Proposal to use bail system to punish drunk drivers is 'laughable' - law prof

Wits Law Professor James Grant has dismissed a new proposal by the Road Traffic Management Corporation (RTMC) for harsher punishment against drunk drivers.

The RTMC wants motorists found driving under the influence be locked up for seven days before they can apply for bail.

Read: Drunk drivers could spend 7 days in jail before a bail hearing if law changes

The RTMC has written to the Justice Department asking for drunk driving to be reclassified in terms of the Criminal Procedure Act.

Justice Project South Africa (JPSA) says it's also opposed to the proposal.

It's frankly laughable.

James Gant, Wits law professor

It confuses the law and is out of touch.

James Gant, Wits law professor

It's not about the extent of punishment but about the certainty of punishment that operates on people's minds.

James Gant, Wits law professor

Listen to the conversation on The John Maytham Show:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Would you have spoken out if you were in Zuma's Cabinet, asks John Maytham?

Would you have spoken out if you were in Zuma's Cabinet, asks John Maytham?

John wonders if most people would have spoken out and ended their political careers. What would you have done?

Mboweni threatens war against South African editors

Mboweni threatens war against South African editors

The Finance Minister's late night tweets have come under the spotlight.

Joost van der Westhuizen's final will was his dying wish says lawyer

Joost van der Westhuizen's final will was his dying wish says lawyer

The will that Van der Westhuizen deposed in 2015 was, in fact, his last dying wish says lawyer Ulrich Roux.

[LISTEN] Bee farmer describes tens of thousands of bees dead in Constantia

[LISTEN] Bee farmer describes tens of thousands of bees dead in Constantia

Bee farmer Brendan appeals to other beekeepers to check their bees and collect samples if they have witnessed any deaths.

Drunk drivers could spend 7 days in jail before a bail hearing if law changes

Drunk drivers could spend 7 days in jail before a bail hearing if law changes

The Road Traffic Management Corporation wants driving under the influence moved from a schedule 2 to a schedule 5 or 6 offence.

DA accuses ANC of giving drunk drivers the go-ahead to claim from Rabs

DA accuses ANC of giving drunk drivers the go-ahead to claim from Rabs

The Bill for the Road Accident Benefit Scheme (Rabs) was tabled by the ANC to replace the Road Accident Fund but DA not happy.

Popular articles
Thandeka Gqubule prepared to fight EFF to the end

Thandeka Gqubule prepared to fight EFF to the end

SABC Journalist and part of the SABC 8 Thandeka Gqubule says she has not had any communication from the EFF.

Discovery Bank takes on Capitec Bank, TymeDigital (Patrice Motsepe), Bank Zero

Discovery Bank takes on Capitec Bank, TymeDigital (Patrice Motsepe), Bank Zero

South Africa has a brand-new bank! The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Adrian Gore, Discovery Group CEO.

[LISTEN] Bee farmer describes tens of thousands of bees dead in Constantia

[LISTEN] Bee farmer describes tens of thousands of bees dead in Constantia

Bee farmer Brendan appeals to other beekeepers to check their bees and collect samples if they have witnessed any deaths.

Heads to roll for N2 car spinning frenzy

Heads to roll for N2 car spinning frenzy

WC Traffic Chief says there was no authorisation given for cars to be spun on a provincial road with the protection of officers.

Water restrictions see 17 municipal pools across CT open from December

Water restrictions see 17 municipal pools across CT open from December

The City of Cape Town's JP Smith says four of the existing municipal pools will be converted into salt water pools.

#DataMustFall! Meet Rain CEO Willem Roos... he is making it happen

#DataMustFall! Meet Rain CEO Willem Roos... he is making it happen

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Rain CEO Willem Roos for his weekly “ShapeShifter” feature.

Booming economy… cheap beer… great food… Beira is where it’s at, but the taxes!

Booming economy… cheap beer… great food… Beira is where it’s at, but the taxes!

VAT at 17%... yoh! Bruce Whitfield interviews Lee Kasumba, who is exploring Mozambique’s central port city of Beira.