Is ANC's dogmatic past coming back to haunt them asks former political prisoner

Paul Trewhela is a South African journalist, communist, and former political prisoner and chats to Koketso Sechane, standing-in for Eusebius McKaiser on CapeTalk and 702.

Roughly 60 years ago, the ANC took the radicle decision to confront an oppressive armed state with the armed struggle, says Trewhela.

He adds that the ANC was initially non-violent, but took the decision to confront the state with violence.

That was a colossal decision to take, and it was made entirely in association with the South African Communist Party.

Paul Trewhela, former SACP member and former political prisoner

Research has found that members who were convicted in the Rivonia Trails, including Nelson Mandela, were actually members of the SACP says Trewhela. He adds that the events that unfolded took the ANC away from the philosophy of its founders.

Trewhela says that the ANC’s structure was top-down:

There was no room for critical discussion essentially in the ANC in exile, and those who did have critical opinions or a different opinion on the way forward were oppressed.

Paul Trewhela, former SACP member and political prisoner

Fast forward to now, and the ANC still seems to be in the same predicament.

At the 702 Town Hall meeting, Karima Brown was in conversation with presidential hopeful Baleka Mbete to discuss the ways in which she plans to strengthen the country economy.

Mbete had no plan for the economy and even said that she will use state machinery, says Karima.

She’s coming in off the back of the same parties’ economic policies that have not resulted in the kind of jobs that we see, that has not resulted in more people being included in the economy.

Karima Brown, Veteran Journalist and Talk Radio 702 host

Brown adds that Mbete said very little and failed to outline, even in broad policy terms, how she plans to get a stagnant economy, with structural challenges up and running.

She spoke very briefly about her focus on agriculture as well as her focus on rural economies but with incredibly little detail.

Karima Brown, political analyst and 702 host

One can conclude that Mbete has not given the economy thought says Karima. She adds that we need to find out from these candidates how they're going to address matters that involve money, corruption, and the renewal of the ANC.

These characteristics are not my characteristics of the ANC. This is all to be found in the diagnostic report of the security general Gwede Mantashe which was tabled at the ANC’s policy conference.

Karima Brown, political analyst and 702 host

To hear more on the ANC past and present click on the audio below...

Listen to Karima talk about Mbete's brief statements at the 702 Town Hall Meeting here...


This article first appeared on 702 : Is ANC's dogmatic past coming back to haunt them asks former political prisoner


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Can't commit? Understanding commitment phobia and relationship anxiety

Can't commit? Understanding commitment phobia and relationship anxiety

Relationship anxiety is rooted in fear - fear of failure, fear of being inadequate, fear of rejection or of unmet expectations.

A 5-day working week could be a thing of the past for Britain as AI takes over

A 5-day working week could be a thing of the past for Britain as AI takes over

Tech guru Aki Anastasiou looks at a milestone for self-driving cars, the Blackberry Key 2 and how AI may reduce our work week.

Journos provide fresh insights into the latest on state capture inquiry

Journos provide fresh insights into the latest on state capture inquiry

Journalists Karyn Maughan and Erin Bates provide insights into the state capture inquiry.

Mbete says Zuma must finish term with dignity, refuses to be drawn on Fezeka

Mbete says Zuma must finish term with dignity, refuses to be drawn on Fezeka

National ANC chairperson Baleka Mbete said she didn't want to be "pressurised" to answer questions about Fezeka Kuzwayo.

Baleka Mbete: This is not a war

Baleka Mbete: This is not a war

Mbete is adamant that the ANC's elective conference will go ahead on 16 December and that the factions within the party are not a war.

Mbete in the hot seat on Karima Brown's Town Hall one-on-ones

Mbete in the hot seat on Karima Brown's Town Hall one-on-ones

Tune in for this ANC presidential candidate in conversation with Karima Brown on Monday night at 20h00.

Popular articles
Idols judge Unathi Nkayi gets intimate - opens up about money, beliefs about it

Idols judge Unathi Nkayi gets intimate - opens up about money, beliefs about it

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Nkayi about her attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

VBS gave Zuma R8.5m before any security was provided for loan - News 24 journo

VBS gave Zuma R8.5m before any security was provided for loan - News 24 journo

News 24 investigative journalist Kyle Cowan reports that Zuma was granted the loan despite the fact that he could not afford it.

Can't commit? Understanding commitment phobia and relationship anxiety

Can't commit? Understanding commitment phobia and relationship anxiety

Relationship anxiety is rooted in fear - fear of failure, fear of being inadequate, fear of rejection or of unmet expectations.

'All those responsible for Sunday Times "tainted scoops" should be accountable'

'All those responsible for Sunday Times "tainted scoops" should be accountable'

Sanef's Katy Katopodis says the Sunday Times saga has done great damage to our society, democracy and to journalism.

Let your nose decide if docci claims into perfume industry are true

Let your nose decide if docci claims into perfume industry are true

Claims have been made that the perfume industry don't want consumers to know the real cost of making these products.

Tito Mboweni, Pik Botha, VBS and Floyd Shivambu - no holds barred on The Debrief

Tito Mboweni, Pik Botha, VBS and Floyd Shivambu - no holds barred on The Debrief

Politician Lindiwe Mazibuko, economist Refilwe Moloto, and journalist Rose Rogers have discussed the biggest topics this week.

Snakes season is here and if the crawlies visit you, here's what to do

Snakes season is here and if the crawlies visit you, here's what to do

Snake handler Willem van Zyk of Blouberg Snake Rescue says he's already being kept busy with callouts.

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

These are the emergency numbers you should have on your cellphone and this is what you must understand about how they work.