If Baleka Mbete called Pierre de Vos for advice on the no confidence vote

The motion of no confidence date is fast approaching. Members of Parliament are expected to decide through a vote whether or not to keep President Jacob Zuma in power.

Prof. Pierre de Vos, Constitutional Law Expert wrote:

The Speaker of the National Assembly (NA), Baleka Mbete, will soon have to decide whether the vote of no confidence in President Jacob Zuma is to be conducted through a secret ballot or an open ballot.

As the Constitutional Court noted “the Speaker has made it abundantly clear that she is not averse to a motion of no confidence in the President being decided upon by a secret ballot”. But she may have been lying to the court or she may, in the meantime, have changed her mind about granting a secret ballot.

Whatever she decides, the decision will be controversial. Which raises the question: what are the legal considerations she has to take into account to make a constitutionally valid decision?

The Constitutional Court did everything it could apart from ordering Baleka Mbete to hold a secret vote.

Prof. Pierre de Vos, Constitutional Law Expert

De Vos says a secret ballot depends on what constitutes the vote of no confidence. He adds if the vote is held to hold the President to account and if it is seen as a last resort, then a secret ballot is warranted.

If there are threats from the party side that will be very much in favour for a secret ballot.

Prof. Pierre de Vos, Constitutional Law Expert

De Vos says it would be unwise for Mbete to call for an open ballot.

He adds that the big test, however, will involve the Speaker presenting rational and plausible reasons to back up her decision for an open vote, then the courts are less likely to intervene.

Listen to the interview in the clip below:


This article first appeared on 702 : If Baleka Mbete called Pierre de Vos for advice on the no confidence vote


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
NEC decision to back Zuma 'ill-advised', says ANC MP Mondli Gungubele

NEC decision to back Zuma 'ill-advised', says ANC MP Mondli Gungubele

Former Ekurhuleni mayor Mondli Gungubele is part of a growing number of ANC MPs who have publicly called for Zuma to go.

DA will call for early election if Zuma loses motion of no confidence

DA will call for early election if Zuma loses motion of no confidence

Mmusi Maimane says for South Africa to survive, change is needed.

 Holomisa: secret ballot protects ANC MPs amid threats and political violence

Holomisa: secret ballot protects ANC MPs amid threats and political violence

If Speaker Baleka Mbete objects to the secret ballot, UDM's Holomisa says parties may take her decision under judicial review.

Submissions for a secret ballot have been made, parties now wait on Mbete

Submissions for a secret ballot have been made, parties now wait on Mbete

Several parties had until the end of business on Friday, 14 July, to submit their views on the preferred means of voting.

7 candidates in Presidential succession race, SACP preps for ANC split: analysis

7 candidates in Presidential succession race, SACP preps for ANC split: analysis

Karima Brown said 7 candidates are publicly vying for the position of ANC President.

Holomisa: Mbete's 'attack on judiciary' shows bias

Holomisa: Mbete's 'attack on judiciary' shows bias

The UDM leader says it's a conflict of interest for National Assembly Speaker Baleka Mbete to preside over the no confidence vote.

Mbete must recuse herself for Zuma no confidence vote, argue opposition parties

Mbete must recuse herself for Zuma no confidence vote, argue opposition parties

Opposition parties leaders believe that National Assembly Speaker Baleka Mbete is compromised after her comments on the judiciary.

Jeremy Cronin plans to hang up his deputy secretary hat after over 20 years

Jeremy Cronin plans to hang up his deputy secretary hat after over 20 years

Karima Brown provides political analysis on this and other news.

Mbete unlikely to allow secret ballot vote against Zuma, says SACP's Cronin

Mbete unlikely to allow secret ballot vote against Zuma, says SACP's Cronin

Jeremy Cronin suspects Baleka Mbete will opt for an open ballot, which may result in further court action by opposition parties.

ANC MP Makhosi Khoza's claims of intimidation

ANC MP Makhosi Khoza's claims of intimidation

Khoza says no one within the ANC has condemned the threats she has received except chief whip Jackson Mthembu.

Popular articles
'Love your vulva the way it is' - Designer vaginas are dangerous, warns Dr Eve

'Love your vulva the way it is' - Designer vaginas are dangerous, warns Dr Eve

So-called 'designer vaginas' are created through various surgical or non-surgical procedures, explains clinical sexologist Dr Eve.

'Cyril is the most popular president since Nelson Mandela'

'Cyril is the most popular president since Nelson Mandela'

Author Max de Preez weighs in on where SA would be if Jacob Zuma was still president and the impact of Ramaphosa now.

Kirstenbosch curator's widow thanks hospital's 'unsung heroes'

Kirstenbosch curator's widow thanks hospital's 'unsung heroes'

Kirstenbosch National Botanical Gardens curator Phillip Le Roux died on Wednesday after a horrific cycling accident.

Here is what to do if you're affected by driving licence backlog

Here is what to do if you're affected by driving licence backlog

The WC Traffic Department has made provisions to cater for motorists affected by the backlog with the issuing of driving licences.

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Eskom has warned that more power cuts can be expected as maintenance continues over the next twelve months.

[LISTEN] Meet your 2018 Idols SA winner... Yanga Sobetwa!

[LISTEN] Meet your 2018 Idols SA winner... Yanga Sobetwa!

17-year-old Yanga Sobetwa was recently crowned the winner of the 14th season of the reality singing competition.

[WATCH] Ellen Pakkies shares her own story as local film adaptation hits screens

[WATCH] Ellen Pakkies shares her own story as local film adaptation hits screens

Eleven years after murdering her drug addict son, the film about Ellen Pakkies' story is being shown at cinemas across SA.

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

These are the emergency numbers you should have on your cellphone and this is what you must understand about how they work.