Today's Big Stories, Homo Naledi: All eyes on SA's Cradle of Humankind

Doubts over Homo Naledi could be a case of sour grapes

Yesterday the world stopped and focused on South Africa for a while. The historical unveiling of the discovery of the remains of the so-called Homo naledi trove of fossils at Maropeng, at the Cradle of Humankind, has been met with some criticism - of the claims that this is a new species.

Sarah Wild is a science journalist who’s been looking at this issue. She speaks to Stephen about this criticism.

Wild says that questions are over if this is a new species or simply a variation of existing species.

She doesn't however take away from the finding, calling it "a spectacular and amazing find".

She says that there are also questions over why leader of the expedition, Paleoanthropologist, Lee Berger revealed the finding before dating it. This would have given light to where in history Homo naledi fits in. Scientists around the world are waiting for these numbers.

She also adds that there needs to discern over the criticism being legitimate scientific questioning and a case of 'sour grapes'.


This article first appeared on 702 : Doubts over Homo Naledi could be a case of sour grapes


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Wits Nehawu members down tools over salaries

Wits Nehawu members down tools over salaries

Nehawu Wits acting secretary Tumisho Madihlaba says negotiations with management deadlocked resulting in a strike.

Former Eskom interim CEO Sean Maritz under fire for signing off R400 mil payment

Former Eskom interim CEO Sean Maritz under fire for signing off R400 mil payment

‘Documents show that the fee contract was entered into by Anoj Singh & signed off by the acting CEO Sean Maritz' - Chris Yelland

‘Qedani Mahlangu helped people die then she ran away’ – Stephen Grootes

‘Qedani Mahlangu helped people die then she ran away’ – Stephen Grootes

Stephan Grootes shares his views on the events that unfolded at Life Esidimini and comments on Qedani Mahlangu’s apology.

Metrorail train derails due to vandalism on the central line

Metrorail train derails due to vandalism on the central line

The Central line was set to resume services on Thursday but has been postponed due to vandalism at Heideveld and Netreg stations.

#HomoNaledi - How important is this discovery?

#HomoNaledi - How important is this discovery?

Dr Chris Smith, The Naked Scientist share his views on the discovery of human ancestor, Homo Naledi with CapeTalk's John Maytham.

Homo naledi: The wonder of it all

Homo naledi: The wonder of it all

In the largest fossil find ever in Africa, a new species representing nearly 15 individuals may alter views of human behaviour.

Popular articles
[LISTEN]Tempers flare as Eusebius grills SABC's Maroleng about hiring and firing

[LISTEN]Tempers flare as Eusebius grills SABC's Maroleng about hiring and firing

Embattled public broadcaster's new COO, Chris Maroleng tries to defend SABC about Sakina Kamwendo incident.

'White South Africans learning an African language would show respect'

'White South Africans learning an African language would show respect'

A video of a white man speaking fluent TshiVenda went viral, but languages expert Dr Dowling says most black people speak English.

Water to be released from Berg River to Misverstand Dam to avoid Day Zero

Water to be released from Berg River to Misverstand Dam to avoid Day Zero

Government has put plans in place to prevent the Misverstand Dam from running dry in a week's time.

What Hashim Amla's fascinating story illuminates about South African society

What Hashim Amla's fascinating story illuminates about South African society

Writer Niren Tolsi says SA cricketer Hashim Amla is the living embodiment of a nation trying to express itself while healing.

Highly-criticised world athletics body's rule could end Caster Semenya's career

Highly-criticised world athletics body's rule could end Caster Semenya's career

She faces ongoing complaints from rivals about having an "unfair advantage" on the track, but how fair is this proposed IAAF rule?

Cape plumber designs device to ensure geyser water doesn't go down the drain

Cape plumber designs device to ensure geyser water doesn't go down the drain

Wattapac is a water-saving bladder and pump designed to help plumbers save as much as 1 000 litres of water a day.

Madiba’s private secretary Zelda la Grange opens up about money (hers and his)

Madiba’s private secretary Zelda la Grange opens up about money (hers and his)

Bruce Whitfield interviews La Grange about her and Madiba's attitude to money (hopes and fears, successes and failures, etc.)