Streaming issues? Report here
Lester Kieviet 2019 1500 BW 2
Tonight with Lester Kiewit
20:00 - 22:00
volume_up
volume_mute

Up Next: The Aubrey Masango Show
See full line-up
Tonight with Lester Kiewit
20:00 - 22:00
Home
arrow_forward
Sport
arrow_forward
Politics

Caster ruling: 'They recognised the discrimination, but felt it necessary'

2 May 2019 8:38 AM
Tags:
Caster Semenya
IAAF
Court of Arbitration for Sport
CAS
Sports medicine scientist Dr Shuaib Manjra and UCT Head of Human Biology Professor Malcolm Collins unpacks the judgment.

South African athlete Caster Semenya's challenge against the International Association of Athletics Federations rules forcing her to lower her testosterone levels to compete with women has been rejected.

Read: Caster Semenya on CAS ruling: 'I will once again rise above'

The Court of Arbitration for Sport issued its ruling on Wednesday.

Also read: 'There are no two ways about it, we will appeal this Caster judgment'

It means Semenya will have to take medication to suppress her testosterone if she wants to keep running in certain events on the international stage.

To weigh in on the judgment, Sports medicine scientist Dr Shuaib Manjra speaks to 702's Bongani Bingwa.

The Court of Arbitration for Sport released its findings yesterday, and it was a two-page finding, but there is a 138-page judgment, so we have to read the reasonings and the signs that they have used to conclude the way that they have and then we will get a better understanding.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

They are saying if she wants to compete, then she must fight on an equal footing, and for her to compete on a similar level, she must reduce her testosterone level, so it doesn't give her an unfair advantage. That is the reasoning why they want her to lower her testosterone.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

He says the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) relied on two scientific papers which other scientists around the world argue are deeply flawed.

And that was the evidence that was presented to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, we don't know how the court rates both sets of evidence, but clearly, those two-page findings demonstrated a significant advantage.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

I think the vote was split, it was a two to one vote, it wasn't a unanimous vote, they recognised that there is discrimination, but they felt that the perception was necessary, rational and proportionate to uphold the differences in sports.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

He adds that Semenya has a number of options available.

The one option is to quit running altogether, the second option is to appeal the findings, the third is to use hormonal therapy to reduce her testosterone level, and the fourth one is for her to compete in the 1500m and above.

Dr Shuaib Manjra, Sports medicine scientist

Listen below to the full interview:

Head of Human Biology at UCT, Professor Malcolm Collins speaks to CapeTalk's Kieno Kammies about the ruling and the biology behind it.

I am very disappointed with the ruling.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Semenya has stated that she has a genetic advantage which is part of elite sport.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He says her particular advantage is being discriminated against.

One of the big questions the sports world is trying to unpack is, what determines an elite sports person? And the big debate over the years is, is it nurture or is it nature?

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He says it has now been established that athletic ability is determined by very complex and poorly understood interaction between the two.

So our genetic makeup does play a very important role in determining whether we will be top contenders in any discipline.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Semenya's genetic advantage is undisputed, he says.

She is born with differences in sex development which means she will produce higher levels of testosterone, but high jumpers are born with height...so does this mean every sport will have to be capped with something?

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

He does not believe she has an unfair advantage.

Because that is the nature of sport.

Professor Malcolm Collins, Head of Human Biology - UCT

Listen to Professor Collins below:


This article first appeared on 702 : Caster ruling: 'They recognised the discrimination, but felt it necessary'


2 May 2019 8:38 AM
Tags:
Caster Semenya
IAAF
Court of Arbitration for Sport
CAS

More from Sport

ali-bacher-john-studiojfif

[WATCH] Ali Bacher discusses history and future of South African cricket

17 January 2020 5:42 PM

Cricket legend Dr Ali Bacher has seen South African cricket come a long way. He reflects on the country's best bowlers and more.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

siya-kolisijpg

Last season ever at Newlands: ‘We’ve got 7 Springboks and a new playing style'

14 January 2020 9:52 AM

Refilwe Moloto interviews Stormers coach John Dobson and his scrumhalf Herschel Jantjies and flyhalf Damian Willemse.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

190219-exercise-gym-traininjpg

New laws and regulatory body proposed for fitness trainers and gyms

13 January 2020 1:56 PM

Sports Minister Nathi Mthethwa has called on the public to submit their comments on the draft bill aimed at the fitness industry.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Desiree Ellis

Star coach Desiree Ellis dedicates CAF Award to Banyana team

9 January 2020 3:23 PM

Banyana Banyana coach Desiree Ellis was crowned the Women's African Coach of the Year for the second year in a row.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

cassiem-2jpg

Meet Boeta Cassiem, the legendary ice cream vendor who makes Newlands come alive

8 January 2020 12:46 PM

Cape Town icon Boeta Cassiem reflects on his amazing innings as the premier ice cream vendor at Newlands Stadium.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Cricket-ball-sport-123rfjpg

4-day Test cricket: Do we need it, or has the world gone completely bonkers?

