Calls for a commission of inquiry into alleged FNB discrimination
An appeal is being made to President Cyril Ramaphosa to establish a commission of inquiry into claims of discrimination against black homeowners by First National Bank (FNB) and other banks.
This week Special Assignment spoke to black homeowners who claimed that they were charged higher interest rates on home loans compared to their white counterparts.
Corroborating these claims, Financial Consultant Emerald van Zyl says the cover-up of discrimination is one of the biggest scandals in the history of SA banking and has spanned over a period of ten years.
He says the Reserve Bank, Human Rights Commission, Banking Council & the Standing Committee on Finance are aware of the issue but failed to act.
He has also accused the African National Congress, Economic Freedom Fighters and Democratic Alliance of inaction, saying banks are their financial support.
Ripped off with R 150 000 due to unfair discrimination with interest rates by FNB .— Emerald van Zyl (@interrec) March 9, 2019
Frans Mokomane one of the prejudice clients interviewed by Special Assignment for Sundays evening show rates were increased with 4.25% due to discrimination. From Dec '01 he paid 40% more monthly
Cover up of discrimination is one of the biggest scandals in the history of SA banking. The Reserve Bank, Human Right Commission, Banking Council & Standing Committee Finance Parliament are aware but failed to act. The ANC, EFF & DA won't act as banks are their financial support— Emerald van Zyl (@interrec) March 9, 2019
Did you know? President Cyril Ramaphosa was on the board of directors of First Rand Bank and also a big shareholder in the period of discrimination by FNB with interest rates on low cost housing.— Emerald van Zyl (@interrec) March 11, 2019
Van Zyl says a database leaked to him in 2010 revealed how FNB collected 3.25 percent more in mortgage loans from low-cost housing clients.
The low-cost housing book consisted of 23 300 clients and FNB argued that all the people in that group were not all black, I then obtained the services of Professor Cornie Groenewald and he found that all the clients are black, government employees, they receive a subsidy and salaries must be below a certain threshold.Emerald van Zyl, Private Financial Consultant
On Sunday night the Ombudsman for banking services, denied any sort of discrimination while I informed him about 2 years ago about this. Nothing is happening at government level, now the Equality Court has been going on for six years in which FNB has tried every single trick to delay the matter. They got a cost order against them for not delivering documentation that we asked for.Emerald van Zyl, Private Financial Consultant
One can see the clients [who appeared on Special Assignment] are all charged in excess of R 130 000.Emerald van Zyl, Private Financial Consultant
Black citizens are now requesting President Cyril Ramaphosa to appoint a commission of inquiry into discrimination by banks in South Africa.Emerald van Zyl, Private Financial Consultant
Some of them are paying 27% on their motor vehicles. Some of them are paying 7 or 8% more than what white people are paying for.Emerald van Zyl, Private Financial Consultant
FNB bought Saambou’s home loan book when the latter collapsed in 2002. Although FNB obtained the mortgage book of Saambou for R1 after the bank collapsed on 9 February 2002, it obtained the Low Cost Housing mortgage book by securitisation in 1998/1999.
CEO of FNB Home Finance, Lee Mhlongo says van Zyl's allegations are reckless and baseless and that FNB rectified Saambou's operating model by 2006.
He says a lot of the issues mentioned were tested in the North Gauteng High Court in 2013 and were found to be baseless.
The accusations around racial discrimination are hurtful and baseless.Lee Mhlongo, FNB Home Finance - CEO
Where does the FNB Saambou relationship begin, that begins in 2002, anything that precedes that is a matter of a Saambou operating model, not an FNB operating model. Secondly, there was an interest recalculation implemented in 2006, this recalculation was something clearly understood and known about as part of that acquisition. That was effected proactively and an amount of R 154 million was paid to these Saambou customers to rectify issues that preceded...Lee Mhlongo, FNB Home Finance - CEO
The policy that Saambou carried out prior to that 1998 period is an issue that relates to how Saambou carried out its affairs and the court found that the allegations put forward were not congruent with the statements that Mr van Zyl is making.Lee Mhlongo, FNB Home Finance - CEO
Within an FNB context, we have a dedicated business unit whose sole focus was to find affordable solutions for customers in the affordable housing space. We send customers monthly statements, if interest rates change we send out communication to those customers. We run a comprehensive borrowers education tool to empower customers to be fully aware of what their rights are.Lee Mhlongo, FNB Home Finance - CEO
Click on the link below to hear the full story...
This article first appeared on 702 : Calls for a commission of inquiry into alleged FNB discrimination
The SA Drug Policy Initiative says the prohibition of booze and cigarettes has had harmful health, social, economic, and criminal effects.Read More
We must now try and rescue what's left of the economy, says Democratic Alliance (DA) leader John Steenhuisen.Read More
Teffo says the board's decision will not pass the test of rationality in a court of law in South Africa if it were challenged.Read More
Is there something more to the cigarette ban, asks political analyst Sanusha Naidoo. Why cigarettes and not alcohol?Read More
National Health Director-General Dr Anban Pillay explains Lockdown level 3 which will be implemented from 1 June.Read More
The Presidency of the Republic of South Africa released these key points outlining the level 3 lockdown for the country from 1 June.Read More
President Cyril Ramaphosa announced in an address to the nation that SA will move down to Level 3 lockdown from 1 June.Read More
The President has delivered a lockdown update - listen to his explanation of the move to Level 3 from 1 June.Read More
A survey by teacher unions shows that 92% of SA's schools are not ready and safe to re-open says Natu's Cynthia Barnes.Read More
The president is set to address a nation anxiously awaiting a drop in the lockdown level, at 7pm on Sunday.Read More