Why class action lawsuits don't get that far in SA

Ride-hailing service Uber faces a class action lawsuit following a number of high-profile incidents involving the platform.

Criminal defence attorney Ulrich Roux is representing 11 Uber victims who were either robbed, raped and attacked while using the service in South Africa.

But how likely is the lawsuit to succeed? Law expert Dr Theo Broodryk says the class action is not the appropriate legal mechanism in this case.

Read: Commuters file a class action lawsuit against e-hailing service Uber

Broodryk says that class actions suits are relatively novel in SA, with no completed trials to date because of settlements.

Before a class action lawsuit can proceed, the class must be certified, which creates two stages of the procedure.

A class action is divided into two phases. To date, there's been no completed class action litigated in South Africa.

Dr Theo Broodryk, Senior Lecturer - Stellenbosch University Faculty Of Law

Many class action lawsuits are settled out of court after the case has been certified and given the go-ahead, Broodryk explains. Therefore, most cases never make it to trial.

Almost 90% of class actions settle after they have been certified.

Dr Theo Broodryk, Senior Lecturer - Stellenbosch University Faculty Of Law

There has been an abuse of the mechanism. There are class action law firms who specialise in this field because they know that it's very likely to settle after they get the class action certified.

Dr Theo Broodryk, Senior Lecturer - Stellenbosch University Faculty Of Law

Also read: Uber SA says insurance cover is in place, but consumers tell a different story

He also argues that the absence of scrutiny or legal framework has hindered the advancement of class action proceedings.

The problem in SA is that we don't have a single piece of legislation or a court rule that regulates class actions. So we rely exclusively on the courts to tell us what the process is.

Dr Theo Broodryk, Senior Lecturer - Stellenbosch University Faculty Of Law

Listen to the expert discussion on The John Maytham Show:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Has Boris Johnson scuppered his chances for a go at the UK's top job?

Has Boris Johnson scuppered his chances for a go at the UK's top job?

Police were called to the home of the prime ministerial hopeful following an alleged altercation with his girlfriend.

What does the future hold for vandal-hit Gugulethu fire station?

What does the future hold for vandal-hit Gugulethu fire station?

The station has suffered in excess of R500,000 worth of damage over the past 11 months and was most recently targeted on 14 June.

Commuters file a class action lawsuit against e-hailing service Uber

Commuters file a class action lawsuit against e-hailing service Uber

Uber victims lawyer Ulrich Roux says his clients have all gone through terrible ordeals while riding in Uber vehicles.

Some of the weirdest things people leave in an Uber - Uber Lost & Found Index.

Some of the weirdest things people leave in an Uber - Uber Lost & Found Index.

The ride-hailing service releases aits 3rd annual list of the weirdest things left in Ubers this past year.

Why ride-hailing companies not legally responsible for driver behaviour

Why ride-hailing companies not legally responsible for driver behaviour

A company such as Taxify and Uber cannot be held responsible Western Cape Transport MEC, Donald Grant.

Uber SA says insurance cover is in place, but consumers tell a different story

Uber SA says insurance cover is in place, but consumers tell a different story

Uber says the blanket cover is paid for by the company in case of death, disability or injury suffered by drivers and passengers.

Popular articles
Investec gives staff unlimited leave days and freedom to wear what they want

Investec gives staff unlimited leave days and freedom to wear what they want

The bank rewards innovation with substantial bonuses and pays according to output not hours at work, says Lesley-Anne Gatter.

How to never-ever fall prey to ID theft… and info about a free service if you do

How to never-ever fall prey to ID theft… and info about a free service if you do

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Manie van Schalkwyk, Executive Director at The South African Fraud Prevention Service.

We've technologist on record saying she'll not treat patients - Discovery Health

We've technologist on record saying she'll not treat patients - Discovery Health

CEO Dr Broomberg has rubbished reports that a KwaZulu-Natal patient died after the company stopped payments.

What NOT to do at the scene of a road accident

What NOT to do at the scene of a road accident

Western Cape traffic chief Kenny Africa explains what you should do if you're the first responder at the scene of an accident.

'Zindzi's comments were racist and have nothing to do with the Mandela name'

'Zindzi's comments were racist and have nothing to do with the Mandela name'

ANC veteran Mavuso Msimang says South African ambassador to Denmark should be held accountable for her tweets.

Cape Town man found alive in eSwatini, believed dead for 6 years

Cape Town man found alive in eSwatini, believed dead for 6 years

His family believed he had died and performed a memorial service for him but now they are struggling to get him back home.

Public Protector has now become a "rogue unit", says Judge Kriegler

Public Protector has now become a "rogue unit", says Judge Kriegler

Busisiwe Mkhwebane is reportedly probing President Cyril Ramaphosa for alleged money laundering to the tune of R400m.

Gauteng waitress gets R18,000 tip for 'amazing service'

Gauteng waitress gets R18,000 tip for 'amazing service'

A waitress at The Beerhouse in Fourways who received the generous donation wants to finish her matric and become a paramedic.

[WATCH] Looks like 'Mabena' found his way to Sona and Mzansi had a good chuckle

[WATCH] Looks like 'Mabena' found his way to Sona and Mzansi had a good chuckle

The name Mabena has become synonymous with out of step and clumsy soldiers, and it seems one made an appearance at Parliament.