"What we have here is a legal tool for people to hold schools to account"

Jacques Rousseau, Critical Thinking and Ethics lecturer at UCT welcomes the High Court ruling on Wednesday that schools cannot promote one religion or favour one over another.

The application was brought by the Organization for Religious Education and Democracy, known as Ogod, and was opposed by the Federation of Governing Bodies of South African Schools as well as other groups such as Afriforum.

Ogod argued that there is religious bias in South African public schools.

It could have gone further, but it is a good start.

Jacques Rousseau, Critical Thinking and Ethics, UCT

We do live in a deeply religious country, and I think that is what leads to this misconception - that secularism has to include anti-religion. And it does not have to be that at all....religions is rather a private matter.

Jacques Rousseau, Critical Thinking and Ethics, UCT

He argues that we do want to cherish. respect and teach the wonderful diversity of belief and culture - but without prescribing any one of them.

So there is certainly a place for education on religion, and religious culture and symbolism. It is a vitally important thing.

Jacques Rousseau, Critical Thinking and Ethics, UCT

Related article: It is not the school's task to instruct children on religion - Ogod

But what we don't want, says, is to take formative young minds and lead them down a particular path before they are able to think for themselves.

Rosseau explains that the Court ruling left in place school governing boards ability to dictate the nature of religious adherence so long as schools ensured and respected Section 52 of the Constitution - that they were free, equitable and voluntary.

Schools can no longer advertise itself as having a Christian character or having religious symbolism on uniforms.

Up until now, pupils have had the option to 'opt out' of religious practices within schools but he says that often came with judgement and peer pressure, he says.

What we have here is a legal tool for people to hold schools to account to be equitable and fair.

Jacques Rousseau, Critical Thinking and Ethics, UCT

But measuring what is equitable and fair is difficult, and in that sense Rosseau says it is a narrow ruling.

We might find schools justifying what they already do but dressing it up in a different way, he concludes.

Take a listen:


This article first appeared on 702 : "What we have here is a legal tool for people to hold schools to account"


CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Tough decisions ahead for Idols SA winner Paxton Fielies, says publicist

Tough decisions ahead for Idols SA winner Paxton Fielies, says publicist

Publicist and artist manager Martin Myers talks about what's ahead for Idols South Africa season 13 winner Paxton Fielies.

WATCH: Authors discuss tell-all book on how Jacob Zuma stole SA

WATCH: Authors discuss tell-all book on how Jacob Zuma stole SA

Investigative journos Adriaan Basson and Pieter du Toit on President Zuma's rule and how he's apparently wrecked SA institutions.

Mugabe expected to face impeachment bid on Tuesday

Mugabe expected to face impeachment bid on Tuesday

If Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe refuses to step down, impeachment proceedings will begin on Tuesday.

How to overcome your terror of flying

How to overcome your terror of flying

Former flying phobic, Damon Beard chats to John Maytham about his 'Flying Without Fear' course coming to Cape Town next week.

De Lille: Delayed 'Day Zero' due to bolstered water saving, additional sources

De Lille: Delayed 'Day Zero' due to bolstered water saving, additional sources

Cape Town Mayor Patricia De Lille says the City maintains its call for residents to use no more than 87 litres per person per day.

Delicious Syrah that won't break the bank? John Maytham's top 3  wine picks

Delicious Syrah that won't break the bank? John Maytham's top 3 wine picks

John Maytham's three wine picks of the week are brought to you by Picardi Rebel.

Popular articles
Financially prepare yourself before the wedding bells

Financially prepare yourself before the wedding bells

Liberty Legal Marketing Specialist, Faeeza Khan talk us through a few financial pointers before getting hitched.

Oscar's family unhappy with producers as movie makes SA debut this weekend

Oscar's family unhappy with producers as movie makes SA debut this weekend

The movie stars Joburg-born actor Andreas Damm as Pistorius and Victoria Secret model Toni Garrn as Reeva Steenkamp.

Statement to remove LLB programme from SA universities is misleading: Max Price

Statement to remove LLB programme from SA universities is misleading: Max Price

Max Price says Council on Higher Education's announcement that UKZN, UCT and UL could lose their LLB accreditation is not right.

Is taking items from the hotel room stealing?

Is taking items from the hotel room stealing?

Tsogo Sun Cape regional manager explains which items are free to be taken home by guests and why.

WATCH: Innovative spray limits toilet flushes and saves water

WATCH: Innovative spray limits toilet flushes and saves water

Loo Me is a simple yet effective scented foam that takes the yuck out of "mellowing" toilets preventing multiple flushes.