'All xenophobic attacks of this kind are inherently criminal' says Eusebius
International Relations Minister Lindiwe Sisulu has called the attacks on foreign nationals criminal and not xenophobic.
Sisulu and Police Minister Bheki Cele met with the ambassadors of African countries in Pretoria on Monday to discuss last week's attacks on foreign nationals in KwaZulu-Natal.
Show host Eusebius McKaiser says he disagrees with the minister's stance.
Firstly, how much research has the government done to try and understand what the motivations were behind these most recent attacks to be able to rule out Afrophobic or xenophobic motives behind them.Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter
Secondly, the two are not mutually exclusive. All xenophobic attacks of this kind are inherently criminal. The question is not whether they are criminal but whether they are also accompanied by and motivated by xenophobic sentiment.Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter
That is very important so that you can intervene properly, knowing what it is that you are intervening in. If you say it is sheer criminality, then in a sense you are in denial about what some of the underlying drivers are and what the phenomenon is that you need to tackle here politically.Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter
Calling it criminality is the first step, but you cannot stop there. I mean that is entirely unacceptable.Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter
He adds that for the minister to acknowledge that these attacks are xenophobic, is to recognise that the fundamental political and international legal obligations that South Africa has towards citizens from other countries are not being taken seriously by the current government.
There is an international law interest and there is also a geopolitical interest in the minister reducing the description of what is going on here, which is why she is restricting herself to a description of criminality.Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter
Quite frankly minister, that is utterly irresponsible. It is insensitive and we have to be clear about the reality of what you are dealing with.Eusebius McKaiser, Presenter
Callers also weighed in on the minister's stance, and Keneilwe says she does not believe that South Africans are xenophobic.
Whether it is the minority or the marginalised women and children, I would rather have a focus on policy that strengthens the law, strengthens the capacity of the police - because I would question the agenda of painting South Africans as xenophobic.Keneilwe, Caller
Diamond also called in and says the attacks on foreign nationals in Durban are xenophobic.
The issue is that politicians come in and say reckless comments which instil violence in the communities.Diamond, Caller
Zaine says these attacks are more Afrophobia than they are xenophobic and people need to look at what the drivers of these attacks are.
Part of the problem is that we have public representatives and politicians that say things in public spaces that add fuel to the fire instead of actually trying to deal with the problem.Zaine, Caller
Watch below as Eusebius shares his views:
Listen below to the full #702openline:
This article first appeared on 702 : 'All xenophobic attacks of this kind are inherently criminal' says Eusebius
The Deputy Minister of Mineral Resources died in a car crash on Friday. The details surrounding the crash remain unclear.Read More
A Facebook post has put the Wykeham Collegiate private school for girls in Pietermaritzburg in the limelight.Read More
The fired Old Mutual CEO has responded to board chair Trevor Manuel's claims made in a media briefing on Friday.Read More
Residents have been urged to adapt accordingly as the Integrated Vaal River System is also negatively impacted by the decline.Read More
The MDC president says this is not the time to score 'cheap' political points and that due regard must be given to the statesmen.Read More
JSE CEO Nicky Newton-King received a memorandum from demonstrators on Friday and says women's demands will not fall on deaf ears.Read More
Activist Nolwazi Tusini gives her critique of the #SandtonShutdown and the conversation around gender-based violence.Read More
Police Minister says the country needs to move away form moral degeneration and put families first.Read More
ZimFacts head Cris Chinaka weighs in on the impact of the former Zimbabwean president on the country and its people.Read More
MMC Michael Sun says the municipality has to comply with the rules and regulations when giving private operators such a tender.Read More
“Pick n Pay dug themselves a hole, then jumped into it,” says branding and advertising expert Andy Rice.Read More
Too scared to “gamble” away your hard-earned cash? Kabous le Roux asks you to consider this simple argument with an open mind.Read More
The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield asks Peter Attard Montalto (Head of Capital Markets Research at Intellidex) for comment.Read More
The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield hosts a debate on NHI between Paul Theron (Vestact) and Russell Rensburg (Wits).Read More
Gavin Watson knew a lot. But now the story that shook SA and the ANC to its core will never be complete, says Adriaan Basson.Read More
Lord Tim Bell has died. Listen to this fascinating 2017 interview of Bell by Bruce Whitfield on The Money Show.Read More
Bruce Whitfield interviews David Lewis (Corruption Watch) and arms deal activist Terry Crawford-Browne.Read More
There was nothing illegal, yet the CR17 leaks is a PR disaster for Cyril Ramaphosa, says communications consultant Chris Vick.Read More
Zwelakhe Mnguni (CIO at Benguela Global Fund Managers) shares his stock picks of the week: Naspers, Standard Bank and Pick n Pay.Read More
If the SANDF deployment is extended on the Cape Flats, it must be done in conjunction with better policing, an analyst explains.Read More
Khayelitsha green entrepreneur Siyabulela Sokomani has brought his 'moving forest' to Sanlam Cape Town Marathon for a good cause.Read More
Minister Patricia de Lille has invited the public to pay their final respects to Williams at the Newlands Stadium in Cape Town.Read More
Hundreds of women gathered outside the JSE in Sandton as early as 3am this morning to demand support from the private sector.Read More
Old Mutual is not backing down in its fight with fired CEO Peter Moyo. Ray White interviews EWN’s Nthakoana Ngatane.Read More
Olivia Jasriel says they were informed on Thursday that Hewitt will be released n the 23 September 2019.Read More
Businesswoman Khanyi Chaba says she spoke out about the abuse of her late friend Dr Thandi Ndlovu in order to honour her legacy.Read More
Kgabele Memela says because of the initiative he received an internship at Unlockd.Read More
Civic pressure group Stop CoCT says it found discrepancies in the tariff increases implemented by the City.Read More
Centre for Child Law project manager Zita Hansungule says children still have the ability to be rehabilitated and reintegrated.Read More