'The law is clearly being abused' Hawks Vs Pravin Gordhan

Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan has issued a statement saying he will not be honouring the Hawks request to present himself to their offices by 14h00 on Thursday 25 August.

This stirred up comments on social media, with people saying that the Minister is not above the law, and that he should allow the law take its course.

However Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Chair in Constitutional Governance, argues that this is not a case where the law should simply follow its course.

He says the law has not been correctly interpreted and applied according to the available facts. He referred to the the whole debacle against the Finance Minister as an extra legal process, rather than a criminal offence.

A letter written to Minister Gordhan by the Hawks refers to two provisions of two different acts which do not create criminal offence

Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Chair in Constitutional Governance

He says that the charges of corruption against Minister Gordhan, and facts provided by the Hawks, still do not constitute it as criminal offence.

It is a bit vague to say we should let the law take its course because the law is clearly being abused

Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Chair in Constitutional Governance

De Vos also questioned the fact that the Hawks accuse Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan of acting corruptly by granting early retirement to the former deputy head of Sars, Ivan Pillay, a decision which was made by former Sars commissioner Oupa Magashula.

It is overwhelming that the Hawks are targeting one particular individual despite the fact that there is no legal basis for it

Pierre de Vos, Claude Leon Chair in Constitutional Governance

Listen to the full conversation below:

Read More
Health and wellness: All you need to know about ears, nose and throat

Health and wellness: All you need to know about ears, nose and throat

CapeTalk's Pippa Hudson speaks to Dr Gary Kroukamp, ENT specialist about a couple of ENT conditions that we need to be aware of.

More South Africans on social grants than those earning an income

More South Africans on social grants than those earning an income

According to SAIRR researcher Gerbrandt van Heerden the number of people receiving social grants has increased by 328% since 2001.

DA could take Mbete's decision on review if she doesn't grant secret ballot

DA could take Mbete's decision on review if she doesn't grant secret ballot

DA Federal Leader, James Selfe says Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng's ruling was the right one and the party welcomes it.

Concourt makes it impossible for Mbete not to adopt secret ballot - analyst

Concourt makes it impossible for Mbete not to adopt secret ballot - analyst

Professor Somadoda Fikeni says Speaker will have to provide a superior argument not to approve the voting through secret ballot.

Business owners ponder succession plans at the business networking breakfast

Business owners ponder succession plans at the business networking breakfast

Business growth specialist Pavlo Phitidis shares some of the highlights of the CapeTalk Nedbank Business Accelerator.

Caller raises concerns about the SA Nursing Council

Caller raises concerns about the SA Nursing Council

The SA Nursing Council seems to be having operational issues that leave many within the profession unhappy.

Popular articles
Two dogs allegedly jumped a fence, viciously attacked 3 year old and her grandpa

Two dogs allegedly jumped a fence, viciously attacked 3 year old and her grandpa

The two dogs belong to the family's neighbour are believed to be a rottweiler and pit-bull.

5 facts about the new SA number plates being implemented this year

5 facts about the new SA number plates being implemented this year

No official date has been set for the roll out of SA's new number plate legislation, but here's what you need to know so long.

In case you hadn't noticed, Cape Town feels freezing cold (and here's why)

In case you hadn't noticed, Cape Town feels freezing cold (and here's why)

Capetonians are pulling out hot water bottles and mittens as a cold front is predicted to make landfall on Thursday morning.

Ntsiki Mazwai gets behind 24 hour social media boycott #DataMustFall

Ntsiki Mazwai gets behind 24 hour social media boycott #DataMustFall

Ntsiki Mazwai is asking South Africans to stay off social media on Wednesday in a #DataMustFall campaign.

CAPS is killing teachers passion - caller

CAPS is killing teachers passion - caller

CapeTalk caller says Curriculum Assessment Policy Statements (CAPS) is not good for South Africa's education system.