Why the definition of unfair labour practice is very blurry

The legal definition of "unfairness" (or lack thereof) complicates workplace dynamics.

Expert labour law consultant Ivan Israelstam says that the meaning of unfair as a legal term is problematic.

The Labour Relations Act uses the term unfair instead of the concept of illegality, Israelstam explains.

Ruling on unfair dismissal or unfair labour practice becomes a difficult job for judges and arbitrators because of the subjective nature of unfairness, he adds.

Read: What is constructive dismissal? (and how to prove it)

The way to determine what is unfair in labour law is by referring to precedent set by case law and previous rulings.

According to Israelstam, if the act of an employer cannot be justified on its own merits, then it will generally be seen as unfair.

Read also: Dismissal isn't the default outcome of disciplinary action, a lawyer advises

Rational justification is needed when defending decisions made during arbitration on unfair labour practices.

It's a very problematic concept.

Ivan Israelstam, CEO of Labour Law Management Consulting

The word illegal is an objective word. Unfair is a subjective word.

Ivan Israelstam, CEO of Labour Law Management Consulting

There isn't an attempt to define unfair in the The Labour Relations Act.

Ivan Israelstam, CEO of Labour Law Management Consulting

One has to glean the meaning [of unfair] by looking at the at the pattern of decisions that have been made over the decades by the court.

Ivan Israelstam, CEO of Labour Law Management Consulting

Israelstam shared his expert advice and helped callers with their questions and cases.

Take a listen to the informative discussion during the World of Work feature:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Dismissal isn't the default outcome of disciplinary action, a lawyer advises

Dismissal isn't the default outcome of disciplinary action, a lawyer advises

The outcome of disciplinary action will depend on if the trust relationship between two parties has broken down, an expert shares.

Stories about horrible bosses (and how to handle workplace bullying)

Stories about horrible bosses (and how to handle workplace bullying)

Tales of workplace bullying: from wrongful misconduct charges, to being targeted over of body weight, and dismissal via WhatsApp.

The difference between insubordination and insolence (and which gets you fired)

The difference between insubordination and insolence (and which gets you fired)

Labour law specialist Melanie Hart explores insubordinate and insolent behaviour in the workplace, and the consequences thereof.

Pros and cons of refusing to submit your old payslip to your potential employer

Pros and cons of refusing to submit your old payslip to your potential employer

Labour Law specialist Puke Maserumule talks about why employers request payslips before making a salary offer.

What is constructive dismissal? (and how to prove it)

What is constructive dismissal? (and how to prove it)

Employers and employees get confused about what constitutes a constructive dismissal. Labour lawyer Natasha Moni dives in deep.

Tips on how to ensure that your career is on the right track

Tips on how to ensure that your career is on the right track

Career pathing requires people to take an honest look at their career goals, skills, knowledge, experience, and personal traits.

CV advice to help you land your next job

CV advice to help you land your next job

Talent strategist and leadership consultant Anja van Beek says a CV should be seen as part of your personal branding.

Popular articles
[LISTEN] DA MP Glynnis Breytenbach withdraws her candidacy for NDPP post

[LISTEN] DA MP Glynnis Breytenbach withdraws her candidacy for NDPP post

Breytenbach was one of 12 candidates shortlisted for the position.

'I felt racially profiled at Wellness Warehouse'

'I felt racially profiled at Wellness Warehouse'

Efua Prah shares how she felt she was racially profiled while shopping, a problem she says exists in many Cape Town outlets.

Amnesty International strips Myanmar leader of top honour once awarded to Madiba

Amnesty International strips Myanmar leader of top honour once awarded to Madiba

The global human rights organisation revoked the Ambassador of Conscience Award it gave Aung San Suu Kyi in 2009.

Water restrictions see 17 municipal pools across CT open from December

Water restrictions see 17 municipal pools across CT open from December

The City of Cape Town's JP Smith says four of the existing municipal pools will be converted into salt water pools.

Ever wondered why university vice-chancellors earn millions. Here's why

Ever wondered why university vice-chancellors earn millions. Here's why

CEO of Universities SA, Professor Ahmed Bawa explains why university vice-chancellors earn a lot of money while students struggle.