Does SA have the right mechanisms for political accountability? A debate

Do you think there are enough accountability mechanisms built into our democratic processes?

Do we have a culture of accountability in our main political parties, the state and in general politics?

Eusebius McKaiser engaged senior researcher and analyst AngeloFick, political analyst Dr Sithembile Mbete and Pari Research Manager and interim executive director Dr Mbongiseni Buthelezi about the state of accountability in SA politics.

Minister of Finance Nhlanhla Nene has found himself in a dilemma after he apologised for meeting with the controversial Gupta family.

Opposition parties have asked President Ramaphosa to show Nene the door.

The panel on the Eusebius McKaiser started off by dissecting the apology by the minister.

I don't think redemption should have a role in politics.

Angelo Fick, Senior Researcher and Analyst

Trust and credibility are incredibly important for whoever occupies the position of finance minister to do his job effectively. If these are the facts that were deliberately concealed from the President when he made the appointment then that is also concerning.

Dr Sithembile Mbete, Political analyst

READ: If Nhlanhla Nene survives this then the Pope is not Catholic - political analyst

I think we can talk about forgiveness once he has resigned. He can be forgiven but that does not mean he must stay in his position. It is necessary that we know more.

Dr Mbongiseni Buthelezi, Pari Research Manager and interim executive Director

ALSO READ: Should Nene go? Here's what SA's political heavyweights have to say

Moving on to accountability, Dr Buthelezi says we have seen how politicians bend backward and forward trying to protect one another.

What we are seeing in South Africa is a very low level of accountability.

Dr Mbongiseni Buthelezi, Pari Research Manager and interim executive Director

People who preach revolution are usually practicing accommodation. The revolution we have had in South Africa has been an accommodation to the existing system. If our MPs are members of the provincial or city legislatures, actually lived amongst the poorest and have their children sent to public schools, used public schools etc, we would have a different kind of South Africa at the moment.

Angelo Fick, Senior Researcher and Analyst

But because our politicians live in separate spaces from the majority who are poor, what we have is accountability entirely imagined inside the institutions.

Angelo Fick, Senior Researcher and Analyst

They should not be earning more than what we earn. A Member of Parliament should not be earning more than a nurse or a school teacher. The president should not earn more than a school principal because the incentive for becoming that kind of a public servant should not be under R1.2 million that they currently earn.

Angelo Fick, Senior Researcher and Analyst

Listen to the full discussion below and what callers had to say...


This article first appeared on 702 : Does SA have the right mechanisms for political accountability? A debate


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
[LISTEN] How dire is the state of public schools in the country?

[LISTEN] How dire is the state of public schools in the country?

Equal Education head of research Hopolang Selebalo says KwaZulu-Natal, Eastern Cape and Limpopo schools still use pit latrines.

[LISTEN] 'Status anxiety' and its effects on young people

[LISTEN] 'Status anxiety' and its effects on young people

Psychologist on individual couple and family therapy Tamara Sosa unpacks the anxieties attached to comparing yourself to others.

If Nhlanhla Nene survives this then the Pope is not Catholic - political analyst

If Nhlanhla Nene survives this then the Pope is not Catholic - political analyst

Rumour has it that Finance Minister Nhlanhla Nene has asked president Cyril Ramaphosa to relieve him of his duties.

'Social media users are not buying Nene's apology'

'Social media users are not buying Nene's apology'

Eyewitness News reporter Barry Bateman shares the latest on the Finance Minister's state capture inquiry testimony.

Is it time to remove Nhlanhla Nene from the good guy's list?

Is it time to remove Nhlanhla Nene from the good guy's list?

Political analyst Xolani Dube says Nene's apology is an admittance that he misled society and lied under oath.

 Nene credibility called into question over son's PIC involvement

Nene credibility called into question over son's PIC involvement

Sabelo Skiti says Nhlanhla Nene's son asked the PIC to fund a major investment, S&S Refineries.

Popular articles
W Cape govt plans 'disruptive' gang violence solution as youth death toll rises

W Cape govt plans 'disruptive' gang violence solution as youth death toll rises

Community Safety MEC Albert Fritz says over 2000 young people have died in gang-related violence since November last year.

'I want Catzavelos to recognise that he is a racist,' says Eusebius

'I want Catzavelos to recognise that he is a racist,' says Eusebius

McKaiser contrasts Adam's apology with that of Angelo Agrizzi at the state capture commission.

Mango responds to passenger irked after losing Rolex watch on flight

Mango responds to passenger irked after losing Rolex watch on flight

The airline says it takes limited responsibility for any valuables left in bags.

Jeremy Mansfield gets real about his money and beliefs about it

Jeremy Mansfield gets real about his money and beliefs about it

Bruce Whitfield interviews Jeremy Mansfield about his attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.).

[WATCH] Local six-year-old dancing sensation's video goes viral

[WATCH] Local six-year-old dancing sensation's video goes viral

After Will Smith and Jada Pinkett-Smith shared the video of Ivanah Campbell dancing it has been viewed over 10 million times.

Pocket money: From what age? How often? How much?

Pocket money: From what age? How often? How much?

Certified financial planner Kirsty Scully shares her advice on teaching children about the value of money.