#SecretBallot call could be Baleka Mbete's toughest political decision

Last week the Constitutional Court affirmed Mbete's legal authority to decide on whether to hold a secret ballot or not in the vote of no-confidence against President Jacob Zuma.

Political analysts, Prince Mashele and Ebrahim Fakir interrogate which decision National Speaker, Baleka Mbete should take.

Placing himself in Mbete's position, Mashele says he would exercise his discretion by calling for a secret vote. Mashele suggests that opting for a secret vote, Mbete stands to redeem her character and reputation. He says if she chooses an open vote, Mbete risks going down in history as someone who doesn't hold the interests of South Africans at heart.

Fakir strongly disagrees with Mashele.

Everything Prince says ought to be done and can be done with an open ballot. There is nothing precluding in an open ballot for any MP whether of the governing party or otherwise from exercising their discretion firstly.

Ebrahim Fakir, political analyst

Also read: #SecretBallot: There are two necessary evils, choose the lesser evil - Matshiqi

Secondly, stating their discretion on their conscience. That is not precluded by an open ballot. What Prince is alluding to a fear of reprisal or the fear of consequences for people who are within the ANC to be able to vote openly.

Ebrahim Fakir, political analyst

Fakir explains that if members of the African National Congress (ANC) are fearful of their views opposing those their fellow party members then they should remove themselves from the party.

If any ANC members want President Zuma removed from the helm, then they should say and in this case, vote so, openly, he adds.

The way our Parliament works contradicts the values that are embodied in the Constitution.

Prince Mashele, Political analysts

Ebrahim Fakir is currently Manager of Governance Institutions and Processes at the Electoral Institute for the Sustainability of Democracy in Africa (EISA). Prince Mashele is a South African political research expert and analyst.

Listen to full analysis in the clip below:


This article first appeared on 702 : #SecretBallot call could be Baleka Mbete's toughest political decision


CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
"If the ANC splits now it will not come into power in 2019"

"If the ANC splits now it will not come into power in 2019"

Political analyst Lukhona Mnguni takes a look at the big ANC provincial meetings that took place ahead of the national conference.

ANC policy conference can be seen as proxy for Dec elective conference - analyst

ANC policy conference can be seen as proxy for Dec elective conference - analyst

Political analysts Lukhona Mnguni and Sthembile Mbete reflected on the ANC succession battle and the upcoming policy conference.

News quiz crossword 19 June answers

News quiz crossword 19 June answers

Answers for the 19 June news crossword

The Constitution is safe with Mogoeng - Judith February

The Constitution is safe with Mogoeng - Judith February

Judith February shares her thoughts on the #SecretBallot ruling and how Zuma is "trite" with real concerns from citizens.

[LISTEN] Lekota says concerns of coercion should help Mbete make a decision

[LISTEN] Lekota says concerns of coercion should help Mbete make a decision

Cope leader adds his voice to the debate over a secret ballot in a proposed motion of no confidence in President Jacob Zuma.

#SecretBallot: There are two necessary evils, choose the lesser evil - Matshiqi

#SecretBallot: There are two necessary evils, choose the lesser evil - Matshiqi

Critics aren't convinced that Parliamentary Speaker Baleka Mbete will not allow a secret ballot, but what is the right decision?

Mbete unlikely to opt for secret ballot - Richard Calland

Mbete unlikely to opt for secret ballot - Richard Calland

An open vote would likely be taken on review and delay process beyond December ANC elective conference, making the judgment moot.

EFF will go back to court if Mbete makes irrational decision on secret ballot

EFF will go back to court if Mbete makes irrational decision on secret ballot

EFF spokesperson Mbuyiseni Ndlozi says opposition parties will not accept an open ballot without strong justification from Mbete.

"ConCourt hinted strongly that a secret ballot would be the wisest decision"

"ConCourt hinted strongly that a secret ballot would be the wisest decision"

Constitutional law expert Pierre de Vos analyses the ConCourt ruling that Parliamentary Speaker Mbete can hold a secret ballot.

Holomisa: ANC mistaken, it did not win secret ballot ruling

Holomisa: ANC mistaken, it did not win secret ballot ruling

UDM leader Bantu Holomisa says that Baleka Mbete's arrogance and blind loyalty to the ANC and Zuma has put them in this mess.

Popular articles
[LISTEN] 'We are dealing with an outbreak of Listeriosis' - Dr Thomas

[LISTEN] 'We are dealing with an outbreak of Listeriosis' - Dr Thomas

Head of the Centre for Enteric Diseases at the NICD Dr Thomas says that Listeriosis is problematic because it isn’t notifiable.

Publisher saves South African students billions with free textbooks

Publisher saves South African students billions with free textbooks

This year we're going to hit a million downloads of free textbooks in SA - James van der Westhuizen, country manager for Bookboon.

Steinhoff money woes and why you should care

Steinhoff money woes and why you should care

The company lost around R100 billion leaving the JSE reeling in one of the biggest private sector business scandals.

Few retirement funds unaffected by Steinhoff implosion (i.e. you just got had)

Few retirement funds unaffected by Steinhoff implosion (i.e. you just got had)

Your money, and Steinhoff… Bruce Whitfield interviews Certified Financial Planner Peter Calitz.

‘There were clear warning signs at Steinhoff. All of which fund managers missed’

‘There were clear warning signs at Steinhoff. All of which fund managers missed’

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Sygnia Group CEO Magda Wierzycka.

Zille: 40 000 affordable housing units in the pipeline for WC

Zille: 40 000 affordable housing units in the pipeline for WC

Western Cape Premier Helen Zille says the government plays a crucial role in the provision of affordable housing in the province.

How businessman Max Lichaba struck gold with his jewellery company

How businessman Max Lichaba struck gold with his jewellery company

Entrepreneur Max Lichaba built his own empire and is the CEO of Lichaba Creations and several other businesses. This is his story.