8 January 2020 11:32 AM

We’ve just seen an absolutely cracking five-day Test match, says Adam Gilchrist. Why change? It's all about the money.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

191227-nic-dlamini2-edjpg

SA cyclist Nic Dlamini in positive spirits and hasn't ruled out 2020 Olympic bid

6 January 2020 4:25 PM

Nic Dlamini's calendar for the 2020 season will be decided after his medical team gives out a final prognosis later this week.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

pepe-dos-santos-facebookjpg

SA has skilled soccer players, what we need is good coaches - Pepe dos Santos

5 January 2020 3:10 PM

The soccer legend on local football and his style of coaching for the up-and-coming Cape Town Chiefs team.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

donne-van-doesburghjpg

Meet the captain who led SA's women's ice hockey team to victory at world champs

20 December 2019 3:30 PM

South Africa's women’s ice hockey team claimed gold in division three at the recent World Championships in Bulgaria.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Ice cream cone melting hot warm weather scoop summer ice-cream

Most popular stories on CapeTalk in November 2019 (a fascinating lookback)

18 December 2019 11:05 AM

These are the stories we couldn't get enough of on CapeTalk as year started drawing to a close in 2019.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

More from Politics

191119-saa-edjpg

SAA CCO downplays flight-shedding, says 'not that many flights cancelled'

22 January 2020 8:57 AM

All airlines review their schedules and cancel and consolidate flights in event of low demand says SAA's Phillip Saunders.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Gavel court case corruption - 123rf

Targeting guilty individuals' pension funds could claw back looted state money

21 January 2020 1:16 PM

Justice Ministry spokesperson explains a precedent may be set in the SIU case to the Special tribunal starting on Tuesday.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

150609NeilAggett.jpg

Frank Chikane describes the last time he saw Neil Aggett alive in police custody

21 January 2020 11:27 AM

Struggle stalwart Frank Chikane was detained at the same time as Dr Neil Aggett. He recalls how brutally they were treated by police.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

education-africa-girl-child-literacy-school-learning-knowledge-teaching-123rf

'22 richest men have more money than all 600 million African women put together'

21 January 2020 10:59 AM

If Jeff Bezos and Bernard Arnault – the world’s two richest men – sat on their wealth piled up in $100 bills, they’d be in space!

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

fees-protest-uctjpg

'Some of these students had to return back home, others are sleeping on campus'

21 January 2020 10:15 AM

#OpenNSFAS rep Kabelo Mahlobgwane says the application deadlines must be scrapped so late-accepted students can receive funds.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

South Africa law justice courts state capture 123rfjustice 123rflaw 123rf

Government employees are now in direct line of fire, says Karyn Maughan

21 January 2020 7:35 AM

Legal journalist Karyn Maughan explains the SIU's special tribunal's first case staring on Tuesday.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

150609NeilAggett.jpg

Apartheid-era police will be subpoenaed to testify in Neil Aggett inquest

20 January 2020 1:47 PM

Almost 38 years after his death, a fresh investigation into the death of anti-apartheid activist Neil Aggett has been opened.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

150323-Marriage.jpg

SAHRC to pursue case of same-sex couple refused at Cape Town wedding venue

20 January 2020 1:45 PM

The lesbian couple has launched a case with the SA Human Rights Commission after the venue refused to host their wedding.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Herman Mashaba

Our movement for change is coming! - Mmusi Maimane

20 January 2020 1:16 PM

"… we are definitely going to participate in the 2021 local government elections...," says former Joburg mayor Herman Mashaba.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

cabinet-stella-2jpegjpg

Minister Ndabeni-Abrahams blew tax money on her wedding anniversary - report

20 January 2020 11:06 AM

She allegedly did it without President Cyril Ramaphosa’s permission, as required by the Ministerial Handbook.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward