Facebook group #ImStaying responds to 'extremely elitist' backlash
As the Facebook group #ImStaying continues to grow in numbers, some South Africans are interrogating its purpose and impact.
The group has been credited with giving hope to despondent locals by posting uplifting messages about South Africa, encouraging them to stay in the country.
Cape Town real estate entrepreneur Jarette Petzer started the page last month. It now has 416,627 members and counting.
Petzer says the page is fostering compassion and connections between South Africans from all backgrounds.
But some locals disagree, claiming the group is extremely elitist, catering to a privileged white minority.
Petzer denies this and maintains that #ImStaying is all-inclusive.
It's an all-inclusive group. We've got people from every religion, race and from all across the country. Everybody is contributing.Jarette Petzer, Founder of #I'mStaying
The diversity is growing in the background.Jarette Petzer, Founder of #I'mStaying
We're open for everybody. This group is for the country; it's for South Africa.Jarette Petzer, Founder of #I'mStaying
A Woodstock resident feels the group serves a white, wealthy minority that is privileged enough to consider emigration at all.
The group is extremely elitist. It's a fake positivity that only affects a minority group.Dee-dee, CapeTalk caller
Do they want to listen, or do they want to mute and delete us? Our reality is different to their reality. They need to learn to listen.Dee-dee, CapeTalk caller
The page has also been accused of deleting posts and removing members who offer a critique of the platform.
Petzer, however, says the group does not allow negative comments or discussions about politics, religion or what he refers to as "contentious issues."
Another Cape Town resident, Brett Anderson, puts forward that the idea of sharing only "positive" experiences is in itself a privileged act.
He says that white South Africans need to do more than just share positive stories in order to address inequality and the harsh lived experiences of the disadvantaged majority.
The change needs to happen - our fear is that the #ImStaying group is cancelling all of that and saying 'Let's just be happy.'Brett Anderson, CapeTalk caller
I don't know why, but there are so many pictures of white people with their domestic workers in that group. Those are the majority of the stories.Brett Anderson, CapeTalk caller
He says a smaller Facebook group, Conversations For A Just South Africa, is having those difficult discussions about race, privilege and inequality.
Listen to the #ImStaying founder in conversation with Melanie Rice:
Listen to some of the critique:
Some things in life just don’t need a “designer” counterpart, reckons branding and advertising expert Andy Rice.Read More
Rugby is certainly on the up, says the green-blooded Dr Michael Goldman (Sport Management Program, University of San Francisco).Read More
Branding and advertising expert Andy Rice discusses the most-liked TV adverts in South Africa in the second quarter of 2019.Read More
Consumer journalist Wendy Knowler spent a day with financial services ombuds from around the world. Here are their suggestions.Read More
Advertising expert Andy Rice slams it. The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield’s response to the advert? “Hahahahahahahaha!”Read More
It’s good to be a CEO in South Africa – whether you screw up or not, says a disgusted Anthony Clark (Small Talk Daily).Read More
"We pretend as if we don’t know what needs to be done," says Dr Iraj Abedian, CEO at Pan-African Investments and Research Services.Read More
Govt wants to formalise grade 9 as an exit point of schooling. John Maytham interviews Joanne Hardman (UCT School of Education).Read More
The process leading to the shortlist hasn’t been transparent, says Eldred De Klerk (Africa Centre for Security and Intelligence).Read More
The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews Pieter du Toit, author of "The Stellenbosch Mafia: Inside the Billionaires' Club".Read More
The Western Cape Education Department says 36 out of the 274 centres writing Computer Applications Technology were affected.Read More
A survey of southern right whales off the Cape coast has counted just 200 in the area – the second-lowest figure since 1995.Read More
Some of the endangered wildlife has now been listed as farming stock under key legislation that governs breeding.Read More
The municipality had initially ruled out having any designated spots for the discharge of fireworks this festive season.Read More
A study is being planned to determine potential outlets and job-creation opportunities that Cape Town's night-time economy offers.Read More
Consumer journo Wendy Knowler explains why it can be better to claim on your own car insurance after an accident.Read More
The Pietermaritzburg pupil died in his mother's arms on Tuesday.Read More
Deputy Minister Pinky Kekana says the broadcaster is showing commitment to work towards being accountable.Read More
Party federal council elections presiding officer Desree van der Walt says its all systems go for this weekend's elections.Read More
Acting CEO of Business Unity South Africa says the lack of load shedding contributed to the GDP growth in the previous quarter.Read More