant Tertius Troost.

John Maytham's Books: War, an ornithologist's love story and the power of flags

John Maytham's Books: War, an ornithologist's love story and the power of flags

Listen to John's book reviews for the week...

Popular articles
Eusebius McKaiser: Where the hell were you in the making of JZ, Mathews Phosa?

Eusebius McKaiser: Where the hell were you in the making of JZ, Mathews Phosa?

Eusebius McKaiser uses Open Line to send a message to former ANC Treasury who has recently urged Zuma to step down.

Does God exist? A debate

Does God exist? A debate

Eusebius McKaiser hosted a heated debate on God's existence with atheist Jacques Rousseau and believer Mahlatse Winston Mashua.

Sars officials sniff out 271kg of cocaine in biggest bust to date

Sars officials sniff out 271kg of cocaine in biggest bust to date

Cocaine weighing 271kg, with an estimated street value of R78 million, was confiscated by Sars officials at the OR Tambo Airport.

How Airbnb has made renting in Cape Town even more pricey

How Airbnb has made renting in Cape Town even more pricey

Property management company PayProp argues that Airbnb has driven down rental availability and driven up rental prices in the CBD.