Hate Speech Bill: Experts cite unconstitutional consequences

Last year Cabinet invited public comment on the draft Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill.

The Bill aims to give effect to country's obligations in terms of the Constitution and international human rights instruments concerning racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance.

Hate Crimes Working Group chairperson, Sanja Bornman, says the provision around hate speech has dominated the public debate at the expense of the hate crime provision.

Bornman says Section 4 of the Bill outlining the offence of hate speech is very broad.

She highlights that the language used is wide and many speech acts that should not be criminalised might look illegal.

See Section 4 summary below quoted by Bornaman;

"Any person who intentionally, by means of any communication whatsoever, communicates to one or more persons in a manner that advocates hatred, is threatening, abusive or insulting, and which demonstrates a clear intention, cite others to harm, up violence against, or bring into contempt or ridicule, any person or group of persons."

Freedom of Religion South Africa executive director, Michael Swain, says there is a need for adjustments in the Bill.

The hate speech is so broad that it could potentially be used for an application that was not originally intended.

Michael Swain, Freedom of Religion South Africa executive director

The big danger is, in a democracy as soon as you define hate speech broadly, you inevitably limit freedom of speech and when you do so you start to undermine one of the most fundamental freedom that we enjoy for democracy.

Michael Swain, Freedom of Religion South Africa executive director

Another thing is that you paralyse the situation and you can effectively shut down the debate.

Michael Swain, Freedom of Religion South Africa executive director

The more we limit particularly freedom of speech by labeling it hate speech, the more we undermine our democracy and opportunity to engage in what I believe should be very fruitful conversation.

Michael Swain, Freedom of Religion South Africa executive director

Bornman argues that as things stand in the criminal justice system there is no obligation to investigate the motive on hate crime or the court to take it into account.

She says the section focusing on hate crimes is necessary.

Hate crime is recognised in criminal law. All this law needs to do is now recognise the motive, provide us with a definition what is hate crime.

Sanja Bornman, Hate Crimes Working Group chairperson

Listen to the full interview below for more arguments...

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Church leaders oppose the Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill

Church leaders oppose the Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill

Pastor Lazarus Pillay says bill demeans Christian way of life and liberty to speak against sexual sins including homosexuality.

Three women killed in the WC during 16 days of activism

Three women killed in the WC during 16 days of activism

As we wrap up the year, EWN reporter, Lauren Issacs shares some of the interesting stories covered in 2016.

Suspected lesbian hate crime indicative of SA's social crisis, says activist

Suspected lesbian hate crime indicative of SA's social crisis, says activist

LGBTI activist and researcher Phumi Mtetwa says that hate crimes are a societal problem which need to be tackled by all citizens.

Cape woman's murder seen as hate crime

Cape woman's murder seen as hate crime

Noluvo Swelindawo was shot and killed at the weekend and her body found near N2 highway.

Closet racists exist beyond those exposed on social media - analyst

Closet racists exist beyond those exposed on social media - analyst

Political analyst Maynard Manyowa says racially charged events aren't all caught on camera and don't all make it to social media.

Justice Ministry extends deadline for comment on proposed hate crimes bill

Justice Ministry extends deadline for comment on proposed hate crimes bill

The decision to delay the deadline comes after various organisations asked for an extension to allow for submissions.

Comedian's censorship concerns with new Hate Speech Bill

Comedian's censorship concerns with new Hate Speech Bill

The proposed bill could limit various topics for comedians, which would affect how comedians create content.

Stamping out racism needs more than Hate Speech Bill - expert

Stamping out racism needs more than Hate Speech Bill - expert

Founder of Diversi-T, Terry Oakley-Smith, says the proposed new bill is necessary but people need to be educated about racism.

What constitutes hate speech?

What constitutes hate speech?

Minister Masutha announced proposed bill to help combat hate speech and Prof Jane Duncan explains what hate speech involves.

Hate Crimes Bill approved for public comment

Hate Crimes Bill approved for public comment

Steve Letsike describes the aims of the Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill which Cabinet has approved for public comment.

'Gender variations and sexual orientation are not choices people make'

'Gender variations and sexual orientation are not choices people make'

Dr Eve looks at why hate crimes are committed against lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex, and questioning (LGBTIQ).

Reported hate crime against lesbian triggers Twitter outrage

Reported hate crime against lesbian triggers Twitter outrage

Twitter users are up in arms over emerging reports of a horrific murder of a young lesbian, Motshidisi Pascalina, in December last year.

Popular articles
NSRI has freed False Bay whale entangled in ropes

NSRI has freed False Bay whale entangled in ropes

NSRI has manged to free a southern right whale entangled in ropes in Fish Hoek, False Bay.

Local desalination company says no to small-scale tender

Local desalination company says no to small-scale tender

Tom Callaghan at Grahamtek says desalination tender is not viable for business but will bid for the large-scale land based plant.

Snakes on a plein: Drought to push snakes closer to properties

Snakes on a plein: Drought to push snakes closer to properties

Snake catcher Shaun McCleod says about 99% of snakes in the WC are just looking for food.

Vodacom to reimburse customers by end of the morning

Vodacom to reimburse customers by end of the morning

Spokesperson Byron Kennedy says the problem was a configuration change on their billing system.

5 reasons why South Africa granted Grace Mugabe diplomatic immunity

5 reasons why South Africa granted Grace Mugabe diplomatic immunity

 Simon Allison, Africa Editor at the Mail & Guardian explains the political considerations behind Mugabe's diplomatic immunity.

"ANN7 and  New Age sale is effectively a transaction between  Manyi and Guptas"

"ANN7 and New Age sale is effectively a transaction between Manyi and Guptas"

Phillip de Wet, Associate Editor at Mail & Guardian breaks down the sale of Gupta owned ANN7 TV Station and The New Age paper.

This is incredibly embarrassing for both countries - SAIIA Head of Governance

This is incredibly embarrassing for both countries - SAIIA Head of Governance

On Saturday international relations minister Maite Nkoane-Mashabane granted diplomatic immunity to Grace Mugabe.

Meet Bonang Mohale, BLSA's outspoken (‘don’t blame colonialism’) Chairperson

Meet Bonang Mohale, BLSA's outspoken (‘don’t blame colonialism’) Chairperson

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Business Leadership South Africa’s Mohale for his weekly “ShapeShifter” feature.