Karatbars – is it a scam? The case for and against…
Is Karatbars a scam?
The Financial Sector Conduct Authority – the financial services watchdog – says Karatbars International GmbH is not an authorised financial advisor or provider of intermediary services.
Regulators in several countries have warned against Karatbars.
The Bank of Namibia officially declared it a pyramid scheme while in Germany – the home of Karatbars - the banking watchdog issued a cease-and-desist order against it.
Karatbars is under investigation in the US and several reputable cryptocurrency news sites have issued warnings about it to the public.
The multi-level marketing company offers online purchases of cards and notes with tiny “cryptonyzed” gold bars embedded in them to “affiliates” who earn a commission when they enlist other affiliates.
They’re talking to desperate people… it’s very vague… criminals will take advantage of this… Exercise extreme caution. There are so many ways to buy gold through established channels…Warren Ingram, Personal Financial Advisor - Galileo Capital
He then spoke to Thomas Valet, Communication Manager at Karatbars International (apologies, the audio quality is poor).
We intend to make gold affordable in small denominations…Thomas Valet, Communication Manager - Karatbars International
Whitfield also spoke to a listener, Susan, who attended a Karatbars conference in Cape Town.
I was invited to join the conference… it was quite a strange affair… very theatrical… it was sort of a frenzy… pumping music… hyping people up… Then, a grand entrance – everybody started chanting – then Harald Seiz, the CEO, stepped in… it was like the Messiah walking into the room. There was a lot of emotional fervour… it was like a Rockstar on stage…Susan, Karatbars conference attendee
The whole premise is based on belief and trust. They don’t offer any evidence. It’s like a personality cult…Susan, Karatbars conference attendee
He [Karatbars CEO Harald Seiz] told the audience that a lot of people will tell them it’s a pyramid scheme. He then coached the audience on how to deflect those allegations…Susan, Karatbars conference attendee
Finally, Whitfield interviewed Tony De Gouveia, one of the main South African affiliates at Karatbars International.
No, it’s not [a pyramid scheme] … Karatbars won a court case in Canada…Tony De Gouveia, South African affiliate - Karatbars International
I get paid because people in the network buys the product… I would guess more than 10 000 people in South Africa are in Karatbars, buying gold.Tony De Gouveia, South African affiliate - Karatbars International
Our legal firm in South Africa… have contacted the FSCA… giving the correct information about Karatbars…Tony De Gouveia, South African affiliate - Karatbars International
For more detail, listen to the interviews in the audio below.
Get the 10 most-read articles of the week from Bruce Whitfield’s The Money Show, emailed to you every Friday morning:
Pent-up demand, excess supply and record low interest rates are fuelling the unforeseen recovery, says Siphamandla Mkhwanazi.Read More
The bank is one of only six in the world to be recognised in this way for outstanding performance during the global health crisis.Read More
Everything is done electronically – you never have to leave your home, says Mortgage Me’s Andrea Tucker.Read More
[EXPLAINED] The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Craig Wilson, Editor at Stuff Magazine.Read More
Shoprite is exiting the oil-rich but spending-money-poor nation. Bruce Whitfield interviews Dianna Games (Africa At Work).Read More
The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Natascha Viljoen, CEO at Amplats.Read More
It still argues that the lockdown, not the pandemic, is responsible for its clients’ losses. Bruce Whitfield interviews its CEO.Read More
As widely expected, Sarb Governor Lesetja Kganyago announced a repo rate cut of 25 basis points on Thursday.Read More
"Consumers who are in debt have received a huge bonanza," says Econometrix Chief Economist Dr Azar Jammine.Read More
"This case shows rogue officials at Sars that the courts protect taxpayers," says tax attorney Jean-Louis Nel (Tax Consulting SA).Read More