Is the Supreme Court of Appeal the next route for the State in Pistorius matter?

Judge Thokozile Masipa rejected an application by the State to appeal against Oscar Pistorius’ 6-year murder sentence. EWN reporter Gia Nicolaides joins The Midday Report's Stephen Grootes on the line.

She says the judge considered the arguments, but does not believe another court would come to a different conclusion. She says prosecutor Gerrie Nel argued the court misdirected itself when it was looking at the judgments. Nel also felt Judge Masipa was too sympathetic towards Oscar Pistorius's personal circumstances.

Nel argues 6 years in prison is far too lenient, bearing in mind the minimum sentence for murder is 15 years.

Advocate Barry Roux disagreed, saying Oscar has been punished over and over again and if one tallies up the time spent in jail already and under house arrest it comes to an effective 8 years.

After a couple of hours deliberation, Judge Masipa returned and dismissed the application with costs.

Nicolaides says the prosecution does have the option to petition the Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein, to try and get a different outcome.

However Nel was not prepared to speak to the media at this stage about their plans.


This article first appeared on 702 : Is the Supreme Court of Appeal the next route for the State in Pistorius matter?


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[LISTEN] John Maytham's Book Review: murder, dilettantes and Jihad

[LISTEN] John Maytham's Book Review: murder, dilettantes and Jihad

John's three book picks for the week.

[LISTEN] The pros and cons of using reusable nappies

[LISTEN] The pros and cons of using reusable nappies

Disposable nappies generate 1 ton of waste per baby.

[WATCH] John Maytham depressed by District Six land claims figures

[WATCH] John Maytham depressed by District Six land claims figures

John talks about the alarming and depressing figures lodged with the land claims commission.

[WATCH] Male pupils reflect on how #JustMen production opened their eyes

[WATCH] Male pupils reflect on how #JustMen production opened their eyes

The production leaves audiences young and old emotionally moved by the powerful content and performances.

[WATCH] #JustMen cast and director open up about powerful production

[WATCH] #JustMen cast and director open up about powerful production

This multilingual docudrama for men and about men is performed by South African men who tell their personal stories.

 #JustMen actor's raw honesty about his violent past and how he's changed

#JustMen actor's raw honesty about his violent past and how he's changed

John Maytham chats to one of the actors in #JustMen Sherman Pharo about the powerful and emotional performance.

Popular articles
Why are African teams under performing in the 2018 World Cup?

Why are African teams under performing in the 2018 World Cup?

With only five teams in the World Cup, Africa's performance hasn't exactly been memorable, so what could be the problem?

[Listen] Local hero saves family from fire

[Listen] Local hero saves family from fire

A CapeTalk listener shares the story of a young man who saved a family of five from a burning house.

Woman exposed for calling fellow aircraft passengers the K-word

Woman exposed for calling fellow aircraft passengers the K-word

Reverend Solomuzi Mabuza says he is considering laying charges against the woman for calling him a ka***r.

What business is Nomgcobo Jiba doing at NPA offices?

What business is Nomgcobo Jiba doing at NPA offices?

Freedom Under Law is demanding an explanation from the NPA after Jiba was spotted at their offices, defying a court order.

Hate plastic? Grocer Nude Foods doesn’t have any of it! It’s also cheaper…

Hate plastic? Grocer Nude Foods doesn’t have any of it! It’s also cheaper…

The concept is not new, or a hipster fad. The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Nude Foods founder Paul Rubin.

Why Ethiopian Airlines (not SAA) is Africa's biggest and best airline

Why Ethiopian Airlines (not SAA) is Africa's biggest and best airline

State-owned (but not managed) Ethiopian Airlines is profitable. Bruce Whitfield interviews Africa correspondent Lee Kasumba.

Willemse will take Supersport to Equality Court over walk-out findings

Willemse will take Supersport to Equality Court over walk-out findings

On Tuesday, SuperSport released the findings of an investigation by Advocate Vincent Maleka.

You aren't legally entitled to an annual increase (and why your contract is key)

You aren't legally entitled to an annual increase (and why your contract is key)

Employment law litigator Joe Mothibi explains that an annual increase is not a given unless stated otherwise in the job contract.

Callers ask what will happen to Ashwin Willemse after MultiChoice findings

Callers ask what will happen to Ashwin Willemse after MultiChoice findings

On Tuesday SuperSport and Multichoice's said there was no evidence of racism following an investigation into the incident in May.

LISTEN: What's AfriForum's private prosecution attempt against Jiba about?

LISTEN: What's AfriForum's private prosecution attempt against Jiba about?

AfriForum's Kallie Kriel says Jiba abused her position to fabricate a case against former KZN Hawks head General Johan Booysen.