Is criticism levelled against African Union within reason?

The African Union has over the years come under increased criticism, with commentators labelling it a "toothless" organisation.

Naysayers have lamented the continental body's track record in poor conflict resolution, weak democratisation efforts and human rights concerns.

702/Cape Talk's Eusebius McKaiser (standing in for Redi Tlhabi) spoke to political analyst Prince Mashele and former diplomat Tom Weiler regarding the matter.

Listen to the conversation below:

Mashele said there's little evidence suggesting any effectiveness of the AU according to its own mandate. He said political instability in Zimbabwe, Democratic Republic of Congo, Burundi and Rwanda are examples of ongoing governance challenges.

Inter-governmental organisations by their very nature are held hostage to national interests of member states. The AU is not an exception, the UN suffers the same problem, the EU is in turmoil because of the same problem.

Prince Mashele, political analyst

Wieler said that the AU has done well in coordinating talks between regional bodies (SADC, ECOWAS and EAC) as it's important for African leaders to talk.

If the member states choose a strong leader to replace her [Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma], perhaps then that person can turn the organisation around.

Tom Wieler, former diplomat
Read More
Civil society and SA govt must call a truce to work together - experts

Civil society and SA govt must call a truce to work together - experts

The conflict between civil organisations and the state needs to come to an end in order to mobilise social change in South Africa.

Eusebius McKaiser's hard-hitting Q&A with Buti Manamela on SA youth

Eusebius McKaiser's hard-hitting Q&A with Buti Manamela on SA youth

Manamela said government and youth both need to start thinking differently in approaching youth development.

#FridayStandIn Crispin Sonn abides by the business ethic 'do well, do good'

#FridayStandIn Crispin Sonn abides by the business ethic 'do well, do good'

Crispin Sonn, director of Gamiro and son of democratic South Africa's first US ambassador Franklin Sonn, believes in giving back.

How to deal with online harassment, 'sextortion' and revenge porn

How to deal with online harassment, 'sextortion' and revenge porn

If you are a victim of harassment and virtual violence, it is important to take action. Dr. Eve offers advice on how to handle it.

How to make sure your competitive streak doesn't get ugly

How to make sure your competitive streak doesn't get ugly

Dr. Schomer identifies when competitiveness becomes unhealthy and what we can do to curtail negativity when trying to get ahead.

The case for and against return of the death penalty

The case for and against return of the death penalty

The idea that re-instating the death penalty will serve as a deterrent against crimes remains a highly-contested issue.