Why the law proposed to hold bar owners liable for drunks may not work

Liquor outlet owners may soon be held responsible for the behaviour of their inebriated patrons, even once they leave their premises.

With South Africa placing in the world’s top 5 when it comes to alcohol abuse, the Department of Trade and Industry has taken the debate to the public, starting with its proposed legislation.

(Also read our article: Deadline for public comment on proposed national liquor law changes looms)

CapeTalk presenter Kieno Kammies spoke with Leon Louw, Director of the Free Market Foundation about the flaws in the proposed legislation.

According Louw, the draft legislation has several impractical limitations.

The idea of vicarious liability exists in our law. Secondly, even the police are unable to conduct the precursor tests to assess intoxication. The law doesn't say that we may not serve liquor to drunk people. It holds owners liable if they serve them liquor and, thereafter, they to do something wrong.

Leon Louw, Director of the Free Market Foundation

The draft National Liquor Policy proposes that:

  • The availability of liquor be reduced by regulating days and hours when liquor sales will be permitted in accordance with the National Liquor Norms and Standards;

  • The national minimum legal age at which alcohol can be purchased and consumed be raised from 18 to twenty one 21 years;

  • Liquor premises be located at least 500 meters away from schools, places of worship; recreation facilities, rehabilitation or retreat centres, residential areas and public institutions;

  • The Minister of Trade and Industry determine the restrictions and parameters for advertising and marketing of liquor products. This includes the restriction of advertisement of the alcoholic beverages, prohibitions of sponsorship and promotion associated with alcoholic beverages;

The proposed legislation closes for public review on 13 August 2015.

For more information on how to comment on the National Liquor policy visit the Government website.

Listen to the full conversation from CapeTalk's Breakfast with Kieno Kammies:


This article first appeared on 702 : Why the law proposed to hold bar owners liable for drunks may not work


Recommended

by THE NEWSROOM
Read More
LISTEN: Tannie Evita predicted Ramaphosa would be president in 1994

LISTEN: Tannie Evita predicted Ramaphosa would be president in 1994

Tannie Evita Bezuidenhout shares her thoughts on SA's new president.

'We look forward to an uplifting Sona' - Naledi Pandor

'We look forward to an uplifting Sona' - Naledi Pandor

Minister of Science and Technology Naledi Pandor expects Sona will outline the NEC's plans for improving the country.

Patricia de Lille: I'm determined to clear my name of corruption

Patricia de Lille: I'm determined to clear my name of corruption

Cape Town mayor Patricia de Lille, speaks out, following her survival of Thursday's DA motion of no confidence.

Water and Sanitation Dept kicks off #SaveWater campaign in Cape Town

Water and Sanitation Dept kicks off #SaveWater campaign in Cape Town

The department is encouraging all South Africans to keep saving water as parts of country grapple with one of the worst droughts.

It's all systems go for #SONA2018

It's all systems go for #SONA2018

Parly spokesman Moloto Mothapo says everything is ready for the State of the Nation Address which is scheduled for Friday.

Deadline for public comment on proposed national liquor law changes looms

Deadline for public comment on proposed national liquor law changes looms

We explore the Department of Trade and Industry’s draft National Liquor Policy and outline its purpose with relevant stakeholders.

Popular articles
Social media give President Ramaphosa the nod

Social media give President Ramaphosa the nod

Social media reacts with love and hope to President Ramaphosa's maiden State Of the Nation Address.

‘Maimane, Malema will find Ramaphosa harder to deal with than easy-target Zuma’

‘Maimane, Malema will find Ramaphosa harder to deal with than easy-target Zuma’

Afternoon Drive’s Stephen Grootes interviews Senior Research Associate at the Institute for Security Studies Judith February.

EFF's walk out was bizarre - Baleka Mbete

EFF's walk out was bizarre - Baleka Mbete

Speaker of Parliament Baleka Mbete shares her views on the future of Parliament and the readiness for Sona 2018

Hawks video shows fugitive Ajay Gupta leaving SA

Hawks video shows fugitive Ajay Gupta leaving SA

The Hawks are in possession of video footage showing Gupta, wanted in connection with Vrede dairy farm scandal, leaving SA.

Hope Ramaphosa: Cyril never lifted a finger to me, he wouldn't beat a woman

Hope Ramaphosa: Cyril never lifted a finger to me, he wouldn't beat a woman

Cyril Ramaphosa's ex-wife says abuse allegations spread by EFF leader Julius Malema are an attempt to tarnish his reputation.