Get the lowdown on tomorrow's judgement on the Nkandla saga

The Constitutional Court hands down judgment tomorrow which will determine whether or not President Jacob Zuma defied the Public Protector's orders to pay back the money spent on his Nkandla homestead.

Why is the Constitutional Court’s decision on President Jacob Zuma and the Public Protector so crucial ? University of Cape Town Senior Public Law lecturer Cathy Powell unpacks the legal scenarios?

Cathy Powell says that the ruling tomorrow is vital for the long term work of the Public Protector's office.

The effect on the current issue is, she argues, fairly negligible, as the president has already conceded that he should have given effect to the the Public Protector's report on Nkandla.

But if it confirms that the Public protector;s recommendations were binding...then the Public Protector as an office in South Africa is strengthened for the rest of our constitutional life.

Cathy Powell, Senior Public Law Lecturer, UCT

What exactly is the Constitutional Court ruling on tomorrow?

It is ruling on whether the the President and Parliament failed to fulfill a Constitutional obligation, bu not giving effect to the recommendations in the Public Protector's report on Nkandla.

In the President's case that he was supposed to get the Minister of Police and Treasury to find out what the non-security upgrades at Nkandla cos, and then to pay it back.

In the case of Parliament, they were meant to hold the president to account on the basis of the report.

The President did not carry out his assigned role, and neither did Parliament.

Both of them in effect, relied on an alternative report produced by the Minister of Police.

Cathy Powell, Senior Public Law Lecturer, UCT

What is the legal consequence for President Jacob Zuma and for Parliament if the Constitutional Court rules that they were in breach of the Constitution and their Constitutional obligations?

What are the consequences for Parliament?

The legal consequence is that Parliament must now do something about that, but the Court cannot do it for them.

Cathy Powell, Senior Public Law Lecturer, UCT

Though I think in this case, the ruling form the Court will be clear that Parliament cannot accept somebody else's report in place of the Public Protector's report.

Cathy Powell, Senior Public Law Lecturer, UCT

What are the consequences for President Zuma?

Politically I think he will be weakened, and the effect that is going to have is going to depend on the power blocks currently aligned and especially within the ANC.

Legally it simply means he has got to pay back at least R 10.5 million...so legally he's got to pay back the money.

Cathy Powell, Senior Public Law Lecturer, UCT

Powell says we do not know yet how 'interventionist' the Constitutional Court is going to be in terms of timelines for payment.

She says the Court has a couple of options.

The first is that it could rule on the intention with which Jacob Zuma failed to fulfill his Constitutional obligations - in other words, did he do it because he did not understand what his obligations were? or did he deliberately flout it?

Secondly, says Powell, the level of seriousness with which the Court takes the violations of the President and Parliament, will effect the political fallout.

South Africa's eyes will be turned to the Constitutional Court at 10 am tomorrow morning to find out.


This article first appeared on 702 : Get the lowdown on tomorrow's judgement on the Nkandla saga


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Booming economy… cheap beer… great food… Beira is where it’s at, but the taxes!

Booming economy… cheap beer… great food… Beira is where it’s at, but the taxes!

VAT at 17%... yoh! Bruce Whitfield interviews Lee Kasumba, who is exploring Mozambique’s central port city of Beira.

Billionaire gives away R100 billion, leaving only 0.0002% of fortune for himself

Billionaire gives away R100 billion, leaving only 0.0002% of fortune for himself

You've probably never heard of Chuck Feeney. Nevertheless, he’s one of the strangest, most impactful people who has ever lived.

Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin – a bromance that'll define your kids' future

Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin – a bromance that'll define your kids' future

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Wits University Professor of International Relations John Stremlau.

Pratley CEO tempts fate, recreates suspended bulldozer stunt on Friday the 13th

Pratley CEO tempts fate, recreates suspended bulldozer stunt on Friday the 13th

"I will still gladly bet my life on the quality of our product," says Pratley Group CEO Kim Pratley.

Beira (Mozambique)… where beer is cheaper than tea (despite ever-present China)

Beira (Mozambique)… where beer is cheaper than tea (despite ever-present China)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews distinguished Africa correspondent Lee Kasumba, who is in Mozambique’s central city.

R24.9 million per year… what the CEOs of SA’s top-10 companies earn (on average)

R24.9 million per year… what the CEOs of SA’s top-10 companies earn (on average)

Ray White interviews Andreas Horak, Associate Director at PwC.

Popular articles
Vila Kasi TV station leaves employees out in the cold with no pay

Vila Kasi TV station leaves employees out in the cold with no pay

Employees of the start-up media house are angered for not receiving salaries as promised at the end of June.

Nhlanhla Nene asks trade unions for ideas on how to fund wage increase demands

Nhlanhla Nene asks trade unions for ideas on how to fund wage increase demands

Nene asked unions representing Eskom workers to provide ideas to fund wage increases after negotiations with Eskom deadlocked.

How Steinhoff shares doubled in just five days

How Steinhoff shares doubled in just five days

Founder of Herenya Capital Advisors, Petri Redelinghuys, explains how the embattled Steinhoff managed to double its share price in 5 days

Parents no longer have to travel with children's birth certificates

Parents no longer have to travel with children's birth certificates

The new Home Affairs upgrades to the system include printing parents details at the back of the child's passport.

SA-made Rolkem cake decoration products may not be safe to eat

SA-made Rolkem cake decoration products may not be safe to eat

The UK’s Food Standards Agency issued an advisory, claiming that Rolkem failed to confirm that their ingredients were safe to eat.

Criminals targeting homes with aluminium windows, warns neighborhood watch

Criminals targeting homes with aluminium windows, warns neighborhood watch

The Panorama, Welgelegen and Plattekloof Neighbourhood Watch has identified a new house break-in trend.

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

These are the emergency numbers you should have on your cellphone and this is what you must understand about how they work.