Police couple self defense mechanism questioned. What is the legal implication?

An article on IOL news about a police couple who almost got robbed at their Kibler Park home left some of our listeners questioning the criminal law of this country.

A man who is identified only as Stuart wrote to John Maytham wanting to know the legal implications of the incident reported by IOL News.

He writes: I am not a firearm owner but I thought that it was illegal to shoot at a would-be criminal who is fleeing your property. Perhaps it is only illegal to shoot and kill? Difficult to guarantee as one never knows whether a vital organ or artery might be struck by the bullet.

Whilst I'm tempted to believe that the robbers probably got what they deserved and am relieved that couple got through unscathed, I'd just be interested to know what the legal standpoint is.

Thanks very much

CapeTalks John Maytham spoke to Prof. James Grant, Criminal lawyer:

The law basically is whether or not the defense mechanism was justified, it is within the act. They were unlawfully on a property … even when they got injured while in a retreating method it is not necessarily unlawful

James Grant, Criminal lawyer

Listen to the full conversation on The John Maytham Show:


Read More
Lynne Brown tells Parliament she never consulted with Guptas or associates

Lynne Brown tells Parliament she never consulted with Guptas or associates

Parliament's Public Enterprises portfolio committee is looking into claims of state capture at Eskom.

Helen Zille: Greatest agricultural innovations spring from barren countries

Helen Zille: Greatest agricultural innovations spring from barren countries

Zille talks about innovative techniques being developed in dry countries integrated and combined with a large worker-base.

If you're caught driving with your phone, officials are allowed to confiscate it

If you're caught driving with your phone, officials are allowed to confiscate it

If the engine is running and you are sitting behind the wheel you are not allowed to operate your phone says W Cape's JP Smith

Uber asks customers not to panic over 57 million users' leaked data - reporter

Uber asks customers not to panic over 57 million users' leaked data - reporter

EWN senior reporter Barry Bateman says the massive data breach does not include credit card and bank card information.

How Zimbabwe's impeachment of Mugabe will work

How Zimbabwe's impeachment of Mugabe will work

ISS Senior Researcher Derek Matyszak breaks down the numbers and how the impeachment process will play out.

Mahlobo won't be drawn on nuclear, until Cabinet approves energy plan

Mahlobo won't be drawn on nuclear, until Cabinet approves energy plan

Energy Minister David Mahlobo says government has not started the nuclear procurement process, reports EWN's Gaye Davis.

Popular articles
Zim ministers snub Mugabe's cabinet meeting call

Zim ministers snub Mugabe's cabinet meeting call

Regional Co-Ordinator at Crisis Zimbabwe Coalition, Joy Mabenge says the keys to Mugabe's impeachment are turning very fast.

Tender irregularities plague City of Cape Town

Tender irregularities plague City of Cape Town

Allegations point to irregularities in the tender processes where some bidders were preferred by the City's senior executives.

What Shoprite, Checkers, Pick n Pay and Makro will offer on Black Friday

What Shoprite, Checkers, Pick n Pay and Makro will offer on Black Friday

Up for a Springboks level scrum? Instructions on how to ensure you get the deals in your inbox the moment they become known...

I didn't believe that he was ever going to step down - JJ Cornish

I didn't believe that he was ever going to step down - JJ Cornish

EWN Africa Correspondent, JJ Cornish describes Mugabe's Sunday evening speech as a humiliating downturn for the Zim president.