Mild corporal punishment like child spanking linked to physical abuse - group

The UCT Children's Institute says mild forms of corporal punishment, such as a slap or spanking, can have detrimental effects on children.

The Constitutional Court is expected to rule on whether all forms of physical correction of children by their parents should be unlawful.

Last year, a judgment by the High Court in Johannesburg found that the use of physical chastisement in the home was unconstitutional, even if moderate and reasonable.

Read: Child spanking outlawed as court scraps use of 'reasonable chastisement' defence (2017)

Now an organisation called Freedom of Religion South Africa (For SA) is appealing that judgment at the Constitutional Court.

For SA argues that parents should be given the right to discipline their children without the interference of the state.

The UCT Children’s Institute is one of a number of academic, faith and civil society organisations which are respondents in the case and opposed to the use of any corporal punishment.

Read also: 'You can punish your children, you just don't need to hit them'

They say research shows that mild forms of corporal punishment can affect a child's mental health, lead to anti-social and delinquent behaviour and increases child aggression.

The institute's Stefanie Röhr adds that parents who use mild forms of corporal punishment are much more likely to also severely assault their child.

It shows that mild corporal punishment is linked to physical abuse... It's all on a continuum of violence.

Stefanie Röhr, senior researcher at UCT Children's Institute

Most forms of child abuse, 75% in fact, happens during episodes of physical discipline.

Stefanie Röhr, senior researcher at UCT Children's Institute

Since this organisation called Freedom of Religion South Africa appealed the ruling, it means the judgement is not in effect anymore until that appeal has been decided.

Stefanie Röhr, senior researcher at UCT Children's Institute

They are arguing that it's overstepping the boundaries in people's homes. They also say the court should make a decision...that there should be a law drafted and voted on in Parliament.

Stefanie Röhr, senior researcher at UCT Children's Institute

Research clearly shows that even mild forms of corporal punishment, a slap or spanking, can have detrimental effects on children's mental health.

Stefanie Röhr, senior researcher at UCT Children's Institute

Listen to the arguments made on The Pippa Hudson Show:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Dealerships must pay for cars damaged or stolen in their care, it's the law

Dealerships must pay for cars damaged or stolen in their care, it's the law

Once you hand over your keys to a car dealership, the Consumer Protection Act says that they are liable for anything that happens.

More than 11 million clams wash up on Robberg Beach in Plett

More than 11 million clams wash up on Robberg Beach in Plett

Nature’s Valley Trust confirmed that an estimated 11.5-million clams washed up covering a large stretch of shore.

Planned Kleinmond game park won't keep lions or host elephant rides - CapeNature

Planned Kleinmond game park won't keep lions or host elephant rides - CapeNature

Cape Town residents and animal welfare activists have raised concerns about the plans to open the Lamloch Safari Park on the R44.

'You can punish your children, you just don't need to hit them'

'You can punish your children, you just don't need to hit them'

Director at Peace Centre Carol Bouwer and EWN's Thando Kubheka provide an update about corporal punishment ConCourt case.

How the violence of corporal punishment can harm your kids

How the violence of corporal punishment can harm your kids

There's nothing innocent about child spanking. Child protection researcher Dr Stefanie Röhrs explores the detrimental effects.

Child spanking outlawed as court scraps use of 'reasonable chastisement' defence

Child spanking outlawed as court scraps use of 'reasonable chastisement' defence

The defence of reasonable chastisement of children has been declared unconstitutional in the Johannesburg High Court on Thursday.

Popular articles
'Its not good enough to say you just found out that SA trains are never on time'

'Its not good enough to say you just found out that SA trains are never on time'

Eusebius McKaiser shares his views on president Cyril Ramaphosa's train expirience on Monday.

Kilometres of boiler tube leaks 'are biting us big time' says Eskom COO

Kilometres of boiler tube leaks 'are biting us big time' says Eskom COO

Eskom's Jan Oberholzer says it has discovered boiler tube leaks which continue for kilometres and is working to repair this.

'I left Australia for SA so that my sons can practice their religion in freedom'

'I left Australia for SA so that my sons can practice their religion in freedom'

A Muslim mom and former community spokesperson - now living in SA - recounts the deep-rooted history of Islamophobia in Australia.

'Diesel shipment arriving on Tuesday will bring big relief to the grid'

'Diesel shipment arriving on Tuesday will bring big relief to the grid'

Demand management senior general manager, Andrew Etzinger provides details of why load shedding has been implemented.

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Here's how to check your load shedding schedule in Cape Town

Eskom has warned that more power cuts can be expected as maintenance continues over the next twelve months.