Is criticism levelled against African Union within reason?

The African Union has over the years come under increased criticism, with commentators labelling it a "toothless" organisation.

Naysayers have lamented the continental body's track record in poor conflict resolution, weak democratisation efforts and human rights concerns.

702/Cape Talk's Eusebius McKaiser (standing in for Redi Tlhabi) spoke to political analyst Prince Mashele and former diplomat Tom Weiler regarding the matter.

Listen to the conversation below:

Mashele said there's little evidence suggesting any effectiveness of the AU according to its own mandate. He said political instability in Zimbabwe, Democratic Republic of Congo, Burundi and Rwanda are examples of ongoing governance challenges.

Inter-governmental organisations by their very nature are held hostage to national interests of member states. The AU is not an exception, the UN suffers the same problem, the EU is in turmoil because of the same problem.

Prince Mashele, political analyst

Wieler said that the AU has done well in coordinating talks between regional bodies (SADC, ECOWAS and EAC) as it's important for African leaders to talk.

If the member states choose a strong leader to replace her [Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma], perhaps then that person can turn the organisation around.

Tom Wieler, former diplomat
Read More
Phenye Modiane takes South African opera to the world stage

Phenye Modiane takes South African opera to the world stage

The talented Gauteng Opera solo performer tells Eusebius McKaiser how he traded his soccer boots in high school to pursue music.

Naked Scientist explains why you 'shed' weight after a hot bath

Naked Scientist explains why you 'shed' weight after a hot bath

The Scientist explains why your scale may be an inaccurate way to measure weight loss and more.

Is marriage overrated? Listeners share differing views

Is marriage overrated? Listeners share differing views

Relationship guru and sexologist Dr Eve says the notion of the 'marriage advantage' is being debunked by many couples and groups.

Why Eskom, McKinsey must get their story straight on millions paid to Trillian

Why Eskom, McKinsey must get their story straight on millions paid to Trillian

Financial Mail's Sikonathi Mantshantsha says either Eskom or McKinsey is lying about paying Gupta-linked Trillian nearly R500m.

Looking for a new read? Author and columnist Kate Sidley reviews four books

Looking for a new read? Author and columnist Kate Sidley reviews four books

Author, columnist, and editor Kate Sidley's enticing reviews that may have you running to the nearest bookstore.

Debate: Uncovering how wide racism stretches in the media

Debate: Uncovering how wide racism stretches in the media

In his continuing series focusing on the media in South Africa, Eusebius McKasier asks: Is mainstream media racist?

Popular articles
Post Office's Mark Barnes disappointed at Magwaza's departure from Sassa

Post Office's Mark Barnes disappointed at Magwaza's departure from Sassa

Barnes says Magwaza had sent him a letter expressing the agency's intentions to appoint the Post Office to pay social grants.

W Cape hard-hitting video will make you think twice before driving and texting

W Cape hard-hitting video will make you think twice before driving and texting

The Province's #ItCanWait Campaign uses CCTV footage of people walking and texting with disastrous consequences to make its point.

Should employers deduct money for time spent on smoke breaks?

Should employers deduct money for time spent on smoke breaks?

Caller, Ashley in Somerset West shares her opinion on some suggestions made on combating smoking in the workplace.

Glacier reveals bodies of Swiss couple missing for 75 years

Glacier reveals bodies of Swiss couple missing for 75 years

Adam Gilchrist has more on this tragedy that left 7 children orphaned.

ANCYL wants Mapaila's party membership revoked

ANCYL wants Mapaila's party membership revoked

Political analyst Karima Brown shares details on political stories making headlines in South Africa.

WATCH: Vlogger claims billions of litres of usable water in underground tunnels

WATCH: Vlogger claims billions of litres of usable water in underground tunnels

In his video, Adam Spires, takes a look at the underground spring water that flows out to sea which he believes could be used.

[LISTEN] Roger Federer's SA born mother says her son hates to lose

[LISTEN] Roger Federer's SA born mother says her son hates to lose

South African born Lynette Federer speaks to CapeTalk's Kieno Kammies about her son who clinched his 8th Wimbledon title.