Former prosecutor says Judge Masipa's sentence was 'not wrong'

Senior EWN reporter Barry Bateman says Pistorius legal team indicate they won't be appealing the sentence, a clear indication they believe justice has been done. The family appear to feel Judge Masipa has set the record straight.

But will the prosecution take this further, all the way to the Supreme Court of Appeal?

There is no indication from the state at this stage what decision they have made...the prosecution team say they are going to wait for the record of the judge's ruling. They are going to study that and it has not been ruled out. So we may still go to Bloemfontein over this.

Barry Bateman, EWN

Judge Masipa made it clear that the mitigating circumstances outweighed the aggravating ones.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor joins CapeTalk's Mike Wills (standing in for John Maytham) on the line from Johannesburg with his views on the controversial sentencing.

It was lenient...but it definitely was not wrong. She gave a defence favourable judgement.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor

He says each matter has to be considered on it's own merits. It is difficult to compare different cases. The judge has to mete out a sentence that is in conjunction with the circumstances of the matter.

I can't fault her on what she did. I think it was a very good judgement, just lenient.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor

It might seem that she ignored some of the victim's personal particulars and the effect that it had on her. But from Day one, I always thought that Judge Masipa was leaning towards Oscar, and dealing with him very favourably throughout the trial. And this was maybe just a continuation of that.

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor

It was without a doubt a peculiar situation, where she gave a judgement in favour of culpable homicide, and now she's told listen you had it wrong, come back and give it for murder..

Marius du Toit, defense lawyer & former prosecutor
Read More
Controversial circus adamant their animals are happy

Controversial circus adamant their animals are happy

Controversial McClaren Circus, have animal acts as part of their show but claim the animals are not beaten, isolated or retrained.

Ford issues an olive branch to Kuga owners

Ford issues an olive branch to Kuga owners

US auto-maker is covering Kuga owners for a 6 year or 200 000km warranty (whichever comes first) through its Extended Care Plan.

Retired elite athlete opens up about post competitive depression

Retired elite athlete opens up about post competitive depression

In light of former rugby player Dan Vickerman's suicide, former Olympic rower Lee-Ann Persse talks about life after competition.

Township areas are tinder boxes when it comes to xenophobia - photojournalist

Township areas are tinder boxes when it comes to xenophobia - photojournalist

James Oatway says he has witnessed how quickly a peaceful march can turn into a violent xenophobic mob.

We need support structures for sports stars once they retire - psychologist

We need support structures for sports stars once they retire - psychologist

SA-born former Australian rugby player Dan Vickerman's possible suicide has raised the issue of how to cope when a career ends.

New immigration laws may hinder foreigners with working permits

New immigration laws may hinder foreigners with working permits

Immigration lawyer says now a visa in an expired passport - even if you have two passports - means you are illegal in the country.

Popular articles
Budget 2017 and tax: The good (there is some), the bad and the ugly

Budget 2017 and tax: The good (there is some), the bad and the ugly

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews TaxTim cofounder Marc Sevitz.

Legality of Brian Molefe’s Parliamentary nomination called into question

Legality of Brian Molefe’s Parliamentary nomination called into question

A lack of transparency raises suspicions as to whether Molefe's route to Parliament has been ushered in with integrity.

Sars officials sniff out 271kg of cocaine in biggest bust to date

Sars officials sniff out 271kg of cocaine in biggest bust to date

Cocaine weighing 271kg, with an estimated street value of R78 million, was confiscated by Sars officials at the OR Tambo Airport.

How Airbnb has made renting in Cape Town even more pricey

How Airbnb has made renting in Cape Town even more pricey

Property management company PayProp argues that Airbnb has driven down rental availability and driven up rental prices in the CBD.