Numsa loses ConCourt bid to have 733 workers reinstated in retrenchment dispute
In March this year, the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (Numsa) approached the Constitutional Court to seek the reinstatement of 733 workers who were retrenched by Aveng Trident Steel.
(NUMSA and Others v Aveng Trident Steel (a division of Aveng Africa (Pty) Ltd) and Another) (2 of 2) pic.twitter.com/hvbssUyTE9— Constitutional Court (@ConCourtSA) March 4, 2020
The employer issued a Section 189 notice in 2014, informing workers of its plans to restructure the company, due to operational requirements after a decline in the steel industry.
More than 700 employees were retrenched by Aveng Trident Steel in 2015 after they refused to accept an offer of alternative employment.
Numsa attempted to challenge the matter on behalf of its members, arguing that they were unfairly dismissed, in terms of the Labour Relations Act.
The union lost two previous legal challenges at the Labour Court, and the Labour Appeals Court before approaching the ConCourt.
Now the Constitutional Court has ruled in favour of Aveng Trident Steel, upholding the previous rulings which found that the dismissal of the workers was fair.
Employment attorney Andre Vlok says the ConCourt judgment serves as an important lesson for all labour unions when dealing with retrenchment processes.
It's a clarion call for unions to approach this type of negotiation very responsibly.Andre Vlok, Employment attorney
Numsa's argument was that Aveng was trying to hide a dismissal, for the employee's refusal to accept amended working conditions, as a retrenchment.Andre Vlok, Employment attorney
The Constitutional Court just confirms the previous decisions by the lower courts.Andre Vlok, Employment attorney
The Constitutional Court agreed with Aveng that it was a retrenchment, it was a proper termination of employment for operational requirements.Andre Vlok, Employment attorney
The Constitutional Court handed down judgment on Tuesday 27 October. You can read the full judgment here.
Listen to Andre Vlok on Breakfast with Refilwe Moloto:
"It applies to everybody. You have no choice," says Jan Truter of Labour Wise. "It comes at the worst possible time."Read More
The future is now different. The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews trends analyst Dion Chang, the founder of Flux Trends.Read More
It cannot stop its furnaces, so it must keep them going. Bruce Whitfield interviews Mike Arnold, CEO at Consol Glass.Read More
Treasury is mulling raising taxes, says Prof Adrian Saville, Chief Executive of Cannon Asset Managers.Read More
An economist expects China growth at 9.5%, US money-printing, rising metal prices and trade- and current-account surpluses in SA.Read More
Bruce Whitfield asks personal finance advisor Warren Ingram to explain in detail the new laws affecting provident funds.Read More
Germany has squandered its early success in restricting Covid-19, laments Deutsche Welle Correspondent Chelsey Dulaney.Read More
A new harvest is imminent and there's no more space for unsold wine. We have the highest stock level ever - Vinpro's Rico BassonRead More
A new scam is surfacing on Facebook and WhatsApp groups. The masterminds are even using the FSP number of a legitimate company.Read More
Loadshedding is another blow to the struggling restaurant industry. We need more relief says Grace Harding (Restaurant Collective)Read More