Prof says AfriForum farm murder stats misleading and genocide claims are false

Farm murders has been a highly contested issue and AfriForum have released statistics to support the fact that there is a war against white people.

But do these numbers tally?

The question being raised is whether there is indeed a war against white people in the way that AfriForum supporters have framed it?

Law professor at North West University, Elmien du Plessis, has argued that the lobby group's own numbers don't support claims of genocide against whites farmers in SA.

I am not saying the statistics are not true, but the expectation of it is problematic.

Elmien du Plessis, associate law professor North West University

She explains that she deplores any kind of murder, acknowledges the grief people suffer when losing family and friends and they should be condemned.

But in her tweets she questioned whether there is really a concerted attack on white people.

READ: 'More black farm workers are killed than white farm workers' - Johan Burger

And I used AfriForum's own statistics for a very specific purpose... and I hope it highlights the problem and opens the debate so we can speak about these things.

Elmien du Plessis, associate law professor North West University

She explains that to calculate a statistic, a nominator, in this case the number of murders - and a denominator, the pool of people used to calculate per 100 000, are used - but how you determine the denominator will influence the statistical outcome greatly.

AfriForum use the figure of 74 farm murders which is then divided by a denominator. But Du Plessis says the choice of denominator they use is problematic.

If you use 32 000 it is very high, but that is just commercial farmers and it does not include their families, it does not include the small holdings, it does not include farm workers. If you include all the people in the rural area you get to a number of 800 000 and that will change the rate.

Elmien du Plessis, associate law professor North West University

One rate that AfriForum uses is 158 murders per 100 000 people. Our national average is 34.

So they may say you are five times more likely to get murdered if you are a farmer. And it is not clear how they got to that number.

Elmien du Plessis, associate law professor North West University

Du Plessis has been threatened for her views. She says while the AfriForum leadership might not want to harm her, the statements it has made could illicit such a response from its following. After her critical response to to the statistics, she says she received a number of threatening emails and phone calls.

Take a listen to how Du Plessis critiques AfriForum's calculations of farm murders in SA:


This article first appeared on 702 : Prof says AfriForum farm murder stats misleading and genocide claims are false


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI

CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
Insights into the 'Solutionist Thinking with RMB'

Insights into the 'Solutionist Thinking with RMB'

The Money Show host Bruce Whitfield explains the concept behind ' Solutionist Thinking with RMB'.

Callers ask what will happen to Ashwin Willemse after MultiChoice findings

Callers ask what will happen to Ashwin Willemse after MultiChoice findings

On Tuesday SuperSport and Multichoice's said there was no evidence of racism following an investigation into the incident in May.

[WATCH] Always check facts, we can't afford to make mistakes as journalists

[WATCH] Always check facts, we can't afford to make mistakes as journalists

Breakfast show host Bongani Bingwa shares his thoughts on the state of journalism & fact-checking in the era of social media.

'Under Zuma, intelligence became a hand-tool for a specific political party'

'Under Zuma, intelligence became a hand-tool for a specific political party'

Founder & Managing Director of specialised risk consultancy Thabiti talks on state intelligence in SA.

'No excuse for journalists failing to check facts'

'No excuse for journalists failing to check facts'

Head of TRI Facts at Africa Check Nechama Brodie speaks of the importance of checking facts when writing stories.

'Liberty Holdings would be in more hot water if the POPI Act was in full effect'

'Liberty Holdings would be in more hot water if the POPI Act was in full effect'

SA Information Regulator chair Pansy Tlakula says when finalised, the POPI Act would enable them to investigate the data breach.

Popular articles
'Basetsana Kumalo explained to me that this was the worst week of her life'

'Basetsana Kumalo explained to me that this was the worst week of her life'

Social Media Law Expert, Emma Sadleir, says the Randburg court has issued a protection order for the Kumalo's.

A third Metrorail train goes up in flames in less than a month

A third Metrorail train goes up in flames in less than a month

Regional manager, Richard Walker, says there's an indication of arson in all three incidents but the motive is still not clear.

'Cyril Ramaphosa is the weakest president of the ANC since 1994' - analyst

'Cyril Ramaphosa is the weakest president of the ANC since 1994' - analyst

Political analyst Prince Mashele talks about the ANC NEC meeting contradicting messages stemming from this.

Max du Preez opens up about money (and losing everything on Vrye Weekblad)

Max du Preez opens up about money (and losing everything on Vrye Weekblad)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews the famed and fearless journalist about his money history, hopes and beliefs.

2 best companies on the JSE to invest in now (by Nefg Fund Managers)

2 best companies on the JSE to invest in now (by Nefg Fund Managers)

Not sure which shares to buy? Bruce Whitfield interviews Gerbrand Smit, Chief Investment Officer at Nefg Fund Managers.

Malema under fire after 'Indians are racist' comment

Malema under fire after 'Indians are racist' comment

SA Institute of Race Relations media head Micheal Morris says politicians must be cautious of such divisive statements they make.

[WATCH] Eusebius Mckaiser: I call BS on Malema's racism targeting Indians

[WATCH] Eusebius Mckaiser: I call BS on Malema's racism targeting Indians

Show host Eusebius McKaiser says EFF's leader Julius Malema's comments on Indians are grossly unacceptable and irresponsible.

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Stage 1 load s​hedding has been declared nationally. The City of Cape Town has urged residents to take note of the schedules.

Man who dumped body of family dog in street demoted at top JHB law firm

Man who dumped body of family dog in street demoted at top JHB law firm

Media law guru Emma Sadleir warns employees online that there are many potential events that could bring a company into disrepute.