'SCA hate speech ruling does not exonerate Jon Qwelane from wrongdoing'
An appeal by former ambassador to Uganda and controversial columnist Jon Qwelane has resulted in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) declaring as unconstitutional, Section 10 of the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act (Pepuda).
Qwelane had been found guilty of hate speech in 2017 following a newspaper column he wrote with the title Call me names, but gay is not okay which included praise for former Zimbabwean president Robert Mugabe's stance on homosexuality.
The SCA has overturned the South Gauteng High Court's ruling against Qwelane.
It's declared the current definition of hate speech unconstitutional, finding that a comment is only hate speech if incitement to cause harm can be proven. The order will have to be confirmed by the Constitutional Court before the act can be amended.
CapeTalk's Africa Melane gets a response from the chair of the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC), Professor Bongani Majola.
He says the ruling is "not a complete loss" because it will help to clarify the implementation of this piece of legislation - something the SAHRC has been saying is necessary for some time.
In a way the decision is a welcome decision in so far as the case is going to to to the highest court, the Constitutional Court, for a final clarification of how we should go about hate speech.Prof. Bongani Majola, Chairperson - South African Human Rights Commission
For us, this case also means that we've got to sit down and decide what we do with pending cases that we've already initiated and cases that we are about to initiate.Prof. Bongani Majola, Chairperson - South African Human Rights Commission
Professor Majola adds that this ruling does not exonerate Qwelane from wrongdoing and the commission will now have to decide what to do about his case in particular.
To listen to the full discussion, click on the link below:
Roxy Davis runs a surf school in Muizenberg and she dedicates much of her time helping adaptive surfers.Read More
Despite some concerns about infrastructure maintenance earlier this year, park management says Lion's Head is now safe for hikers.Read More
Cape Town's fire chief Ian Schnetler says municipal fire crews are working with other firefighting agencies to contain the blaze.Read More
Cape Town Mayco Member for Transport Felicity Purchase says the machines are old and need replacing.Read More
Lead SA: SPCA officer Thembi Nomkala on rescuing an 80-year-old motorist and how his work involves keeping farm animals off N2.Read More
Eskom has implemented Stage 2 load shedding until 11 pm on Sunday. It says it is "conserving emergency reserves" for the week ahead.Read More
The Arch's family has expressed gratitude for South Africans' love and prayers since his hospitalisation on Wednesday.Read More
Eskom says continued load shedding is necessary to enable it to replenish water reserves for its pumped storage schemes.Read More
Tarryn developed rheumatoid arthritis at age 18 and is dedicated to helping create accessible spaces for wheelchair access.Read More
Safety and security during tourism season in the Cape is everybody's responsibility, says Winde.Read More
John Maytham gets fired up about so-called changes to the Ministerial Handbook.Read More
Refilwe Moloto says the negative outlook for SA in 2019 from investors speaks to a Cabinet not in control of the economy.Read More
Independent energy analyst Ted Blom says the level of load shedding is purely dictated by the level of breakdowns within Eskom.Read More
JP Smith says the court has ordered all parties to meet by Friday and come to an amicable solution.Read More
Eskom sent out a tweet announcing load shedding would change to Stage 6 at 6:00pm on Monday.Read More
The aim of the People’s Dialogue is to build engagement with SA citizens, but a political party is not out of the question.Read More
Leon Schreiber, DA Shadow Minister for Public Service and Administration, weighs in on the new version of the guide for ministers.Read More
EWN reporter Mia Lindeque says Minister Mbalula has appointed Bongisizwe Mpondo as the new administrator at Prasa.Read More
Former anti-apartheid activist and economics professor Ben Turok died on Monday morning. He was 92-years old.Read More
Political analyst Jan-Jan Joubert says Nzimande will fight back does not believe he will leave his ministerial position easily.Read More