Judges ask court to reconsider decision on Hlophe tribunal

Constitutional Court judges who accused Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe of misconduct, now want their own court to change its decision not to hear their appeal.

In 2008 now acting deputy chief justice Bess Nkabinde and Judge Chris Jafta were a part of the Constitutional Court’s decision to lodge a charge of misconduct against Hlophe at the Judicial Service Commission. They claimed at the time that Hlophe approached them and tried to improperly influence them on cases related to Jacob Zuma.

But when the inquiry was about to start, they challenged its lawfulness before the constitutional court itself and eventually the court said it could not hear their application because its judges were conflicted.

Now the same two judges want the Constitutional Court to change that decision.

Stephen Grootes talks to legal writer from Business day, Franny Rabkin and asks if we are on new legal ground here. Can a Constitutional Court decision be overturned?

It just happens extremely rarely. And I have been looking all morning, and I have not found one that has been granted.

Franny Rabkin, Legal writer Business Day

Rabkin says she is at a loss to understand this legal challenge by the two judges.

Rabkin's biggest concern is that every judicial conduct tribunal and every allegation of gross misconduct that the JSC has felt warranted a tribunal, has also been put on hold.

Which means a huge component of our judicial accountability mechanism is not functioning.

Franny Rabkin, Legal writer Business Day
Read More
Health apps are useful, but don't obsess over info says expert

Health apps are useful, but don't obsess over info says expert

Health and Wellness expert Vanessa Ascencao talks about the effect of apps on our well being and dangers of dependency and stress.

Too late for ANC to redeem itself on Marikana - analyst

Too late for ANC to redeem itself on Marikana - analyst

On Tuesday Dlamini-Zuma was denied entry to lay a wreath on the Marikana koppie where 34 striking miners were shot dead in 2012.

Latest Glebelands murder brings death toll to 93

Latest Glebelands murder brings death toll to 93

EWN Reporter Ziyanda Ngcobo reports that a man was gunned down at the now infamous Glebelands Hostel on Tuesday night.

Gupta-linked Charles King SA's director named in Panama leaks - Barry Bateman

Gupta-linked Charles King SA's director named in Panama leaks - Barry Bateman

Oakbay sold its Tegeta mining interests to a little-known Swiss company that trades in fashion products, clothing and shoes.

Government's interventions on poverty are not working - analyst

Government's interventions on poverty are not working - analyst

Labour Analyst Mamokgethi Molopyane and ANC TG Zweli Mkhize respond to Stats SA Poverty Trends report of over 30 million poor.

Judges ask court to rethink Hlope decision

Judges ask court to rethink Hlope decision

Acting Chief Justice Bess Nkabinde and Judges Chris Jafta want leave to appeal again in Hlope decision.

Popular articles
NSRI has freed False Bay whale entangled in ropes

NSRI has freed False Bay whale entangled in ropes

NSRI has manged to free a southern right whale entangled in ropes in Fish Hoek, False Bay.

Local desalination company says no to small-scale tender

Local desalination company says no to small-scale tender

Tom Callaghan at Grahamtek says desalination tender is not viable for business but will bid for the large-scale land based plant.

Snakes on a plein: Drought to push snakes closer to properties

Snakes on a plein: Drought to push snakes closer to properties

Snake catcher Shaun McCleod says about 99% of snakes in the WC are just looking for food.

Vodacom to reimburse customers by end of the morning

Vodacom to reimburse customers by end of the morning

Spokesperson Byron Kennedy says the problem was a configuration change on their billing system.

5 reasons why South Africa granted Grace Mugabe diplomatic immunity

5 reasons why South Africa granted Grace Mugabe diplomatic immunity

 Simon Allison, Africa Editor at the Mail & Guardian explains the political considerations behind Mugabe's diplomatic immunity.

"ANN7 and  New Age sale is effectively a transaction between  Manyi and Guptas"

"ANN7 and New Age sale is effectively a transaction between Manyi and Guptas"

Phillip de Wet, Associate Editor at Mail & Guardian breaks down the sale of Gupta owned ANN7 TV Station and The New Age paper.

This is incredibly embarrassing for both countries - SAIIA Head of Governance

This is incredibly embarrassing for both countries - SAIIA Head of Governance

On Saturday international relations minister Maite Nkoane-Mashabane granted diplomatic immunity to Grace Mugabe.

Meet Bonang Mohale, BLSA's outspoken (‘don’t blame colonialism’) Chairperson

Meet Bonang Mohale, BLSA's outspoken (‘don’t blame colonialism’) Chairperson

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Business Leadership South Africa’s Mohale for his weekly “ShapeShifter” feature.