Why are some court sentences harsher than others?

The Khayelitsha regional court on Wednesday sentenced four men to a combined 127-years imprisonment for running an abalone syndicate.

The sentence shocked many people asking why the justice system is lenient on murderers and rapists and very harsh on these four men.

Criminal law expert, Advocate Mannie Witz, says it all depends on the charges and the Act under which an individual is charged as each one has a sentence provision.

Statutory matters prescribe to the presiding officers what type of sentence should be imposed.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

According to Witz, these kind of crimes used to be under a different kind of Act which has now been changed to Marine and Living resources Act. In this particular Act they charge people with possession of abalone, transporting and processing of it, says Witz.

What happened here is a very important act which was formed in 1998, it's a statute called the Prevention of Organised Crime Act (Poca)... This is a sentence for proper organised crimes - syndicate related crimes.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

In terms of Poca, you can get a fine R100 million or life imprisonment if you are found guilty. The regional court can limit it to a fine of R30 million or 20-25 years imprisonment or both.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

Obviously these people have been convicted under that Act.

Advocate Mannie Witz, Criminal Law Expert

To hear more of this interview, listen below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
How to keep abalone out of poachers hands and in the sea

How to keep abalone out of poachers hands and in the sea

Marine experts discuss ways in which poaching of abalone can be avoided as oceans continue to be plundered.

Inspirational tale of 3rd South African female to summit Mount Everest

Inspirational tale of 3rd South African female to summit Mount Everest

Lee den Hond, entrepreneur & inspirational speaker, shares her journey of becoming an entrepreneur and climbing Mount Everest.

'Illegal catch of abalone is 10 times more than the legal catch'

'Illegal catch of abalone is 10 times more than the legal catch'

Efforts to curb abalone poaching for the past seven years have not produced positive results as populations continue to decline.

The rand… Pravin Gordhan speaks... De Beers on Kimberley’s Big Hole…

The rand… Pravin Gordhan speaks... De Beers on Kimberley’s Big Hole…

These were the 7 most read, most talked about business articles of the past week.

De Beers discusses Kimberley’s Big Hole – one of the largest on the planet

De Beers discusses Kimberley’s Big Hole – one of the largest on the planet

Bruce Whitfield interviews a De Beers spokesperson on what some people claim to be the world’s largest hole dug by hand.

Abalone harvesting to be given to small fishing cooperatives to curb poaching

Abalone harvesting to be given to small fishing cooperatives to curb poaching

Government plans to give the country's entire abalone fishery to poor fishermen with the hope to stop abalone poaching.

How the legal abalone (aka perlemoen) industry functions in South Africa

How the legal abalone (aka perlemoen) industry functions in South Africa

The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews the MD of Abagold, a company that cultivates, processes and exports abalone.

Popular articles
Why are African teams under performing in the 2018 World Cup?

Why are African teams under performing in the 2018 World Cup?

With only five teams in the World Cup, Africa's performance hasn't exactly been memorable, so what could be the problem?

[Listen] Local hero saves family from fire

[Listen] Local hero saves family from fire

A CapeTalk listener shares the story of a young man who saved a family of five from a burning house.

Woman exposed for calling fellow aircraft passengers the K-word

Woman exposed for calling fellow aircraft passengers the K-word

Reverend Solomuzi Mabuza says he is considering laying charges against the woman for calling him a ka***r.

What business is Nomgcobo Jiba doing at NPA offices?

What business is Nomgcobo Jiba doing at NPA offices?

Freedom Under Law is demanding an explanation from the NPA after Jiba was spotted at their offices, defying a court order.

Hate plastic? Grocer Nude Foods doesn’t have any of it! It’s also cheaper…

Hate plastic? Grocer Nude Foods doesn’t have any of it! It’s also cheaper…

The concept is not new, or a hipster fad. The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Nude Foods founder Paul Rubin.

Why Ethiopian Airlines (not SAA) is Africa's biggest and best airline

Why Ethiopian Airlines (not SAA) is Africa's biggest and best airline

State-owned (but not managed) Ethiopian Airlines is profitable. Bruce Whitfield interviews Africa correspondent Lee Kasumba.

Willemse will take Supersport to Equality Court over walk-out findings

Willemse will take Supersport to Equality Court over walk-out findings

On Tuesday, SuperSport released the findings of an investigation by Advocate Vincent Maleka.

You aren't legally entitled to an annual increase (and why your contract is key)

You aren't legally entitled to an annual increase (and why your contract is key)

Employment law litigator Joe Mothibi explains that an annual increase is not a given unless stated otherwise in the job contract.

Callers ask what will happen to Ashwin Willemse after MultiChoice findings

Callers ask what will happen to Ashwin Willemse after MultiChoice findings

On Tuesday SuperSport and Multichoice's said there was no evidence of racism following an investigation into the incident in May.

LISTEN: What's AfriForum's private prosecution attempt against Jiba about?

LISTEN: What's AfriForum's private prosecution attempt against Jiba about?

AfriForum's Kallie Kriel says Jiba abused her position to fabricate a case against former KZN Hawks head General Johan Booysen.