Cabinet will decide to appeal court ruling on ICC withdrawal notice, or not

The High Court in Pretoria has ruled that the Executive or Cabinet's notice to withdraw from the International Criminal Court (ICC) without Parliamentary approval amounts to a breach of separation of powers.

President Jacob Zuma and his Executive have been ordered to revoke the withdrawal.

In the decision to enter into international agreements, that's a prerogative of the Executive. When government or the Executive makes a decision, that decision to enter into such an agreement is then brought to Parliament and then ratified through decision-making processes in Parliament and essentially domesticated and becomes South African law.

Barry Bateman, EWN reporter

What the court found is that the notice of withdrawal is essentially an exercise of that legislative authority of Parliament. It amounts to a ratification.

Barry Bateman, EWN reporter

Justice Minister Michael Masutha says they will look at the judgement to see if they have been given 14 days to make the appeal or abide by the decision.

If the order and judgement relate solid to the question of what is the chicken and the egg, I can say that we grappled with that question at the level of government. We acted on strong legal opinion which suggested that the proper way to go about it is the way we did.

Michael Masutha, Justice Minister

We will have to decide if there is any need to appeal the decision, which could further delay the process or to act accordingly and reapproach Parliament.

Michael Masutha, Justice Minister

There has never been a process where Parliament took a policy decision to enter into an international agreement.

Michael Masutha, Justice Minister

Government's announcement to withdraw followed ICC's order for South African to arrest Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir, who slipped out of the country in contravention of a court order.

Listen to Minister Michael Masutha below to hear why SA wants to withdraw from the Rome Statute...

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Mozambique rejects AU's proposal of mass withdrawal from ICC

Mozambique rejects AU's proposal of mass withdrawal from ICC

Mozambique presidency has announced that it has no intention to leave the International Criminal Court (ICC).

African leaders agree on mass withdrawal from ICC

African leaders agree on mass withdrawal from ICC

African leaders have adopted a strategy for a collective withdrawal from the International Criminal Court (ICC).

Opposition naive to use ICC threat against Yahya Jammeh - commentator

Opposition naive to use ICC threat against Yahya Jammeh - commentator

Gambian President Yahya Jammeh has refused to step down for President-elect Adama Barrow, appealing the election results.

Parliament not bypassed on decision to withdraw from ICC argues State

Parliament not bypassed on decision to withdraw from ICC argues State

DA wants government's decision to withdraw from the International Criminal Court declared unconstitutional.

Application to set aside government's decision to withdraw from ICC urgent - DA

Application to set aside government's decision to withdraw from ICC urgent - DA

DA says court matter needs to be finalised before the withdrawal comes into effect in October 2017 and argues 4 points.

5 big international shockers that made political waves in 2016

5 big international shockers that made political waves in 2016

A look back at some political moves that made headlines, and in some cases, left the world in disbelief this year.

Masutha clarifies legal and political reasons for quitting ICC

Masutha clarifies legal and political reasons for quitting ICC

Justice Minister has confirmed that South Africa is leaving the International Criminal Court (ICC).

SA's decision to withdraw from ICC comes 4 weeks before al Bashir court case

SA's decision to withdraw from ICC comes 4 weeks before al Bashir court case

The Rome Statute is a hindrance for the country to engage in international relations, says Masutha.

South Africa to begin exit process from ICC

South Africa to begin exit process from ICC

Minister of International Relations Maite Nkoana-Mashabane signed 'instrument of withdrawal' from International Criminal Court.

SACP welcomes appeal to challenge Janusz Waluś release

SACP welcomes appeal to challenge Janusz Waluś release

Justice Minister Michael Masutha feels the court erred in its judgment in granting Janusz Walus parole and the SACP agrees.

SCA rules that SA's failure to arrest al-Bashir was unlawful

SCA rules that SA's failure to arrest al-Bashir was unlawful

State fails in its attempt to appeal High Court ruling which found its refusal to arrest Omar al-Bashir's last year to be illegal.

'Precedent will be set in SCA ruling on Al-Bashir'

'Precedent will be set in SCA ruling on Al-Bashir'

South African government is challenging the High Court’s finding that the failure to arrest Omar al-Bashir was unconstitutional.

Popular articles
Best bank ad ever? Andy Rice reviews Investec’s “you’re more than data”

Best bank ad ever? Andy Rice reviews Investec’s “you’re more than data”

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews the advertising expert about the best and worst new advertisements.

Police apparently mulling over warrant of arrest after Grace Mugabe a no-show

Police apparently mulling over warrant of arrest after Grace Mugabe a no-show

EWN understands that lawyers representing the Zimbabwean first lady are negotiating with officers at the Sandton police station.

[LISTEN] 20-year-old SA woman traumatised by Grace Mugabe's assault

[LISTEN] 20-year-old SA woman traumatised by Grace Mugabe's assault

Gabriella Engels says she is saddened by people who are calling her names on Twitter before they understand the full story.

Traffic gridlocked as Imizamo yethu residents make their way to Cape Town

Traffic gridlocked as Imizamo yethu residents make their way to Cape Town

About 40 minibus taxis, in a convoy at a very low speed, are transporting Imizamo Yethu residents into CT for a planned protest.

Words you’ll hear: Grace Mugabe's latest nickname

Words you’ll hear: Grace Mugabe's latest nickname

Find out why Zimbabwe's First Lady should be dubbed with the moniker 'extension cord'.

Discovery CEO (and founder) Adrian Gore bares his soul about money

Discovery CEO (and founder) Adrian Gore bares his soul about money

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Gore about his attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

Ocean Basket gives franchise owner the chop after assault video

Ocean Basket gives franchise owner the chop after assault video

The man was immediately divested of his shares and is no longer part of the group, explains Ocean Basket CEO Grace Harding.

WATCH: Cape schoolkids 'starstruck' after Trevor Noah,  Charlize Theron drop by

WATCH: Cape schoolkids 'starstruck' after Trevor Noah, Charlize Theron drop by

Oaklands High principal Reza Patel says it was an extremely exciting experience for both the learners and staff. We can imagine!

CoCT explains new electricity tariffs

CoCT explains new electricity tariffs

Following residents concerns over new electricity tariffs and properties being re-evaluated, Johan van der Merwe provides clarity.