MyMoney Online

Why you need a pension fund (or retirement annuity) even if you own a house

(Click here for more personal finance articles.)

Also read the following related articles:

You don’t have a pension fund or a retirement annuity, but you’re not worried because you own a large house in a good area.

Home is where the heart is — but it will not fund the retirement you want.

Here’s why…

The value of your house is theoretical

You don’t really know what your house is worth until you sell it and it’s impossible to predict what the property market will look like when you need or want to retire.

What if there’s a massive property bust? What if you are forced to sell due to, for example, a divorce? What if, by the time you retire, your leafy neighbourhood has become a crime hotspot? What if your formerly quiet area turns into a Business District?

Businesses close down, jobs are lost, cities and neighbourhoods change... Yet you’re hoping it’ll all be fine at the time when you sell? You cannot ever know for sure what the future holds. You are betting the good life on your home’s future value, which is conjecture at best.

You still have to live somewhere and most people struggle to downsize

It’ll cost you a pretty penny to sell your house and then what? You still have to live somewhere! Whatever you tell yourself now, it will probably be harder to downscale than you think. Many people try and most either fail or experience the process as a hardship.

You sell your huge house and buy a small one, and the difference is supposed to fund your retirement. How much will that difference be? Would you have to uproot and move to a cheaper area? Again, there are a lot of uncertainties.

You’ve put all your eggs in one basket

On some level you probably understand the concept of “not putting all your eggs into one basket”. Yet, by relying on your home to fund your retirement, this is exactly what you’re doing.

Having a pension fund or retirement annuity gives you the opportunity to diversify your investments between the various asset classes (shares, property, bonds and cash) as well as providing diversification benefits within each asset class (you’ll own shares in various companies, you’ll own shares in various properties, etc.). An investment in a residential property gives you exposure to a single asset within a single asset class.

Diversification is central to a successful investment plan. It is therefore not recommended, and extremely risky, to only invest in a single property.

Maintenance costs

The costs of owning property is open ended and will depend on a variety of factors, many of them unknown at the time of purchase. These include but aren’t limited to maintenance costs, massive amounts paid in interest over the duration of the loan, rates, taxes, insurance, etc…

The cost of owning property is significantly greater than the costs associated with, for example, a retirement annuity. You also know upfront how much it’ll set you back because, unlike property, costs are set in stone.

You’ve missed out on a lifetime of tax breaks that comes with pension contributions

The government taxes you for owning property, but pays you to invest in a pension fund or retirement annuity.

Currently up to 15 percent of your gross income is tax deductible if you invest it in a retirement annuity. If you contribute more than that you may claim the excess amount in future years and you may add excess contributions to the tax-free portion of any lump sum you receive.

This is not peanuts; it’s a fortune! The government is paying you crazy money to save for your own retirement. By relying only on your property to fund your retirement you’re saying “no thank you” to the mother of all free lunches.

You start over if you go bankrupt

If you should go bankrupt you'll have to sell your house (or the bank will do it for you) in order to pay your creditors.

If you had a retirement annuity you would’ve been completely protected against them. Your pension plan would be 100 percent intact and you would not lose a cent. This makes a retirement annuity especially advantageous to business owners.

The long-term returns of property are not great

Whatever you believe about your home's ability to fund your retirement, the fact is that residential property attains much lower returns than equities (though with less volatility) over longer terms.

According to the ABSA house price index, residential property lagged inflation for 16 years between 1986 and 2002. In other words, an investment in property would have lost you money. On the other hand, an investment in equities during this period outperformed property by a whopping 66 percent!

Then came the biggest property boom in South Africa's history. For five years property returned close to 20 percent, on average. This performance seems awesome, until you consider that equities returned 19.1 percent over the same period.

According to Matthew de Wet, Head of Investments at Nedgroup Investment, cash (i.e. money market investments) outperformed property, on average, by 0.5 percent per year since 1966.

A fascinating study by Piet Eichholtz, entitled The Herengracht Index, lends further weight to this argument. The Herengracht Index is an ultra-long-term study of the prices of property in the Herengracht district of Amsterdam. Records dating back to 1628 give us nearly 400 years of data to work with.

