Don’t say the word "xenophobia" (and blame Twitter, not Goodwill)

Rebecca Davis spoke to John Maytham from parliament. Davis was there to cover Zuma’s address on xenophobia. As she discovered the word itself was barely mentioned.

Davis and Maytham discussed the:

  • Pre-parliamentary shenanigans
  • Zuma’s address to the nation
  • The response

Maytham felt that Zuma’s speech was neither inspirational nor convincing.

I tend to agree it was lacking on the inspirational side. There really wasn’t a sense of real passion and urgency from the president.

Rebecca Davis

However Davis did say that she was expecting worse.

She referenced the statement released by the presidency last weekend, which put the blame on foreign nationals.

  • The presidency said they’d be beefing up security on the boarder
  • Foreign nationals should not indulge in crime

There was a clear message on that occasion that perhaps some of the suspicions towards foreigners were warranted.

Rebecca Davis

What is interesting is that the word "xenophobia" itself became the unspoken.

He (Jacob Zuma) acknowledged the concern of South Africans about foreign nationals. As usual, not a mention of the word xenophobia. The government prefers to talk about the ‘attacks on foreign nationals’ but it certainly is revealing that up till now we have not seen one statement from this government so far that has used the word xenophobia.

Rebecca Davis

In my memory, and I was making fairly extensive notes, he used the word xenophobia only once.

Johan Maytham

#blametwitterandfb

Here’s what JZ talked about:

  • He said the attacks violate respect for life, human dignity and Ubuntu. The country stands against racism, xenophobia, homophobia and sexism

  • He appealed to social media, namely Facebook and Twitter, to refrain from fanning the flames of violence

Here’s what JZ did not talk about:

  • He did not refer to King Goodwill Zwelithini’s statement, “We are requesting those who come from outside to please go back to their countries.”

  • He did not mention his own son, Edward Zuma, who said in reference to foreigners, “We are sitting on a ticking time bomb.”

  • He did not mention any other government leaders

I’d like to see some evidence that the people who are looting foreign owned shops and driving them away from their homes and into refugee camps and brandishing pangas are being persuaded to do so by their twitter timeline.

John Maytham

“ I’d like to see some evidence that the people who are looting foreign owned shops and driving them away from their homes and into refugee camps and brandishing pangas are being persuaded to do so by their twitter timeline.”

Davis also spoke about the timing and impact of the address. She noted that the president gave a longer portion of his speech in Zulu.

I’d like to see any evidence that those people are sitting at home and listening to Jacob Zuma give this appeal. A parliamentary address at midday is always going to be preaching to the choir. It’s hard to imagine people seeing that and putting down their looting implements.

Rebecca Davis

Davis agreed with John that a major flaw was Zuma’s unwillingness to criticize King Goodwill Zwelithini. He wasn’t the only one who refused to criticize the monarch.

We just saw Julius Malema from the EFF who gave a very, very hard speech criticizing a culture of violence which he said had been instigated by the ANC government under Zuma’s leadership. But he was at pains to state he did not want to be misinterpreted as criticizing Zwelithini.

Rebecca Davis

Davis spoke about Zwelithini’s power and authority, which Maytham grappled with.

It’s hard for someone like me with my middle class anti-monarchist sentiments to understand that. Particularly given the fact that Zwelithini hardly distinguished himself as a stalwart in the struggle against apartheid, he was utterly and completely complicit until the ANC came into power.

John Maytham

Maytham then turned the focus to the man who has subsequently announced that he has accepted the nomination to stand as the DA’s leader, Mmusi Maimane.

Political football

Maimane is a good speaker, he spoke somewhat more passionately than Zuma. He managed to get in a few digs at the current administration, unemployment and their inability to support small business. But he did say, which I think was the right approach, that we cannot turn xenophobia into political football.

