Documentary filmmaker under fire for ignoring women's voices in new ANC movie

The Giant is Falling, a film produced by Rehad Desai, has sparked a conversation about the exclusion of black women's voices from socio-political discourse in the country.

Activist Simamkele Dlakavu raised the lack of women's voices in the film calling it "subjective".

The film documents South Africa's changing political landscape in recent years, marking dwindling support for the African National Congress.

The only woman who was interviewed was Fiona Forde, while the list of men included Jackson Mthembu, Dali Mpofu, Julius Malema, Kgalema Motlanthe, Ronnie Kasrils, Ben Turok, Moeletsi Mbeki, Songezo Sibi, Vuyani Pambo and Zwelinzima Vavi.

However, Desai has countered the argument, claiming to have not had ample opportunity to approach more women.

There are a couple of people who refused to communicate with me. Judith February agreed to do the interview with me. Ranjeni Munusamy is one other person I pestered.

Rehad Desai, producer of documentary

Desai later conceded Dlakavu's concerns, saying the following:

"There should have been more consideration for more female representation in the voices. I should've tried harder and I'm sure I could've gotten the people."

Dlakavu highlighted the danger of Desai using his platform to tell a South African story through a subjective angle that silences and erases black women's voices.

It comes with a responsibility. You are narrating a nation's politics... If international audiences watched this not knowing the politics of this country, they would think that black women in this country have not engaged in political dissent.

Simamkele Dlakavu, equality activist

Listen to the full interview below:

Read More
Maternal deaths caused by unsafe abortion a cry for reproductive justice

Maternal deaths caused by unsafe abortion a cry for reproductive justice

Two medical experts unpack the importance of reproductive justice in SA and recognising a woman's right to choose.

[LISTEN] Naked Scientist tells us how dreaming occurs and why people sleeptalk

[LISTEN] Naked Scientist tells us how dreaming occurs and why people sleeptalk

Naked scientist Chris Smith explains brain activity associated with dreaming, as well as why you are likely to talk in your sleep.

LISTEN: Debate on Mabulu's latest work and what constitutes art

LISTEN: Debate on Mabulu's latest work and what constitutes art

Ayanda Mabulu has drawn controversy once again over his latest painting depicting Nelson Mandela in a sexually explicit position.

Tumi Morake talks weight loss and her new show

Tumi Morake talks weight loss and her new show

The production, Tease, will run through November and December at the Market Theater.

59 women have led their countries in the last half century

59 women have led their countries in the last half century

Sri Lanka was the first modern country with a female leader. If the US elects Clinton, she’ll be the most powerful woman ever.

Engineers are the super heroes of the world, more women need to sign up

Engineers are the super heroes of the world, more women need to sign up

The percentage of women graduates in engineering is still below 20% in many countries and WomanEng is on a mission to change that.

Popular articles
'We weren't going to quit', says Tim Noakes on not guilty verdict

'We weren't going to quit', says Tim Noakes on not guilty verdict

Prof Tim Noakes has been found not guilty by the Health Professions Council of South Africa on a charge of unprofessional conduct.

New evidence comes to light in Ipid's probe against top cop

New evidence comes to light in Ipid's probe against top cop

Ipid has revealed that evidence against Khomotso Phahlane shows a dubious pattern in car purchases.

Still no trace of missing Charlotte Nikoi, one month on

Still no trace of missing Charlotte Nikoi, one month on

The husband of missing Charlotte Nikoi has pleaded with public to come forward with any information regarding her whereabouts.

[Watch] All the Foreshore Freeway Project proposals

[Watch] All the Foreshore Freeway Project proposals

Take a look at the 6 six proposals that have been received by the City for the Foreshore freeway precinct.

We are in denial of people marching against us - Lindiwe Sisulu

We are in denial of people marching against us - Lindiwe Sisulu

Human Settlements Minister criticised the ANC for being passive at the memorial of late struggle stalwart Amhed Kathrada.

'Gigaba will have limited effect; the elephant in the room is the President'

'Gigaba will have limited effect; the elephant in the room is the President'

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Standard Bank Chief Economist Goolam Ballim.

How does El Nino affect Western Cape province?

How does El Nino affect Western Cape province?

Professor William Landman explains what El Nino is and its effects on the coming seasons in the Western Cape.

'Land restitution failed because Government is the biggest owner of land'

'Land restitution failed because Government is the biggest owner of land'

Bruce Whitfield interviews Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba's advisor Chris Malikane and Business Leadership SA's Bonang Mohale.