'Things said in the 1800s are not appropriate to say today'

Lawyers for convicted racist Vicki Momberg have until Friday to submit supplementary papers explaining why she should be granted leave to appeal.

The court was not completely convinced on Wednesday by the arguments advanced by her lawyers as to why she should be allowed leave to appeal against are conviction and sentence.

John Maytham speaks to Professor of Sociology, University of the Witwatersrand Roger Southall about the differing views on whether racists should be jailed for speaking language which the majority of South Africans find offensive, in public. Some argue it gives those convicted, matyr status and drives racists underground - which could be more dangerous.

Southall says people need to recognise that the use of certain terms has changed in the way they are used over time.

Some things which were said in the 1800s are not appropriate to say in the 20th century.

Roger Southall, Professor of Sociology, University of the Witwatersrand

The way in which the black population today was referred to in the past by whites, as well as the way black people refer to themselves, has changed, he says.

The law is there to maintain people's dignity, he adds.

He added that with Vicki Momberg it was the number of times she used the word, that is why her sentence was so severe.

Listen further to this insightful interview:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Political Desk: 'EFF's destruction is at the hands of Malema'

Political Desk: 'EFF's destruction is at the hands of Malema'

Political analyst Professor Teffo talks about the continued fight for Nelson Mandela Bay, and critiques the EFF.

'It's very obvious that Steve Hofmeyr is a racist'

'It's very obvious that Steve Hofmeyr is a racist'

Former schoolmate of Steve Hofmeyr on a mission to have the singer barred from performing at WC school

'Barbie is pretending to be inclusive and diverse'

'Barbie is pretending to be inclusive and diverse'

Sunday Times columnist and editor Pearl Boshomane Tsotetsi discusses whether Barbie is 'woke or just pretending'.

Words have the power to harm - but does the punishment fit the crime?

Words have the power to harm - but does the punishment fit the crime?

Following the Momberg sentence, Eusebius McKaiser poses the question - Should people be jailed for what they say?

[CARTOON] Black Like Vicki?

[CARTOON] Black Like Vicki?

By Dr Jack & Curtis.

Momberg appears in court with cornrows, appeal hearing postponed

Momberg appears in court with cornrows, appeal hearing postponed

After a week in prison, convicted racist Vicki Momberg appeared in court with a new hairdo.

#WhatsTrending: A singing dog... and Trevor Noah's take on Vicki Momberg

#WhatsTrending: A singing dog... and Trevor Noah's take on Vicki Momberg

Khabazela shares videos and post trending on the internet.

Political Desk: Analyst discuss EFF motion of no confidence against Trollip

Political Desk: Analyst discuss EFF motion of no confidence against Trollip

Pundit discuss the reasons why two smaller parties are in support of Trollip.

Crime and punishment: Vicki Momberg's landmark sentence explained

Crime and punishment: Vicki Momberg's landmark sentence explained

Momberg is the first person in SA to be convicted and sentenced to jail on charges of crimen injuria.

Getting to grips with the legalities in the Vicki Momberg case

Getting to grips with the legalities in the Vicki Momberg case

Stephen Grootes speaks to Wits University associate professor, James Grant about the legal issues of the landmark Momberg case.

'White people should be at the forefront of fighting racism'

'White people should be at the forefront of fighting racism'

News24 editor Adriaan Basson says Momberg's jail sentence is a historic moment for South Africa.

Historic precedent set on racist language in Momberg sentencing

Historic precedent set on racist language in Momberg sentencing

Hopefully, people will learn that the use of the K-word is not meaningless in the context of South Africa says SAHRC spokesperson.

Vicki Momberg handed three years in jail for racist rant, one year suspended

Vicki Momberg handed three years in jail for racist rant, one year suspended

Momberg was found guilty on four counts of crimen injuria after a racist rant that was captured on video in Northriding in 2016.

[ALERT] Police use rubber bullets at EFF protest at H&M East Rand Mall

[ALERT] Police use rubber bullets at EFF protest at H&M East Rand Mall

H&M had used a black child to model a sweatshirt with the slogan "coolest monkey in the jungle".

Patriots for Equality says media has painted them as racists and it's "hogwash"

Patriots for Equality says media has painted them as racists and it's "hogwash"

Anthony Phillips William from Patriots for Equality in Klipspruit denies they were involved in burning of Putco bus.

If not wanting Zuma is racism then we are racists - Julius Malema

If not wanting Zuma is racism then we are racists - Julius Malema

The EFF leader joined other opposition parties and addressed crowds in a joint protest calling for the President to step down.

"I can't take responsibility for racists engaged in those kinds of tropes"

"I can't take responsibility for racists engaged in those kinds of tropes"

Zapiro says he agrees rape is the worst violation of a woman but says the country is being violated.

Popular articles
Ever wanted a 13-month year? Well, the Ethiopians have one

Ever wanted a 13-month year? Well, the Ethiopians have one

Ethiopia is one of the few countries using a calendar different from the conventional calendar most countries are accustomed to.

'Basetsana Kumalo explained to me that this was the worst week of her life'

'Basetsana Kumalo explained to me that this was the worst week of her life'

Social Media Law Expert, Emma Sadleir, says the Randburg court has issued a protection order for the Kumalo's.

'Cyril Ramaphosa is the weakest president of the ANC since 1994' - analyst

'Cyril Ramaphosa is the weakest president of the ANC since 1994' - analyst

Political analyst Prince Mashele talks about the ANC NEC meeting contradicting messages stemming from this.

Max du Preez opens up about money (and losing everything on Vrye Weekblad)

Max du Preez opens up about money (and losing everything on Vrye Weekblad)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews the famed and fearless journalist about his money history, hopes and beliefs.

Malema under fire after 'Indians are racist' comment

Malema under fire after 'Indians are racist' comment

SA Institute of Race Relations media head Micheal Morris says politicians must be cautious of such divisive statements they make.

[WATCH] Eusebius Mckaiser: I call BS on Malema's racism targeting Indians

[WATCH] Eusebius Mckaiser: I call BS on Malema's racism targeting Indians

Show host Eusebius McKaiser says EFF's leader Julius Malema's comments on Indians are grossly unacceptable and irresponsible.

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Stage 1 load s​hedding has been declared nationally. The City of Cape Town has urged residents to take note of the schedules.

Man who dumped body of family dog in street demoted at top JHB law firm

Man who dumped body of family dog in street demoted at top JHB law firm

Media law guru Emma Sadleir warns employees online that there are many potential events that could bring a company into disrepute.

Athletes to run 375km in solidarity against human trafficking

Athletes to run 375km in solidarity against human trafficking

The run takes place from 5 - 8 December along the N1 from Rawsonville to Beaufort West - a hunting ground for child traffickers.