Mixed reaction to Constitutional Court's ruling over spanking of children
The Constitutional Court has ruled that corporal punishment cannot be used in private homes.
The court has upheld the South Gauteng High Court's 2017 ruling against corporal punishment in the home.
Last year, Freedom of religion South Africa challenged the High Court ruling, which effectively declared all forms of corporal punishment by parents on their children unlawful.
Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng, who presided over the case, said that the defence of reasonable chastisement was inconsistent with the Constitution.
In terms of this judgment practically it means parents who physically correct their children in any way, even a tap on the hand, will be committing a crime of assault.Daniela Ellerbeck, Legal advisor - Freedom of Religion SA
It sets a very dangerous precedent with the state being able to step into the home and dictate to parents how to raise their children.Daniela Ellerbeck, Legal advisor - Freedom of Religion SA
Families will be torn apart because of this judgment, says Ellerbeck.
This will destroy families in South Africa and families are the bedrock of society.Daniela Ellerbeck, Legal advisor - Freedom of Religion SA
Meanwhile, independent children's rights consultant Carol Bower applauds judgment.
We are an extraordinary violence country and when we hit children we teach them the wrong message.Carol Bower, Independent children's rights consultant
Violence begets violence.Carol Bower, Independent children's rights consultant
Maybe the #concourt will then raise SA's kids.— Mtimande (@uMthandeni) September 18, 2019
Tjo.— Khaya Sithole (@CoruscaKhaya) September 18, 2019
Looks like children are under siege in this country.
Everyone is so angry about the #ConCourt judgment 😂😂😂
So #ConCourt, once parents are in jail for spanking their kids, who's gonna take care of them?— Lusso🇿🇦🇸🇿🌡️ (@1st_Vince) September 18, 2019
Listen to the full interviews below...
This article first appeared on 702 : Mixed reaction to Constitutional Court's ruling over spanking of children
The relatively new CAA number plates are about to run out, explains Western Cape Transport MEC Bonginkosi Madikizela.Read More
Taxi drivers have been causing disruptions this week in protest against warrants issued in an operation by the City of Cape Town.Read More
Recent crime statistics show that the police station has the highest number of sexually related crimes in the country.Read More
Expect heavy delays out of the City along all major routes.Read More
Director-General Thabani Zulu says the nuclear programme will be done at a cost and a pace that is affordable to the State.Read More
Cape Town stadium will be leased to a municipal body that's subsidised by the city for R100 per annum.Read More
Stellenbosch University researcher Alanna Rebelo describes the factors involved in Cape Town fires and how residents can help.Read More
In his resignation letter, Boughey - who had been CEO for the DA for five years - said that he had reached an agreement with the party in principle to resign.Read More