Police couple self defense mechanism questioned. What is the legal implication?

An article on IOL news about a police couple who almost got robbed at their Kibler Park home left some of our listeners questioning the criminal law of this country.

A man who is identified only as Stuart wrote to John Maytham wanting to know the legal implications of the incident reported by IOL News.

He writes: I am not a firearm owner but I thought that it was illegal to shoot at a would-be criminal who is fleeing your property. Perhaps it is only illegal to shoot and kill? Difficult to guarantee as one never knows whether a vital organ or artery might be struck by the bullet.

Whilst I'm tempted to believe that the robbers probably got what they deserved and am relieved that couple got through unscathed, I'd just be interested to know what the legal standpoint is.

Thanks very much

CapeTalks John Maytham spoke to Prof. James Grant, Criminal lawyer:

The law basically is whether or not the defense mechanism was justified, it is within the act. They were unlawfully on a property … even when they got injured while in a retreating method it is not necessarily unlawful

James Grant, Criminal lawyer

Listen to the full conversation on The John Maytham Show:


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
'Ramaphosa is an a spot of bother'

'Ramaphosa is an a spot of bother'

News24 editor-in-chief Adriaan Basson says the president's campaigners should never have asked Bosasa for a donation.

Springboks take on Wallabies in Rugby Championship

Springboks take on Wallabies in Rugby Championship

John Maytham and Independent Media head of sport and motoring Mark Keohane go through the starting lineups for the countries.

Men make up majority of more than 6,000 people sleeping rough in Cape Town

Men make up majority of more than 6,000 people sleeping rough in Cape Town

The City of Cape Town says an estimated 6,175 make up the population of street sleepers in the Mother City.

Stellenbosch students find salvation from stress in the soil

Stellenbosch students find salvation from stress in the soil

Stellenbosch University's Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences says its Vegetable Garden Club is proving a huge success.

[LISTEN] Is there room for special gangs courts in South Africa?

[LISTEN] Is there room for special gangs courts in South Africa?

The idea was shared with Police Minister Bheki Cele during the crime summit in Paarl last weekend.

He didn't just appropriate that identity, he lived it  - Nomboniso Gasa

He didn't just appropriate that identity, he lived it - Nomboniso Gasa

Nomboniso Gasa addresses comments suggesting that the 'white Zulu' Johnny Clegg was guilty of cultural appropriation.

Popular articles
'Ramaphosa is an a spot of bother'

'Ramaphosa is an a spot of bother'

News24 editor-in-chief Adriaan Basson says the president's campaigners should never have asked Bosasa for a donation.

Mbube copywright: 'A lump sum of royalties would be paid to Linda family'

Mbube copywright: 'A lump sum of royalties would be paid to Linda family'

Spoor & Fisher consultant professor Owen Dean explains the outcome of the copyright infringement case against Disney.

[WATCH] Tour de France rider smashes into spectator's cellphone

[WATCH] Tour de France rider smashes into spectator's cellphone

Cycling journalist Mikkel Conde tweeted the clip warning spectators to stop leaning over the barriers with their phones.

You made a huge mistake downloading FaceApp if your privacy is important to you

You made a huge mistake downloading FaceApp if your privacy is important to you

Washington Post technology columnist Geoffrey A. Fowler did a forensic analysis of the Russia-based app. Check it out.

Beware 'dodgy' Nadal vs Federer ticket offers

Beware 'dodgy' Nadal vs Federer ticket offers

The Roger Federer Foundation says no ticket platforms are yet in possession of, nor have guaranteed allocation of tickets.

[WATCH] Mzansi's Ndlovu Youth Choir headed for AGT's live shows!

[WATCH] Mzansi's Ndlovu Youth Choir headed for AGT's live shows!

The choir that is stealing America's hearts is headed to the next round of America's Got Talent.

Shark attack: 'I saw a cloud of blood in the water'

Shark attack: 'I saw a cloud of blood in the water'

Joao Felizardo helped rescue his surfer buddy Dusty Phelan after a shark bit him across both his legs in Port Alfred.

'Batchelor was once close to Mikey Schultz and self-confessed Kebble killers'

'Batchelor was once close to Mikey Schultz and self-confessed Kebble killers'

Journalist and author Mandy Wiener describes former footballer Marc Batchelor's links to alleged underworld figures.

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

3 emergency numbers you should have on speed dial and how they work

These are the emergency numbers you should have on your cellphone and this is what you must understand about how they work.