Sars Lawyer: Tom Moyane did not break the law
Sars commissioner Tom Moyane has come under fire for authorising a a R70-million VAT refund to a Gupta-linked company through a third party. He has been accused of money laundering.
Erick Smith, Legal Specialist at Sars says that under no circumstances was the law broken when making these payouts. READ: Fresh claims Tom Moyane fast-tracked fake R70m VAT payments to Gutpas
I can assure you that whilst there were different legal interpretations on the manner of which a VAT refund must be paid, I reinterate, the VAT refund was due and payable by law to the tax payer in this matter.Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist
There was absolutely no transgression of the law in the payment to the tax payer in this case.Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist
Smith says that Moyane's involvement in the payout is also within the bounds of the law, as he is the accountable office within Sars.
According to Smith, normally tax payers escalate their frustrations and concerns to the commissioner, but it is normally dealt with by the legal team.
As to the allegations of wrongdoing and evidence showing top officials warning that these payments would be highly irregular, Smith says that boils down to differences in legal interpretation.
And the issue of third party payments?
I can tell you quite openly that I was one of the legal specialists who had a different interpretation as to whether a taxpayer can be refunded to a third party bank account. Because of the Sars Act, in an attempt to prevent fraud and payments going to the wrong bank account - we had a view that we could not pay a refund to a particular account nominated by the taxpayer in this case.Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist
But there has been an earlier interpretation, by a very senior tax specialist within Sars which invoked another provisional act, which provides for anomalous circumstances. And in those circumstances, the commissioner, through his official, can use his discretion to deal with anomalies.Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist
Smith says this case had an usual set of circumstances. He adds that they money was due and they had to pay it. The only difficulties Sars faced was the interpretation regarding which account the money should be paid to, according to Smith.
In this case, the money was due and payable. It had been through a though audit process - so we had to pay the money.Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist
The Guptas were given no favour.Erick Smith, Sars Legal Specialist
Listen to the full report below:
This article first appeared on 702 : Sars Lawyer: Tom Moyane did not break the law
Darren Hele, CEO of Famous Brands, tells the Money Show how the food outlets in the franchise have navigated lockdown.Read More
UCook has launched a Food Fund with FoodForward South Africa, the Philippi Economic Development Initiative and Ladles of Love.Read More
Sophisticated scanners reveal what products shoppers are buying when they visit spaza shops.Read More
The cafes received essential service status continuing to provide Red Cross and Somerset hospital staff's coffee during lockdown.Read More
"You can't come inside to place and collect an order," says Yousri Hartley. "Your car, I cannot say that’s not your address!"Read More
Google services such as Gmail and YouTube don't work on Huawei devices, but there are workarounds, says Jan Vermeulen.Read More
South Africans may now travel abroad if they meet certain criteria, says Advocate Bongani Bongo (Home Affairs Committee).Read More
Labour lawyer Marleen Potgieter says employers are managing a crisis and must ensure sure the health and safety of employees.Read More
Nando's has said it does not make commercial sense to open all outlets for delivery only.Read More
The head of the National Blood Service is now part of a blood plasma donation programme.Read More
The SA Drug Policy Initiative says the prohibition of booze and cigarettes has had harmful health, social, economic, and criminal effects.Read More
We must now try and rescue what's left of the economy, says Democratic Alliance (DA) leader John Steenhuisen.Read More
Teffo says the board's decision will not pass the test of rationality in a court of law in South Africa if it were challenged.Read More
Is there something more to the cigarette ban, asks political analyst Sanusha Naidoo. Why cigarettes and not alcohol?Read More
National Health Director-General Dr Anban Pillay explains Lockdown level 3 which will be implemented from 1 June.Read More
The Presidency of the Republic of South Africa released these key points outlining the level 3 lockdown for the country from 1 June.Read More
President Cyril Ramaphosa announced in an address to the nation that SA will move down to Level 3 lockdown from 1 June.Read More
The President has delivered a lockdown update - listen to his explanation of the move to Level 3 from 1 June.Read More
A survey by teacher unions shows that 92% of SA's schools are not ready and safe to re-open says Natu's Cynthia Barnes.Read More
The president is set to address a nation anxiously awaiting a drop in the lockdown level, at 7pm on Sunday.Read More