Mapisa-Nqakula slap on the wrist? Ramaphosa has power to fire Cabinet ministers
Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula will have three months' salary docked and instead paid into the Solidarity Fund, because she allowed ANC members to catch a flight on a government plane, to Zimbabwe.
Opposition parties are instead calling for her to be sacked.
UCT's public law specialist, associate professor, Cathy Powell, speaks to Refilwe Moloto about the President's decision.
The starting point is to know he (President Ramaphosa) could have fired her. He has the power to fire his members of Cabinet at will.Cathy Powell, Public Law Specialist - UCT
The Constitution makes provision for the President to hire and fire his Cabinet ministers, she adds.
There are no sanctions against the ministers of transport and finance as it is unlikely they had knowledge of the actions.
But that is also something we should be incensed about, that we were told so little. We have a right to know who made the decision.Cathy Powell, Public Law Specialist - UCT
However, Powell says, though such actions by a public official can be found to be unlawful, it does not necessarily make them criminal.
The ANC has said it will pay the money back.
The act will become invalid but will not be charged unless corruption is found to be involved, such as a gratification made to someone in order for them to break the law.
She outlines what Parliament could do in this situation. The first step would be to investigate exactly who made the decisions for the delegation to fly on the SANDF plane to Zimbabwe.
The second step, she says, would then be for Parliament to impose a sanction on those responsible.
What Parliament cannot do is fire an individual minister. Parliament has the power to fire the entire Cabinet with or without the President, but not an individual minister.Cathy Powell, Public Law Specialist - UCT
Powell does not think the 3-month pay docking is anywhere near sufficient for taking a private contingency to another country without permission.
Quite frankly, I think the woman should be fired.Cathy Powell, Public Law Specialist - UCT
Listen to the interview below:
'Difference is not the problem, but our biases around difference are the problem, says social justice advocate Lovelyn Nwadeyi.Read More
The government wants unions to consider a fresh proposal for an out of court settlement over increases for public sector workers.Read More
A second wave of Covid-19 infections is taking hold in the province. Should Govt lock down? Are people willing to self-regulate?Read More
"Multitudes of people are giving him a hero’s welcome," says Lungisa spokesperson Thabo Kupa.Read More
From Jan van Riebeeck to Thabo Mbeki, from Sepp Blatter to minibus taxi drivers… these people stuffed up beautiful South Africa.Read More
During a heated cross-examination at the state capture inquiry, Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan was accused of racism, arrogance, and jealousy.Read More
The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Pauli van Wyk, an investigative journalist at Daily Maverick.Read More
Nelson Mandela Bay acting mayor Thsonono Buyeye says tavern owners have volunteered to only sell liquor for takeaway amid a surge of Covid-19 infections.Read More
Political scientist and ANC member Professor Keith Gottschalk says it's in vibrant branches where grassroots democracy occurs.Read More
The African Transformation Movement's move against Ramaphosa is posturing ahead of the election in 2021, says Sanusha Naidoo.Read More