Did Gigaba lie to South Africans about the #Guptas?

Following Tuesday's press briefing in which re-appointed Home Affairs minister Malusi Gigaba sought to clarify the status of members of the Gupta family, a local immigration attorney claims Gigaba made some 'fundamental errors'.

The minister confirmed that Ajay and his brother Atul Gupta are not South African citizens.

He claimed the Guptas chose to apply for naturalisation as a family and that all applications were rejected in 2014, due to some members not meeting the criteria.

He said they later appealed and the rejection was over turned, but they were never granted citizenship because they refused to denounce their Indian citizenship.

But Immigration attorney Gary Eisenberg has poked holes in the claims by Gigaba and the DG of Home Affairs Mkuseli Apleni.

There is no appeal process in the South African Citizenship Act, it is not possible to appeal, it is only possible to re-apply a year after the first rejection.

Gary Eisenberg, Immigration Attorney and founder of Eisenberg and Associates

A photograph of what's purported to be Atul Kumar Gupta's passport is currently making the rounds on social media, but Gigaba has denied it is proof of the Guptas having South African citizenship.

The date of issue on the passport is 31 July 2015, which was during Gigaba's tenure as Minister of Home Affairs.

The public should understand the difference between a fabrication and the truth...

Gary Eisenberg, Immigration Attorney and founder of Eisenberg and Associates

We don't know, no matter how many utterances the minister makes on the subject, whether he is confused, ill-informed or he is lying.

Gary Eisenberg, Immigration Attorney and founder of Eisenberg and Associates

Eisenberg has called for a commission of inquiry to investigate the matter, saying it is the only way the truth will be revealed.

To hear more of this conversation regarding the Guptas, listen below:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Lindiwe Sisulu 'surprised' that Gupta brothers are not SA citizens

Lindiwe Sisulu 'surprised' that Gupta brothers are not SA citizens

The International Relations and Cooperation minister says they were informed that the Gupta family were given citizenship.

Gigaba must explain why he is lying -  EFF MP Hlengiwe Mkhaliphi

Gigaba must explain why he is lying - EFF MP Hlengiwe Mkhaliphi

On Tuesday, Home Affairs Minister Malusi Gigaba pronounced that neither Ajay nor Atul Gupta is a South African citizen.

[LISTEN] Former Denel chairman is trying to get away, says Outa

[LISTEN] Former Denel chairman is trying to get away, says Outa

Daniel Mantsha was accused, by civil action group Outa, of trying to give the Guptas access to the country's defence technologies.

[LISTEN] 'This is not a service, it is an ATM card for the Guptas'

[LISTEN] 'This is not a service, it is an ATM card for the Guptas'

Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi conducted a walkabout at the Gupta linked Mediosa mobile clinic in the North West on Friday.

Lynne Brown is a liar - Sikonathi Mantshantsha

Lynne Brown is a liar - Sikonathi Mantshantsha

Deputy Editor at Financial Mail Sikonathi Mantshantsha says Lynne Brown did the right thing by resigning.

The Political Desk: Dudu Myeni a 'no-show' at state capture inquiry

The Political Desk: Dudu Myeni a 'no-show' at state capture inquiry

On Wednesday Parliament resumed its inquiry into state capture at Eskom

Guptas launch urgent court bid to keep Bank of Baroda in SA

Guptas launch urgent court bid to keep Bank of Baroda in SA

Rob Rose, Financial Mail editor takes a look at the latest development in the Gupta saga.

EFF, DA and FF+  boycott Magashule's state of the province address

EFF, DA and FF+ boycott Magashule's state of the province address

There has been increased opposition to Ace Magashule's leadership in the Free State.

Can this man save the Guptas’ companies (and the jobs of thousands)?

Can this man save the Guptas’ companies (and the jobs of thousands)?

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Louis Klopper, a Senior Business Rescue Practitioner at Coronado Consulting Group.

'Land restitution failed because Government is the biggest owner of land'

'Land restitution failed because Government is the biggest owner of land'

Bruce Whitfield interviews Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba's advisor Chris Malikane and Business Leadership SA's Bonang Mohale.

Popular articles
'Basetsana Kumalo explained to me that this was the worst week of her life'

'Basetsana Kumalo explained to me that this was the worst week of her life'

Social Media Law Expert, Emma Sadleir, says the Randburg court has issued a protection order for the Kumalo's.

A third Metrorail train goes up in flames in less than a month

A third Metrorail train goes up in flames in less than a month

Regional manager, Richard Walker, says there's an indication of arson in all three incidents but the motive is still not clear.

'Cyril Ramaphosa is the weakest president of the ANC since 1994' - analyst

'Cyril Ramaphosa is the weakest president of the ANC since 1994' - analyst

Political analyst Prince Mashele talks about the ANC NEC meeting contradicting messages stemming from this.

Max du Preez opens up about money (and losing everything on Vrye Weekblad)

Max du Preez opens up about money (and losing everything on Vrye Weekblad)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews the famed and fearless journalist about his money history, hopes and beliefs.

2 best companies on the JSE to invest in now (by Nefg Fund Managers)

2 best companies on the JSE to invest in now (by Nefg Fund Managers)

Not sure which shares to buy? Bruce Whitfield interviews Gerbrand Smit, Chief Investment Officer at Nefg Fund Managers.

Malema under fire after 'Indians are racist' comment

Malema under fire after 'Indians are racist' comment

SA Institute of Race Relations media head Micheal Morris says politicians must be cautious of such divisive statements they make.

[WATCH] Eusebius Mckaiser: I call BS on Malema's racism targeting Indians

[WATCH] Eusebius Mckaiser: I call BS on Malema's racism targeting Indians

Show host Eusebius McKaiser says EFF's leader Julius Malema's comments on Indians are grossly unacceptable and irresponsible.

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Stage 1 load s​hedding has been declared nationally. The City of Cape Town has urged residents to take note of the schedules.

Man who dumped body of family dog in street demoted at top JHB law firm

Man who dumped body of family dog in street demoted at top JHB law firm

Media law guru Emma Sadleir warns employees online that there are many potential events that could bring a company into disrepute.