How to have productive arguments in public

In a democracy, controversy is healthy, and public interest is well served by robust public argument.

However, when people disagree, the result can be more heat than enlightenment, with neither side actually taking the time to listen to the other.

The question then becomes, how do we build a culture of debate that allows for meaningful engagement in the realm of ideas even when we do not agree?

University of Cape Town (UCT) philosophy lecturer, Jacques Rousseau, talks to Eusebius McKaiser about productive disagreements.

Rousseau says people need to learn to detach their ideas from their self-worth.

We should talk to each other to discover our own errors rather than to persuade people of their own errors.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT philosophy lecturer

Your mindset should not be one of destruction and criticism but rather self-interrogation, self-reflection and self-improvement.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT philosophy lecturer

We do aim to improve the world. And that means detecting and eliminating errors where we can. When you do detect errors worth considering or debating, one should be willing and engage, but not in a way that demeans and trivialises that person's belief.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT philosophy lecturer

Rousseau emphasises that there is a lot to take from a dialogue, even when people disagree.

There is a different way of understanding productive. One can learn how people think about things. One can learn about their arguments, blind spots and biases.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT philosophy lecturer

Rousseau also has a few tips for those who debate and engage in heated conversations on social media.

You must remember that you are not only talking to the person you talking to. It's the same as talk radio. There is an audience that may never call in, but they are listening. They are hearing your tone, strategy and arguments, and learning how to debate and argue reasonable.

Jacques Rousseau, UCT philosophy lecturer

Listen to the full interview with Jacques Rousseau below...

Read More
Cellphones help inmates in family reunification - Sapohr

Cellphones help inmates in family reunification - Sapohr

As the debate over whether inmates should be allowed cellphones continues, Sapohr says they should be legalised for inmates.

President Zuma calls on students to engage in constructive dialogue

President Zuma calls on students to engage in constructive dialogue

During his brief appearance at the higher education summit, President Zuma condemned acts of violence and destruction to property.

Student movement needs to rethink their game plan, says Wits academic

Student movement needs to rethink their game plan, says Wits academic

Wits prof Vishwas Satgar says students need new mechanisms to open the national dialogue on university fees and other grievances.

Lerato Tshabalala defends her opinions about black and white 'stereotypes'

Lerato Tshabalala defends her opinions about black and white 'stereotypes'

Author of a book The Way I See It , Lerato Tshabalala says her book is based on truth and the way she observes South Africa.

Zapiro takes on critic Eusebius McKaiser over organ grinder monkey cartoon

Zapiro takes on critic Eusebius McKaiser over organ grinder monkey cartoon

Zapiro's cartoon depicting NPA boss as an organ grinder's monkey has caused much public criticism, with accusations of racism.

HIV/Aids awareness song sparks public debate

HIV/Aids awareness song sparks public debate

A song raising awareness on HIV/Aids, which was commissioned by Doctors Without Borders, has been met with criticism and praise by members of the public.

Will the DA public debate signal the return of public debating?

Will the DA public debate signal the return of public debating?

Mmusi Maimane and Wilmot James will face-off against each other in a televised debate on Monday night fighting for DA leadership.

Popular articles
"Case against President Zuma is strong, it is sound and ready to go to trial"

"Case against President Zuma is strong, it is sound and ready to go to trial"

Barry Bateman, EWN reporter in the Supreme Court of Appeal's ruling to reinstate charges and what this means for President Zuma.

V&A Waterfront responds to claims of sewage water on customer's car

V&A Waterfront responds to claims of sewage water on customer's car

A customer was not happy to find her car in a huge puddle of effluent water after doing her shopping at the V&A Waterfront.

Heroic fire fighter saves drowning child while on holiday

Heroic fire fighter saves drowning child while on holiday

It's not clear how long the little girl (3) spent underwater but it took ten minutes to resuscitate her.

De Waal Drive is now renamed after Philip Kgosana, but who was he? Here's a look

De Waal Drive is now renamed after Philip Kgosana, but who was he? Here's a look

Cape Town's well-known bend has been renamed in honour of PAC stalwart Philip Kgosana, but very few know his historic importance.

A list of words that people need to 'basically' stop using

A list of words that people need to 'basically' stop using

These words have become so overused and pretentious that listeners believe that they've lost their meaning.

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

These are the emergency numbers you should have on your cellphone and this is what you must understand about how they work.