The houses on the Herengracht are well suited to a long-term study, because they have largely remained unchanged (although very well maintained) over the period in question. The Herengracht area has preserved its status as the finest area in Amsterdam in which to reside. This is important, because it means we are analysing an area that has retained its value relative to properties in other areas.

It is remarkable that real (i.e. taking inflation into account) house-price growth has averaged only 0.5 percent per year over the entire period. The results are fairly consistent over each century; the lowest real growth of -0.2 percent per year being in the 18th and 20th centuries and the highest real growth of 1.3 percent per annum being in the 17th century. Over shorter periods of time the real growth rate varied far more dramatically, with real price changes in excess of 50 percent over any 10-year period common.

Conclusion

Your large, paid-off house in a leafy neighbourhood is not a pension plan and risking the life you want for yourself on a single asset can never be a good idea.

Subscribe to our Business Wrap Newsletter


This article first appeared on 702 : Why you need a pension fund (or retirement annuity) even if you own a house


CapeTalk welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.

However, we will NOT condone the following:

  • Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
  • Sexism
  • Homophobia
  • Religious intolerance
  • Cyber bullying
  • Hate speech
  • Derogatory language
  • Comments inciting violence.

We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.

We strive to make the CapeTalk community a safe and welcoming space for all.

CapeTalk reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.

Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.

CapeTalk is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.

Read More
'The South African stock market is massively hedged against a weak rand'

'The South African stock market is massively hedged against a weak rand'

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Galileo Capital Personal Financial Advisor Warren Ingram.

3 shares that’ll boost your wealth, if you buy now (by Cannon Asset Managers)

3 shares that’ll boost your wealth, if you buy now (by Cannon Asset Managers)

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Cannon Asset Managers Portfolio Manager Samantha Steyn.

5 things you believe about investing that are keeping you from getting rich

5 things you believe about investing that are keeping you from getting rich

We interviewed Warren Ingram, Financial Advisor at Galileo Capital, who debunks widely held, yet patently false, investing myths.

What happens to your Retirement Annuity if your fund manager goes bust?

What happens to your Retirement Annuity if your fund manager goes bust?

Fund managers do from time to time go bankrupt. Here’s what’ll happen to your Retirement Annuity if yours does…

10 reasons why this is BY FAR the best way to save for retirement

10 reasons why this is BY FAR the best way to save for retirement

Is there a single best way to build your wealth so you can retire with dignity? Yes, there is, despite costs and limitations.

4 beliefs about shares that keep you from growing wealthy

4 beliefs about shares that keep you from growing wealthy

4 popular, yet patently false, beliefs about stock market investing that's holding you back.

Popular articles
If you're caught driving with your phone, officials are allowed to confiscate it

If you're caught driving with your phone, officials are allowed to confiscate it

If the engine is running and you are sitting behind the wheel you are not allowed to operate your phone says W Cape's JP Smith

[WATCH] Zola Tsotsi drops bombshell about Zuma meeting at State Capture Inquiry

[WATCH] Zola Tsotsi drops bombshell about Zuma meeting at State Capture Inquiry

Former Eskom chair Zola Tsotsi’s jaw-dropping statements include Tony Gupta saying they could hire or fire Eskom board members.

SA fizzy drinks undergo "shrinkflation" to control sugar intake

SA fizzy drinks undergo "shrinkflation" to control sugar intake

Coca-Cola has reduced its 500ml "buddy" to 440ml and the traditional 330ml Coke cans will soon have a volume of just 300ml.

Mugabe threatened to dissolve Parliament hours before his resignation

Mugabe threatened to dissolve Parliament hours before his resignation

Deputy President of MDC says Mugabe's threats could not deter them from their mission to impeach him - they were determined.

What Shoprite, Checkers, Pick n Pay and Makro will offer on Black Friday

What Shoprite, Checkers, Pick n Pay and Makro will offer on Black Friday

Up for a Springboks level scrum? Instructions on how to ensure you get the deals in your inbox the moment they become known...