Giving someone retirement package does not warrant fraud charges - Judge Yacoob

Former Constitutional Judge, Zak Yacoob, gives his opinion on the case against Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan, saying it is difficult to understand how National Director of Public Prosecutions, Shaun Abrahams exercised the discretion to prosecute Gordhan.

He says all Gordhan did when he was commissioner at Sars was to approve the recommendation from Sars that Ivan Pillay should receive his retirement package, to which he was entitled. he was then reinstated because he was necessary to Sars.

Yacoob says this same practice happens all the time in the corporate sector and does not warrant being called fraud.

He says the way things were done also raises eyebrows because the summons was delivered at his house instead of through his lawyers without giving Gordhan and his lawyers an opportunity to make representations.

Firstly I say there is no case and even if there is somewhat of a case, giving someone a retirement package and then let them carry on because they are necessary to the organisation does not seem to me to be the kind of offense which you'll charge to put the whole country at risk.

Justice Zak Yacoob, former justice of the Constitutional Court

Listen to the full conversation below:

Read More
Gender Commission stumped as to why so few women in judicial positions of power

Gender Commission stumped as to why so few women in judicial positions of power

The Commission is calling for a summit on gender transformation in the judiciary to try and find out why the pace is so slow.

20% maths pass mark only on the table for 2016

20% maths pass mark only on the table for 2016

Department of Basic Education says the reduction in maths pass requirement is a once off measure for this year only.

Expert energy panel says Minister ignored advice on nukes

Expert energy panel says Minister ignored advice on nukes

Chris Yelland says Minister Tina Joemat-Pettersson also refused advice from her own advisory council to force plans to go ahead.

Coffin assault accused denied bail

Coffin assault accused denied bail

The presiding magistrate said it is not in the interest of justice to grant bail and their lives may be in jeopardy if released.

Ex SABC board member says he was attacked for discussing PP's report in meeting

Ex SABC board member says he was attacked for discussing PP's report in meeting

Ronnie Lubisi says he was verbally attacked for trying to discuss the Public Protector's report on former COO Hlaudi Motsoeneng.

Investigative journo unit exposes Gupta money laundering claims

Investigative journo unit exposes Gupta money laundering claims

AmaBhungane claims they have evidence that Gupta family using a group of holding companies to launder money and linked to SOEs.