Former prosecutor says Judge Masipa's sentence was 'not wrong'

Senior EWN reporter Barry Bateman says Pistorius legal team indicate they won't be appealing the sentence, a clear indication they believe justice has been done. The family appear to feel Judge Masipa has set the record straight.

But will the prosecution take this further, all the way to the Supreme Court of Appeal?

There is no indication from the state at this stage what decision they have made...the prosecution team say they are going to wait for the record of the judge's ruling. They are going to study that and it has not been ruled out. So we may still go to Bloemfontein over this.

Barry Bateman, EWN

Judge Masipa made it clear that the mitigating circumstances outweighed the aggravating ones.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor joins CapeTalk's Mike Wills (standing in for John Maytham) on the line from Johannesburg with his views on the controversial sentencing.

It was lenient...but it definitely was not wrong. She gave a defence favourable judgement.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor

He says each matter has to be considered on it's own merits. It is difficult to compare different cases. The judge has to mete out a sentence that is in conjunction with the circumstances of the matter.

I can't fault her on what she did. I think it was a very good judgement, just lenient.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor

It might seem that she ignored some of the victim's personal particulars and the effect that it had on her. But from Day one, I always thought that Judge Masipa was leaning towards Oscar, and dealing with him very favourably throughout the trial. And this was maybe just a continuation of that.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor

It was without a doubt a peculiar situation, where she gave a judgement in favour of culpable homicide, and now she's told listen you had it wrong, come back and give it for murder..

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor

Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Struggling to focus? You may have adult ADHD

Struggling to focus? You may have adult ADHD

Antoinette Muller, who is diagnosed with ADHD, explains the change she felt after going on treatment.

#AfricaConnected: 'Fashion in Cote d'Ivoire is pretty big!'

#AfricaConnected: 'Fashion in Cote d'Ivoire is pretty big!'

Pan-African broadcaster Lee Kasumba says Ivorians love to wear bright colours and take great pride in their local fabrics.

'What message are we sending by recycling someone who isn't fit to be spy boss?'

'What message are we sending by recycling someone who isn't fit to be spy boss?'

Pres Ramaphosa was clearly forced into a political compromise to transfer Arthur Fraser instead of suspension, says Murray Hunter.

#AfricaConnected: SA ambassador to Ivory Coast on a mission to bolster trade

#AfricaConnected: SA ambassador to Ivory Coast on a mission to bolster trade

Lee Kasumba met with Ambassador to Ivory Coast Dayanand Naidoo to discuss business relations between SA and Cote d'Ivoire.

#AfricaConnected: R347m contract to build ferries for Côte d'Ivoire boosts jobs

#AfricaConnected: R347m contract to build ferries for Côte d'Ivoire boosts jobs

SA shipbuilder Nautic Africa has a deal with Cote d'Ivoire-based Citrans to build ferries for the Ivory Coast, Lee Kasumba finds.

Another truck stuck under Muizenberg Bridge (will they ever learn?)

Another truck stuck under Muizenberg Bridge (will they ever learn?)

The Muizenberg railway bridge has become notorious for having buses and trucks smashed into the 2.5 metre high structure.

Popular articles
Highly-criticised world athletics body's rule could end Caster Semenya's career

Highly-criticised world athletics body's rule could end Caster Semenya's career

She faces ongoing complaints from rivals about having an "unfair advantage" on the track, but how fair is this proposed IAAF rule?

Cape plumber designs device to ensure geyser water doesn't go down the drain

Cape plumber designs device to ensure geyser water doesn't go down the drain

Wattapac is a water-saving bladder and pump designed to help plumbers save as much as 1 000 litres of water a day.

'He raped me every day for a year when I was 8 years old'

'He raped me every day for a year when I was 8 years old'

A woman has penned her triumphant story of survival after being sexually abused by an uncle as a child.

Staff at CPT hospital threaten to resign after Parly visit

Staff at CPT hospital threaten to resign after Parly visit

Khayelitsha Hospital staff claim they were ill-treated in front of patients during a visit by a Parliamentary Select Committee.

This is how much you should be paying your domestic worker

This is how much you should be paying your domestic worker

Stephen Rathai, director of employment standards at the Department of Labour talks on the new national minimum wage.

Madiba’s private secretary Zelda la Grange opens up about money (hers and his)

Madiba’s private secretary Zelda la Grange opens up about money (hers and his)

Bruce Whitfield interviews La Grange about her and Madiba's attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.)

Mugg & Bean agrees to pay medical bill of customer

Mugg & Bean agrees to pay medical bill of customer

Mugg & Bean has agreed to pay for customers medical bills after a month of being in pain and pestering the chain to pay the bill.