Business Unusual

Half this article will no longer be true in the future

You know smoking is harmful to your health, you understand that vaccines are good and you are not aware of negative impacts from mobile phone radiation.

At least, I hope so. While there is no dispute about smoking anymore, it was contested in the past and originally it was thought smoking had medical benefits.

Likewise, vaccines are safe and necessary, but some still hold out that they might not be.

Mobile phones were once feared and are still a source of concern for some. In time it will be shown either to be completely safe or there will be clarity about under what circumstances there are indeed risks with certain levels of exposure.

The above is an illustration of the process by which we come to know things.

How we discover new facts and discredit old ones

Luck was the principal form once upon a time; eventually we began examining the things we knew we did not know. After even more time this was refined to become the scientific method.

You begin with something you have observed or strongly believe. You then consider the circumstances that would explain it - your hypothesis. You then devise a series of tests that would support or discredit your hypothesis. The data from the tests would leave you with evidence with which you formulate a theory to explain your observation. That theory needs to be tested by others to see if the results match. Repeated tests with the same results by many different people adds credibility to your theory which in time will be accepted as the best explanation for a given observation. It does not make it an undisputable fact, just the best and most appropriate proxy for a fact we have. This, at least, is a simple explanation of it - a fuller understanding of it will help you significantly with what lies ahead.

I can’t comment about other languages, but English uses fact as a synonym for truth and truth is not supposed to change.

However, English is not subject to the scientific method and so our language itself leads us to regard things that are highly probable as an absolute truth, which sometimes is not true.

This is made even more complex with our relationship with religion. Generally, a central strength of religion is its surety and steadfastness, things don’t change much in religion and it does not welcome being challenged.

The Information Age

Yet, we live in an information society. A phrase popularised in the 60s when an economist Fritz Machlup began looking at knowledge as an economic resource. Like any resource it is produced, output is measured and a price is associated with quality and volume.

But knowledge production does not allow for you to declare the same “fact” everyday. It must be new, it must advance our understanding and in so doing relegate or make previous knowledge obsolete.

It is not a smooth process and we don’t know which theories will remain true. What is known is that over a given period a certain percentage will no longer be true.

The field being studied, and how groundbreaking the observation is, will determine the period of time when half of the known information will no longer be considered true.

This the half-life of knowledge and was the title of Machlup’s book on the subject.

The half-life of facts

Since then studies have looked at different industries and calculated the half-life of the facts unique to then. The results are not comforting for those who religiously adhere to “known” facts.

In one respect, we are very happy to accept the constant and often rapid change. You know that you need to keep refreshing your knowledge about latest thinking and best practices for your profession, yet we assume nothing else should change outside of that.

If you work in manufacturing, you know better machines and processes will be developed, but when asked how many genders there are you might think it crazy that the answer is no longer just two.

How it affects everything

This presents some obvious and significant issues. Most industries have progressed to the point that knowledge production is now so high that half their practices and accepted facts are outdated in a decade.

It is fair to say that South Africa struggles to prepare young people for what they need to know now and that the prospect of them in effect never stopping learning is going to be a real challenge for many.

Likewise; for those who have spent a fair chunk of their careers with only gradual changes will find the body of knowledge that once was the envy of others is now a liability.

This is part of why the World Economic Forum is so concerned about the fourth industrial revolution which we are currently entering. The pace at which machines can develop new methods and practises will not only challenge us, we may be unable to keep pace.

Just a thought

Another factor that our belief in what we thought were facts, and unwillingness to accept that things change, relates to politics and the economy. So many debates are still grounded in political and economic theory that, thanks to technological advances, simply don’t apply anymore. Part of the support for a Brexit vote is a belief that economies can operate independently. The reality is closer to the model of a multi-national company with influence, dependence and value coming from many and often remote locations. This very diversity offers an opportunity to react to changes that otherwise may have put it out of business.

Countries are no longer singular blocks of similar people, but an ever changing mix of people arriving and leaving for many reasons.

US conservative politics is in part a reaction to the open, unsure and dependent nature of modern trade. Some US citizens no longer feel they are a world power and want to return to what they believed were American values. They no doubt were, and in many places still are, but enough has changed that it will never be the same again. Those unable or unwilling to change were swept up by the promise to somehow return the US to those times.

It is a little unfair to only use the UK or the US, the same applies to South Africa and all countries.

Don't get attached to facts, get attached to testing them.

Trying to replicate something from the past or even becoming the best version of the present without consideration for the internal and external factors that would or would not allow it will fail.

South Africa will change because everything does and a good indicator of how well we will manage that change will be our willingness to question our current practices and change the ones that are no longer valid. Even harder; embrace the reality of what an information society will need when navigating a global revolution we can no longer stop.

Sam Arbesman explains some well known examples to illustrate the half-life of facts.

Explore more about Samuel Arbesman

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Your camera could save the world

Your camera could save the world

A picture is no longer worth just a thousand words, it is how we will build the future and save the past.

What Artificial Intelligence (A.I.) is and what it isn't

What Artificial Intelligence (A.I.) is and what it isn't

There is much to gain and even more to lose which means we all need to learn more about AI.

Radio's past may ensure its future

Radio's past may ensure its future

All media has been disrupted by the web and mobile. What is the impact on radio?

This sport requires you to run, drive and fight all while remaining seated

This sport requires you to run, drive and fight all while remaining seated

eSports are more than just a game now and may even be an Olympic sport by 2024.

Great ideas, wrong time

Great ideas, wrong time

The iPhone, Ebay and Facebook, we all know these killer applications but what about their very similar predecessors that flopped.

The world of business is changing, here is what you need to know.

The world of business is changing, here is what you need to know.

Companies, institutions and principles, nothing is safe from the impact of the 4th industrial revolution.

Popular articles
83 SANDF vehicles gone up in smoke

83 SANDF vehicles gone up in smoke

Vehicles belonging to the SANDF were destroyed in a fire at a vehicle depot at Wallmannstal Pretoria last week.

Signs your child could be suffering from anxiety

Signs your child could be suffering from anxiety

Counselling psychologist Nikole Seele says it is important to differentiate between healthy anxiety and debilitating anxiety.

Taxi Strike Cape Town: Buses torched, mayhem on the roads

Taxi Strike Cape Town: Buses torched, mayhem on the roads

EWN Reporter Kevin Brandt gives the latest updates on the taxi strike as protestors prevented commuters using alternative means of transport.

Rotten apples and root of corruption at Eskom revealed

Rotten apples and root of corruption at Eskom revealed

Eusebius McKasier and investigative journalists dissect looting of Eskom and capturing of other state owned enterprises.

"Robben Island has struggled to manage its ferries properly"

"Robben Island has struggled to manage its ferries properly"

Tourism Spokesperson Beverly Shafer, says that the Robben Island ferry's have been a problem for years.

Taxi Strike: Golden arrow bus torched in Delft, several stoned

Taxi Strike: Golden arrow bus torched in Delft, several stoned

Bronwen Dyke, Golden Arrow spokesperson confirmed that one of their buses were set alight.

Taxi strike damaging to the Western Cape economy

Taxi strike damaging to the Western Cape economy

Unathi Henama, transport economist at Tshwane University of Technology breaks down the negative effects of the taxi strike.