Making sex offenders register public will give only 'false sense of security'
One of the measures put forward by President Cyril Ramaphosa in his pre-recorded address to the nation on Thursday evening to address the epidemic of violence against women and children, is to overhaul the national register for gender-based violence offenders.
This includes asking Parliament to make the register public.
But would this really have an impact?
Activist and researcher Lisa Vetten says the problem is too urgent for the state to be investing time and money in measures that research shows are not effective.
There is no research in the countries where public sex offenders registers have been created, that they've had any effect whatsoever.Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research
It is one of those measures that gives us a sense of security, that looks and seems in terms of our common sense to make a difference, but I think it's a measure that gives us false security because ultimately it doesn't work.Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research
She emphasizes that the register itself has a place, in terms of alerting those who employ others to work with children and people with intellectual disabilities to offenders in these categories.
Why the Law Commission didn't extend this more broadly is because there isn't a lot of evidence for these measures having broader impact.Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research
So we would be putting a lot of time, a lot of money, a lot of human resources into something that simply does not work.Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research
On the calls for introducing chemical castration of rapists, Vetten has this to say:
The fundamental point is that the act of rape is not an act of uncontrollable, excessive hormone production. It is a problem of what goes on inside your head.Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research
This problem is far too serious and far too urgent for us to be wasting time and money on things that don't work, although they make us feel better.Lisa Vetten, Research associate - Wits Institute For Social Economic Research
Among the priority areas that could have more of an impact she says are getting proper statistics and researching them to determine patterns of behaviour and finding out why protection orders are not working.
Listen to the thought-provoking conversation here:
Yusuf Ambramjee shared a video showing sealed packets of what appears to be drugs hidden in pieces of cooked meat.Read More
Lester Kiewit and estate agent Karen Dunlop take a satirical look at what the former president's homestead has to offer.Read More
Gauteng Education MEC says there is no room in a non-racial South Africa for reminders of apartheid.Read More
The Deputy Minister of Mineral Resources died in a car crash on Friday. The details surrounding the crash remain unclear.Read More
A Facebook post has put the Wykeham Collegiate private school for girls in Pietermaritzburg in the limelight.Read More
The fired Old Mutual CEO has responded to board chair Trevor Manuel's claims made in a media briefing on Friday.Read More
Residents have been urged to adapt accordingly as the Integrated Vaal River System is also negatively impacted by the decline.Read More
The MDC president says this is not the time to score 'cheap' political points and that due regard must be given to the statesmen.Read More
JSE CEO Nicky Newton-King received a memorandum from demonstrators on Friday and says women's demands will not fall on deaf ears.Read More
Activist Nolwazi Tusini gives her critique of the #SandtonShutdown and the conversation around gender-based violence.Read More