"ConCourt hinted strongly that a secret ballot would be the wisest decision"

While the ruling that there was no reason for the Parliamentary Speaker not to hold a secret ballot in itself was not surprising, was there anything that stood out in the judgment from a legal and constitutional perspective?

Constitutional law expert Pierre de Vos things there was.

I think there was something quite interesting in the sense that we are a system in which the National Assembly, on paper at least is the most powerful of the two branches of government...because they elect the President, they can fire the President.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

But in practice it does not always work that way, he says.

The Parliament does not always hold the Executive as accountable as it should. And the language in this judgment is very strong as to the...constitutionally mandated obligations...of the National Assembly to hold the Executive accountable.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

And the fact that their first obligation is to the Constitution and not their political parties, the court found.

Which is interesting as the Members of Parliament are only in Parliament because they happen to be in the good books of the leaders of their political party.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

But will this finding have any impact on the real world of politics?

De Vos says the judgment may be a useful precedent for the future.

The ConCourt did sort of hedge their bets...saying when the Speaker decides on the secret ballot she needs to take into account the whole picture.

Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert

This hedging allows for secret ballots only to happen when appropriate.

He says the ConCourt today was hinting very strongly that a secret ballot would be the wisest and the best decision to follow in this particular case.

Take a listen:

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Schools Act prohibits political activities during school time, says SGB group

Schools Act prohibits political activities during school time, says SGB group

There is public debate over an image of Maritzburg College pupils carrying EFF branded T-shirts, calling for land redistribution.

'Zero chance Zuma will appear in court before ANC's elective conference'

'Zero chance Zuma will appear in court before ANC's elective conference'

News editor Adriaan Basson says it is unlikely that the NPA will decide on whether or not to prosecute Zuma before December.

Holomisa: ANC mistaken, it did not win secret ballot ruling

Holomisa: ANC mistaken, it did not win secret ballot ruling

UDM leader Bantu Holomisa says that Baleka Mbete's arrogance and blind loyalty to the ANC and Zuma has put them in this mess.

DA could take Mbete's decision on review if she doesn't grant secret ballot

DA could take Mbete's decision on review if she doesn't grant secret ballot

DA Federal Leader, James Selfe says Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng's ruling was the right one and the party welcomes it.

Concourt makes it impossible for Mbete not to adopt secret ballot - analyst

Concourt makes it impossible for Mbete not to adopt secret ballot - analyst

Professor Somadoda Fikeni says Speaker will have to provide a superior argument not to approve the voting through secret ballot.

ANC caucus will not vote against President  - ANC Chief Whip #SecretBallot

ANC caucus will not vote against President - ANC Chief Whip #SecretBallot

Jackson Mthembu says voting the President out of power is in the interest of the DA.

Popular articles
Hassen Adams (he brought Burger King and Dunkin’ Donuts to SA) talks money

Hassen Adams (he brought Burger King and Dunkin’ Donuts to SA) talks money

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Adams about his attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

Eusebius Opinion: "Let go Kevin Pietersen, you do not own the school"

Eusebius Opinion: "Let go Kevin Pietersen, you do not own the school"

McKaiser responds to former SA, now England cricketer Pietersen's comments over Maritzburg College pupils holding EFF t-shirts.

Twitter is gobsmacked as Nigeria honours Jacob Zuma with bronze statue and road

Twitter is gobsmacked as Nigeria honours Jacob Zuma with bronze statue and road

During Zuma's visit to Nigeria, the Governor of the Imo State in Nigeria, Mr Owelle Okorocha, conferred an Imo Merit Award on him.

Minister Lynne Brown's partner scored R1.2 million contracts with Eskom

Minister Lynne Brown's partner scored R1.2 million contracts with Eskom

Sikonathi Mantshantsha says this revelation explains why Brown was reluctant to take any action against Eskom executives.

KZN school ordered to stop action against students with EFF shirts

KZN school ordered to stop action against students with EFF shirts

A letter has been addressed to the Maritzburg College principal after an image of the boys went viral last week.

Kloof Street residents living in fear as crime multiplies

Kloof Street residents living in fear as crime multiplies

A Cape Town man was stabbed to death on Saturday while trying to assist two women who were being mugged on Kloof street.

‘I started my thriving business with R5000 (and made a profit in the 1st month)’

‘I started my thriving business with R5000 (and made a profit in the 1st month)’

After 3 years there are 3 Nic Harry stores (incl online) that sell 100 000 pairs of socks in over 20 countries around the world.