Zille's tweet has history buffs refuting dominant colonial narrative

Following Helen Zille's controversial tweet saying there were some redeeming features to colonialism, Eusebius McKaizer hosts a discussion that broadens the historical context of this practice and bursts the bubble of the dominant narrative.

In fact, for the first four or five centuries of colonialism, Europeans didn’t even have advanced medical care.

Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon, African Centre for Migration & Society

Their medical care was very rudimentary and primarily what they brought were disease and these diseases wiped out huge proportions of the populations because of lack of local immunity.

Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon, African Centre for Migration & Society

Predominant narratives around medical practice have over the years been used to deliberately ignore and erase existing indigenous knowledge systems which produced good health practices.

The tweet by Helen Zille sparked debate once again on what Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon says is ‘the continued liberal myths of colonisation - that Europeans brought advanced and widespread medical care to the colonies'.

Dr. Carla Tsampiras, Senior Lecturer in Medical Humanities at the University of Cape Town, explains how this narrow focus on history is as a result of past political power dynamics.

She also elaborates on how this translated into the use of European sciences to perpetuate domination over people and nations.

To speak of history in such a flat manor removes a number of things.

Dr. Carla Tsampiras, Senior Lecturer in Medical Humanities at UCT

If we think about what we define as western bio-medicine it removes the relationship between the enlightenment and the Islamic golden age.

Dr. Carla Tsampiras, Senior Lecturer in Medical Humanities at UCT

We know that in the Islamic golden age between the 8th and the 13th century there were Arabic and Islamic scholars who were well advanced in medical practice and knowledge. They had collated a lot of the classical knowledge that had been produced in the previous empires.

Dr. Carla Tsampiras, Senior Lecturer in Medical Humanities at UCT

There was an active mechanism to try and use medicine and science to prove difference because doing that would allow the perpetuation of certain types of power an privilege over other peoples.

Dr. Carla Tsampiras, Senior Lecturer in Medical Humanities at UCT

Speaking on the impact of forced labor migration and the poor living conditions later on during the surge toward industrialization, Wilhelm-Solomon reminds listeners that this was an active spread of disease and raised levels of epidemic disease.

He says colonisation did not set the trajectory for good healthcare.

Most of the time European medical knowledge wasn't what we consider advanced medical knowledge at all. They didn't even understand the basics of germ transmission.

Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon

This is very important. The issue is that these developments did not fundamentally benefit colonised populations. In fact, they often worked directly against colonised populations.

Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon

Right from the beginning of Johannesburg's history public health scares were used to displace black populations.

Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon

Click on the link below to listen to the full interview...


This article first appeared on 702 : Zille's tweet has history buffs refuting dominant colonial narrative


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Max Du Preez says Zille has no option but to resign

Max Du Preez says Zille has no option but to resign

Zille is currently facing a disciplinary charge following a controversial tweet stating colonialism was beneficial.

[CARTOON] What a Twit

[CARTOON] What a Twit

EWN's Avi & Curtis sum up what most South Africans felt after Western Cape premier and DA member Helen Zille's unfortunate tweet.

Zille did not mean to defend colonialism - spokesperson

Zille did not mean to defend colonialism - spokesperson

DA Federal Chairperson says no charges have been officially laid internally or outside of the DA with regards to Zille's tweets.

DA's interim WC leader says he will address Helen Zille on her colonial tweet

DA's interim WC leader says he will address Helen Zille on her colonial tweet

Democratic Alliance's Bonginkosi Madikizela stated that he can't pronounce on whether Zille will be recalled or not.

Opinion: Eusebius McKaizer declares Helen Zille's apology feeble

Opinion: Eusebius McKaizer declares Helen Zille's apology feeble

The talk show host believes Western Cape premier failed to acknowledge that she defended colonialism in her tweet on Thursday.

Popular articles
Eskom: WhatsApp message about Thursday 'blackout' is fake news

Eskom: WhatsApp message about Thursday 'blackout' is fake news

Eskom's head of generation, Andrew Etzinger, says the WhatsApp message doing the rounds about a blackout is misinformation.

What are the rules and regulations when it comes to owning a generator?

What are the rules and regulations when it comes to owning a generator?

A listener on the Afternoon Drive has shared his frustrations with a neighbor's noisy generator and the health risks it posed.

Eskom and authorities have to plan for worst case scenario, says energy expert

Eskom and authorities have to plan for worst case scenario, says energy expert

Analyst Chris Yelland says South Africans should be comforted and not alarmed by the fact that Eskom has made contingency plans.

Distraught caller describes harrowing experience on Baden Powell Drive

Distraught caller describes harrowing experience on Baden Powell Drive

A CapeTalk caller explained to Lester Kiewit how he went through flames and over rocks, and debris to escape his car being stoned.

What's next with Jacob Zuma's corruption charges trial?

What's next with Jacob Zuma's corruption charges trial?

Investigative journalist, Karyn Maughan, reflects on a year since charges against former President Jacob Zuma were reinstated.

Kilometres of boiler tube leaks 'are biting us big time' says Eskom COO

Kilometres of boiler tube leaks 'are biting us big time' says Eskom COO

Eskom's Jan Oberholzer says it has discovered boiler tube leaks which continue for kilometres and is working to repair this.

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Eskom has warned that more power cuts can be expected as maintenance continues over the next twelve months.