The case for and against return of the death penalty

South Africa's high crime rates have resulted in increasing calls for the re-instatement of the death penalty as a deterrent.

Despite various polls indicating a significant portion of the country being in favour of its re-instatement, it remains a divisive and contentious issue that would require an amendment to the Constitution which protects citizens' right to life.

The death penalty was abolished more than 20 years ago with the advent of a post-apartheid society.

If we are going to bring back the death penalty, we would have to amend the Bill of Rights which is almost never a good idea.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional Law expert

De Vos made it clear that any changes to the Bill of Rights requires a two-thirds majority vote in Parliament and says that will never happen.

702/Cape Talk's Eusebius McKaiser (standing-in for Redi Tlhabi) engaged constitutional law expert, Pierre de Vos, and director of Christian View Network, Philip Rosenthal, to present both sides of the argument regarding the issue.

De Vos said that the pro-death penalty deterrence argument conflicts with the heart of democratic South Africa's founding principles in upholding equality and justice.

People talk about the death penalty as if it's going to stop crime or be a deterrent, while all the evidence suggests is that it is not a deterrent.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional Law expert

The SA Institute of Race Relations (SAIRR) recently said the following in stating a case against the re-instatement of the death penalty:

"human beings who are not infallible ought not to choose a form of punishment which is irreparable".

However, Rosenthal emphasised that part of the process of justice is taking a life for a life in the form of capital punishment.

The view of the sanctity of life - which is held by most of South Africa and explained in the Bible - is one that sees the state having a role in administering justice which includes punishing murderers.

Philip Rosenthal, Christian View Network director

Listen to the conversation below:


This article first appeared on 702 : The case for and against return of the death penalty


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
A flirt or a predator? Callers share thoughts on flirting in light of #MeToo

A flirt or a predator? Callers share thoughts on flirting in light of #MeToo

It's become clear that more people are trying to carefully navigate the line between flirting and harassment, or sexual predation.

Zuma's permanent stay of prosecution bid puts NPA on trial, says Karyn Maughan

Zuma's permanent stay of prosecution bid puts NPA on trial, says Karyn Maughan

Reporter Karyn Maughan shares latest in Jacob Zuma's high court bid to have corruption charges against him permanently dropped.

This mess that is Eish-kom, is the ANC's doing, says Eusebius

This mess that is Eish-kom, is the ANC's doing, says Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser and callers discuss Ramaphosa's comment that South Africans will overcome load shedding like they did apartheid.

John Maytham's book reviews: Killers, eccentric families and a tale of injustice

John Maytham's book reviews: Killers, eccentric families and a tale of injustice

John reviews 3 books, a Chief Inspector who hunts serial killers, hilarious family antics...and a South African apartheid story.

Return of the death penalty mooted

Return of the death penalty mooted

The South African Institute for Race Relations (SAIRR) has released a report on whether capital punishment should be reinstated.

Shepherds & Butchers film unveils trauma of white men under apartheid regime

Shepherds & Butchers film unveils trauma of white men under apartheid regime

The film has started a conversation about how white men were also victims of oppression under the apartheid regime.

Popular articles
Shift to stage 2: Over 800 megawatts back on line from Cahora Bassa - Eskom

Shift to stage 2: Over 800 megawatts back on line from Cahora Bassa - Eskom

Eskom COO Jan Oberholzer predicts Stage 2 load shedding for Friday and Saturday and energy expert Chris Yelland also weighs in.

Distraught caller describes harrowing experience on Baden Powell Drive

Distraught caller describes harrowing experience on Baden Powell Drive

A CapeTalk caller explained to Lester Kiewit how he went through flames and over rocks, and debris to escape his car being stoned.

SA doctors use 3D printing in world's first ever middle ear transplant

SA doctors use 3D printing in world's first ever middle ear transplant

Thanks to the groundbreaking surgery, a 35-year-old man will hear again after his ear was completely damaged in a car crash.

DStv subscription price hikes for 2019

DStv subscription price hikes for 2019

MultiChoice will increase the prices of certain DStv packages from 1 April.

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Eskom has warned that more power cuts can be expected as maintenance continues over the next twelve months.

SA only nation capable of hosting Afcon 2019, says sports pundit

SA only nation capable of hosting Afcon 2019, says sports pundit

Safa will make a bid to host Afcon next year after Cameroon was stripped of its hosting rights over security concerns and other delays.

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

These are the emergency numbers you should have on your cellphone and this is what you must understand about how they work.