Rebecca Davis

Therein lies the crux. Instead of parliamentarians putting their differences aside and focussing on this hugely significant issue, they used the platform for other disputes

In the pre-Zuma address today when parliament was quibbling for almost an hour over the rules of the house, over whether he would be answering the Nkandla question, I think the overwhelming thing was frustration. So I think Maimane did a good job there reminding everyone that this wasn’t the moment for political game playing.

Rebecca Davis

One can only watch this space and hope that the presidency will do more towards tackling xenophobia over and above cautioning tweeters. Considering the reluctance to mention the very name itself, perhaps we could change it to #NoZenInPhobia.

Listen to the audio for more detail.

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Xenophobic attacks may threaten SA Inc. in Africa (and therefore your pension)

Xenophobic attacks may threaten SA Inc. in Africa (and therefore your pension)

Do you have a pension fund or retirement annuity? How xenophobia may potentially harm the wealth you've worked so hard to amass…

Plan B - What's more important; plants or people?

Plan B - What's more important; plants or people?

Future ramifications of statue removals; terribly drafted Traditional Courts Bill; plants vs people; when 'no' means 'yes'...

Shining a torch on torture; a stellar Sabiti

Shining a torch on torture; a stellar Sabiti

“In war if you look very closely you’ll find peace.” - Stella Sabiti. A story of suffering transformed into global significance.

New Beginnings: Christel House School, quality education to children in need

New Beginnings: Christel House School, quality education to children in need

This school takes children from dire poverty and shows them a future beaming with possibilities. The results are astonishing.

How kidnapping survivor Monique Strydom is tackling abuse through chats on taxis

How kidnapping survivor Monique Strydom is tackling abuse through chats on taxis

A woman boards a taxi and starts a conversation about abuse. And so the healing starts...

New Beginnings: Cape Camino - A journey to the self in the south

New Beginnings: Cape Camino - A journey to the self in the south

In order to find yourself you first need to lose yourself. Now there is a Cape Town route to enlightenment, the Cape Camino.

Popular articles
5 reasons why South Africa granted Grace Mugabe diplomatic immunity

5 reasons why South Africa granted Grace Mugabe diplomatic immunity

 Simon Allison, Africa Editor at the Mail & Guardian explains the political considerations behind Mugabe's diplomatic immunity.

"ANN7 and  New Age sale is effectively a transaction between  Manyi and Guptas"

"ANN7 and New Age sale is effectively a transaction between Manyi and Guptas"

Phillip de Wet, Associate Editor at Mail & Guardian breaks down the sale of Gupta owned ANN7 TV Station and The New Age paper.

This is incredibly embarrassing for both countries - SAIIA Head of Governance

This is incredibly embarrassing for both countries - SAIIA Head of Governance

On Saturday international relations minister Maite Nkoane-Mashabane granted diplomatic immunity to Grace Mugabe.

Read and weep: 10 of the most expensive houses in South Africa

Read and weep: 10 of the most expensive houses in South Africa

These super luxury houses with enormous price tags will induce some serious house envy.

44 drivers arrested for drunk driving in WC traffic blitz

44 drivers arrested for drunk driving in WC traffic blitz

Western Cape provincial traffic chief, Kenny Africa gives traffic updates of what he described as a very hectic weekend in the WC.

Grace Mugabe immunity: SA between ‘rock & hard place’

Grace Mugabe immunity: SA between ‘rock & hard place’

Professor Christopher Landsberg has praised the International Relations and Cooperation Minister for her 'honest approach'.

[Watch] John Maytham shuts down victim shamer on air

[Watch] John Maytham shuts down victim shamer on air

A caller wanted to know what the alleged victim had done in order for Grace Mugabe to assault her.

Meet Bonang Mohale, BLSA's outspoken (‘don’t blame colonialism’) Chairperson

Meet Bonang Mohale, BLSA's outspoken (‘don’t blame colonialism’) Chairperson

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Business Leadership South Africa’s Mohale for his weekly “ShapeShifter” feature.