New migration green paper proposing detention camps for asylum seekers

Immigration is a sensitive topic worldwide. it played a role in the Brexit referendum and even here we saw looting of foreign owned shops during the Tshwane unrest.

Immigration and migrants to South Africa is an important issue and now the Department of Home Affairs has released a green paper on migration. In introducing the paper, Minister Malusi Gigaba spoke of a twin track approach. If you have been granted asylum and have your papers, you will be free to live and work where you choose.

But the paper suggests that while you are applying and your status is undetermined, you should be kept in a camp close to your point of entry. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees will play an oversight role in management and administration of these centres.

John Maytham talks to Professor Loren Landau South African Research Chair Mobility and the Politics of Difference African Centre for Migration & Society Wits University about the contents of this Green Paper

These places are unlikely to be in line with South Africa's human rights standards.

Loren Landau South African Research Chair Mobility and the Politics of Difference African Centre for Migration & Society Wits University

Landau says detention centres in places like Australia and the USA are cases in point. They are not designed as a place where people stay for a few days while being processed. They are rather meant to discourage others from coming, he says.

People are kept in detention for long periods without access to their families.

Loren Landau South African Research Chair Mobility and the Politics of Difference African Centre for Migration & Society Wits University

People then choose to rather avoid the process of applying formally for papers, and end up making their way into cities where they live and work illegally without documents.

Landau says he is encouraged that the ANC seems to be discussing the issue in an open and transparent way, but is concerned that more needs to be done to allay locals fears about immigrants. Research shows that immigrants create trade and jobs rather than taking jobs away.

I would have liked to see more research going into it and many more facts. There are a lot of presumptions and assertions which need to be challenged.

Loren Landau South African Research Chair Mobility and the Politics of Difference African Centre for Migration & Society Wits University

At the end of the day, he says, given the anti immigrant climate the world over right now, the green paper is a reasonable document.

Read More
Caller Julie says luxury train stuck in the middle of the Karoo...all day

Caller Julie says luxury train stuck in the middle of the Karoo...all day

Shosholoza Meyl Premier Classe Luxury Train stuck for hours and it doesn't look like it's going anywhere soon, says Julie.

John Books: Stories of serial killers, tricky DNA and a woman ahead of her time

John Books: Stories of serial killers, tricky DNA and a woman ahead of her time

John' Maytham's three book picks for the week.

Disabled riding school loses ConCourt battle and must find new pastures

Disabled riding school loses ConCourt battle and must find new pastures

SA Riding for the Disabled Association has to move premises after 35 years but have been awarded compensation.

Police shoot at crowd of immigrants with rubber bullets (arrests 136 people)

Police shoot at crowd of immigrants with rubber bullets (arrests 136 people)

"As we speak there’s another standoff in Sunnyside, " says EWN's Barry Bateman.

Controversial circus adamant their animals are happy

Controversial circus adamant their animals are happy

Controversial McClaren Circus, have animal acts as part of their show but claim the animals are not beaten, isolated or retrained.

Retired elite athlete opens up about post competitive depression

Retired elite athlete opens up about post competitive depression

In light of former rugby player Dan Vickerman's suicide, former Olympic rower Lee-Ann Persse talks about life after competition.

Popular articles
Letters show Moyane refuses to account to Gordhan, turns to Zuma to intervene

Letters show Moyane refuses to account to Gordhan, turns to Zuma to intervene

M&G reports that Sars Commissioner Tom Moyane declared an intergovernmental dispute against Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan.

Some investments are more attractive after Budget 2017 (some not so much)

Some investments are more attractive after Budget 2017 (some not so much)

Personal Financial Advisor Warren Ingram gives advice on where to put your money; considering changes brought by Budget 2017.

Criminal charges laid against culprit of Stellies rooster assault

Criminal charges laid against culprit of Stellies rooster assault

Police are probing a complaint about a man who tossed a rooster around and forced it to smoke a cigarette at a Stellenbosch party.

Budget 2017 and tax: The good (there is some), the bad and the ugly

Budget 2017 and tax: The good (there is some), the bad and the ugly

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews TaxTim cofounder Marc Sevitz.

Cape Town has the worst traffic and Joburg pips it to the post

Cape Town has the worst traffic and Joburg pips it to the post

TomTom Traffic Index 2017 findings have revealed that Cape Town is South Africa’s most congested city when it comes to traffic.