Refugee Appeal Board taken to court over a crisis of adjudication

On Tuesday, the Pretoria News ran with a story that a group of people led by the Somali Association of South Africa is going to the High CCourt in Pretoria to argue that there is a crisis of adjudication at the Refugee Appeal Board.

Stephen Grootes, host of The Midday Report spoke to Wayne Ncube, Lawyers for Human Rights and Senior Attorney who prepared for the case of Somali refugee’s reject status.

Ncube explains that the case is specifically about status termination, to decide whether or not someone can be a refugee in South Africa.

What we're finding is that the Refugee Appeal Board keeps on making a number of consistent errors in their decision making.

Wayne Ncube, Senior attorney, Lawyers for Human Rights

This includes applying the right tests to decide whether or not someone is a refugee. Applying basic legal principles.

Wayne Ncube, Senior attorney, Lawyers for Human Rights

Ncube adds that the appeal board was disbanded last year and was recently set up again and as a result is facing a massive backlog.

Listen to the full report here:


This article first appeared on 702 : Refugee Appeal Board taken to court over a crisis of adjudication


CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
#CapeStorm: How you can help

#CapeStorm: How you can help

How you can help and where to donate in the wake of #CapeStorm.

"Refugees and asylum seekers may not be refused emergency medical treatment"

"Refugees and asylum seekers may not be refused emergency medical treatment"

Human rights lawyer Kayan Leung says this common unconstitutional practice saw DRC immigrant give birth in Gautrain carriage.

Real radical economic transformation

Real radical economic transformation

Could the overused and undefined phrase hold real meaning for South Africa and the rest of the continent?

Youngest Somali Cabinet minister shot dead

Youngest Somali Cabinet minister shot dead

31-year-old Abbas Abdullahi Sheikh Siraji was shot dead by soldiers guarding another minister in what may have been an accident.

Young slam poets paint an uplifting picture with their spoken word

Young slam poets paint an uplifting picture with their spoken word

Four young wordsmiths from the SA poetry house 'Current State Of Poetry' gave presenter Eusebius McKaiser a lesson in slam poetry.

SA surf heroes honoured with Cape monument at Muizenberg  beach

SA surf heroes honoured with Cape monument at Muizenberg beach

The 'walk of fame' site will be SA’s first national monument dedicated to preserving and promoting the heritage of surfing.

How to put your finances in the only hands you can trust – your own!

How to put your finances in the only hands you can trust – your own!

A guide to finance and investment for normally intelligent people who aren't in the industry.

Revamped Marabastad refugee centre gets automated

Revamped Marabastad refugee centre gets automated

President Jacob Zuma will open the centre that hopes to combat corruption and provide services to foreign nationals.

Top finance CEO exposes how financial services industry sells you fairy tales

Top finance CEO exposes how financial services industry sells you fairy tales

Magda Wierzycka is the CEO of Sygnia Group and says her grounding in maths and science was key to her success.

US appeals court rejects reinstatement of Trump's Muslim ban

US appeals court rejects reinstatement of Trump's Muslim ban

Judges say government failed to prove why banning migrants from seven Muslim-majority countries is urgent.

 Uganda welcomes more refugees than Europe

Uganda welcomes more refugees than Europe

Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC) says Uganda welcomed more refugees daily in 2016 than many wealthy European countries.

Chinese President: Don't blame globalisation for world's problems

Chinese President: Don't blame globalisation for world's problems

Chinese President Xi Jinping has delivered his speech at 46th World Economic Forum in Davos.

Gift of the Givers helping Syrian refugees, needs donations

Gift of the Givers helping Syrian refugees, needs donations

20 000 civilians have been reportedly evacuated from Aleppo as cold weather sets in.

Berlin Christmas market attack confirmed as terrorism

Berlin Christmas market attack confirmed as terrorism

A 23 year old Pakistani asylum seeker is in police custody in connection with the attack that killed at least 12 people.

Word of the year 2016

Word of the year 2016

Each year the world's wordsmiths list the new and most popular words in the English language.

Home Affairs officials demand bribes from asylum seekers - report

Home Affairs officials demand bribes from asylum seekers - report

Corruption Watch has opened criminal cases against three Home Affairs employees implicated in corrupt activities at Marabastad.

Meet Aimee Barrett, the female rugby referee flying the SA flag in Rio

Meet Aimee Barrett, the female rugby referee flying the SA flag in Rio

Aimee Barrett is the only woman rugby ref from SA to officiate at the 2016 Rio Olympics and shares how her love for the game grew.

Meet Waveheart Arafat Gatabazi

Meet Waveheart Arafat Gatabazi

This 21 year old refugee from DRC lives by one saying: “When you want to do something, you just have to do it.”

'Lighten up': A father's advice to other fathers

'Lighten up': A father's advice to other fathers

Author, Alan Hoskings who has raised three girls spoke to John about how fathers can raise young girls in the 21st Century.

7 gifts you should not get for dad this Fathers' Day.  Or should you?

7 gifts you should not get for dad this Fathers' Day. Or should you?

There aren't any ties or soaps on this list. Nevertheless, these gifts are so bad that they are perfect.

Why fees matter far more than you think

Why fees matter far more than you think

Independent Financial Advisor Peter Calitz unpacks fees and discusses how to ensure you don’t pay too much.

Popular articles
What Shoprite, Checkers, Pick n Pay and Makro will offer on Black Friday

What Shoprite, Checkers, Pick n Pay and Makro will offer on Black Friday

Up for a Springboks level scrum? Instructions on how to ensure you get the deals in your inbox the moment they become known...

‘If Mugabe could be shafted so can Zuma - the view of many in SA’

‘If Mugabe could be shafted so can Zuma - the view of many in SA’

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews independent political analyst Daniel Silke.

'Molefe doesn't fit the recruitment criterion into the SANDF'

'Molefe doesn't fit the recruitment criterion into the SANDF'

Sandu secretary, Pikkie Greef says the union will lay criminal charges against Molefe's illegal appointment in the SANDF.

I didn't believe that he was ever going to step down - JJ Cornish

I didn't believe that he was ever going to step down - JJ Cornish

EWN Africa Correspondent, JJ Cornish describes Mugabe's Sunday evening speech as a humiliating downturn for the Zim president.

 Mugabe is actually showing them that he knows this game - Njabulo Ncube

Mugabe is actually showing them that he knows this game - Njabulo Ncube

Millions tuned for the Zimbabwean president's 'resignation' speech on Sunday night and instead called for unity in Zanu-PF.