5 key lessons after a dealership paid a CT woman for her dud car - five years on

A Cape Town woman has received an undisclosed settlement amount from a car dealership, after she was sold a faulty vehicle five years ago.

Brodie bought a brand new double cab bakkie in 2013 to use for her business, but soon discovered that the vehicle was faulty.

Within a few days, she noticed a knocking noise coming from under the vehicle and noted that it also had a faulty electric window.

Brodie complained to the dealership and distributor of the vehicle for two years before they finally admitted something was wrong with the car.

Read: Car deal extras - what they can and can’t add to your finance contract

In 2015, the foreman at the dealership acknowledged serious problems with brakes and steering. The brake pads were fitted incorrectly at an earlier service.

In February 2016, the bakkie went in for 75 000km service, but the brakes and steering failed 10 minutes after collecting the vehicle from the warranty repair.

Also read: Why it's not easy getting a refund or replacement after buying a dud car

We hopped on the N1 and we started losing breaks and started losing steering. It was very scary.

Brodie

It said on the windscreen "Wrong brake master cylinder supplied." They had acuatully put the wrong parts into our vehicle, that's why it wasn't fixed. They hadn't shared that.

Brodie

After having no luck with the regional service manager, she went to Motor Industry Ombud to open a case.

The matter was further escalated to National Consumer Commission where she was told she didn't have a case.

Brodie took her appeal to the National Consumer Tribunal in June 2017.

The dealership offered to settle one day before the case was due to be heard on 21 May 2018. She accepted.

Read more: Commission to charge dodgy CT car salesman after failing to reimburse customer

While Brodie has been able to buy herself a new car since, not everyone is victorious in such cases.

Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler discuses the lessons that can be learned from this case and shares her expert advice.

1. be patient and don't give up on your case
2. keep a paper trail and all record of your complaints
3. follow procedure and exhaust all avenues with the dealership and distributor before going to the Motor Industry Ombud
4. know your rights and let the dealershipknow that you are aware of your rights (check section 54-56 of Consumer Protection Act)
5. if possible, limit the vehicle usage because if you do return it for a refund you will be charged

She explains that if a vehicle fault involves a safety critical component, then the Motor Industry Ombud recommends that the vehicle be returned.

When it's a safety critical issue, the dealership gets one chance to fix it then then must take the vehicle back. That's how its supposed to work. It's dangerous.

Wendy Knowler, consumer journalist

Visit our Consumer Talk feature for more consumer-related stories.

Take a listen to the discussion during Consumer Talk:

Got a consumer case you need help resolving?

Email: consumer@knowler.co.za, put Cape Talk in the subject line, followed by the issue e.g. cellphone contract dispute


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Tributes pour in for 'approachable but private' design icon Carrol Boyes

Tributes pour in for 'approachable but private' design icon Carrol Boyes

The designer and businesswoman passed away on Wednesday night following a brief illness, her company confirmed.

Local sisters celebrate and preserve coloured identity

Local sisters celebrate and preserve coloured identity

Deidre MacKenna and Delmary Delport celebrate coloured identity and heritage using their brand Hello Coloured Life as a platform.

Car deal extras - what they can and can’t add to your finance contract

Car deal extras - what they can and can’t add to your finance contract

ConsumerTalk's Wendy Knowler lists what charges are allowed to be added...and what may not.

Why it's not easy getting a refund or replacement after buying a dud car

Why it's not easy getting a refund or replacement after buying a dud car

Motor Industry Ombud Johan Van Vreden says the component of the car must first be replaced if it's defective, not the whole car.

Car deal extras - what they can and can’t add to your finance contract

Car deal extras - what they can and can’t add to your finance contract

Know your rights. Consumer watchdog Wendy Knowler shares empowering information about car dealerships and their financing deals.

Commission to charge dodgy CT car salesman after failing to reimburse customer

Commission to charge dodgy CT car salesman after failing to reimburse customer

The dealership owner faces court action after failing to pay back the money for a used VW Passat which broke down after five days.

Popular articles
Impact of new debt-relief bill will be 'severe'

Impact of new debt-relief bill will be 'severe'

The National Credit Amendment Bill aims to help indebted consumers earning less that R7,500 per month, restructure their debt.

Ramaphosa seems to be clueless now - Sikonathi Mantshantsha

Ramaphosa seems to be clueless now - Sikonathi Mantshantsha

Daily Maverick's Mantshantsha says the country has been waiting a long time for the economy to be turned around.

Clamp down on unregistered 'security guards' near Woodstock's Old Biscuit Mill

Clamp down on unregistered 'security guards' near Woodstock's Old Biscuit Mill

Joint law enforcement operation after visitors in Cape Town complained of being coerced into paying R50 to park on the street.

[WATCH] 'I'm not trying to justify what she did,' Zephany Nurse in her own words

[WATCH] 'I'm not trying to justify what she did,' Zephany Nurse in her own words

Stolen from her mother's bedside as a newborn 22 years ago, Zephany or Miché Solomon as she is now known, tells her story.

Tributes pour in for 'approachable but private' design icon Carrol Boyes

Tributes pour in for 'approachable but private' design icon Carrol Boyes

The designer and businesswoman passed away on Wednesday night following a brief illness, her company confirmed.

[WATCH] Woman stealing back her stolen car has social media talking

[WATCH] Woman stealing back her stolen car has social media talking

Khabazela shares tweets and Facebook posts that have gone viral.

Freedom Bakery faces heat over food fraud allegations

Freedom Bakery faces heat over food fraud allegations

It's alleged the Cape Town-based bakery is passing of its products as ‘sugar-free’ and ‘gluten-free’ - when in fact they are not.