ConsumerTalk with Wendy Knowler

'New' antiseptic TCP not the same as the original you grew up with

The TCP which many of us grew up with as the go-to remedy for throat and mouth infections - and many other things too - is not the same as the TCP now on sale, despite the fact that it has been marketed with the words “original” and “The real TCP is back”.

It may smell the same, but it does not contain the same amount of phenol - which has antiseptic and disinfectant properties - as before. And the sodium salicylate, an anti-inflammatory and pain compound, has been removed entirely from the new formulation.

TCP became a registered trademark in South Africa in 1945, having been introduced to the market in the ‘20s, a few years after it went on sale in the UK.

It disappeared from our shelves in 2004, and then, suddenly, in 2015 it was back, with the same distinctive smell, thanks to new owners Omegalabs.

In January this year, all Omegalabs brands, including TCP, were ceded to Austell Pharmaceuticals under a sales and distribution license.

The front label of the new TCP bottle no longer states that the all-purpose personal antiseptic liquid also “treats, cleans and protects” cuts, grazes, minor wounds, insect bites, and minor burns.

The change was to bring TCP in line with the TCP formulation in the UK. “All medicinal claims were removed, which meant that the product could be registered under the Food, Cosmetics, and Disinfectants Act,” said Darryl Combe, who was until recently the general manager of Omegalabs.

Austell’s commercial head, Jarrod Kayton says although TCP is classified under the Foodstuffs, Cosmetics and Disinfectants Act as a disinfectant, “the general directions for use do not negate the validity or benefit of using TCP as it was originally used.”

But all the new TCP bottle says is: “To assist with hygiene matters, dilute 1 part TCP with 4 parts water. For use on surfaces and other household items, apply neat for five minutes.”

“Oral health may be included in ‘hygiene matters’,” Kayton said, adding it was still appropriate for it to be sold in the oral health section of pharmacies.

“We have been engaging with the NRCS around including more specific directions for use so as to clarify these details for consumers,” he said, “and have already submitted a labelling proposal to the NRCS.”

But what will happen for sure is the word “original” will be removed from the packaging and marketing messages.

So what’s the deal with the product called 3CP?

Ironically the original TCP formula has been available in SA as 3CP, by Tritof Enterprises, since 2010. Like TCP, it is registered under the Food, Cosmetics and Disinfectants Act.

Last year Omegalabs brought court proceedings against Tritof based on trademark infringement, accusing the company of “passing off”, in that consumers would be confused into thinking there was an association between the two. At one point 3CP used the marketing line: “Different packaging, same ingredients.”

The court found there was a trademark infringement. The product remains widely on sale as 3CP, at a significantly higher price than TCP.


Recommended

by NEWSROOM AI
Read More
Unauthorised debit orders: When last did you check your bank statement?

Unauthorised debit orders: When last did you check your bank statement?

Unauthorised debit orders are a huge problem affecting thousands of South Africans.

 Nissan 'Hardbody' and other SA carmakers accused of cutting corners on safety

Nissan 'Hardbody' and other SA carmakers accused of cutting corners on safety

South Africans are buying cars that wouldn't be allowed to be sold in other markets because of poor safety features.

Here's what makes a loyalty rewards programme a must-have for consumers

Here's what makes a loyalty rewards programme a must-have for consumers

The Clicks ClubCard is the most used loyalty programme in SA. The CEO loyalty consultancy firm Truth shares the latest insights.

Waiters urged to push back against common (but illegal) restaurant practices

Waiters urged to push back against common (but illegal) restaurant practices

Uniform fees, extra deductions and other dodgy restaurant tactics used to pass along some of their operating costs to their staff.

ADT to pay up R29k for items stolen when guards were on duty after CT house fire

ADT to pay up R29k for items stolen when guards were on duty after CT house fire

Personal belongings were stolen from this Newlands home overnight in May while Fidelity ADT officials were apparently on guard.

Woolies pilots smart recycling machines at two CT stores

Woolies pilots smart recycling machines at two CT stores

Retailer Woolworths introduced a new recycling machine at its Palmyra Junction store last month. Its V&A Waterfront store is next.

Popular articles
Markus Jooste will absolutely hate this book book by FM Editor Rob Rose

Markus Jooste will absolutely hate this book book by FM Editor Rob Rose

Financial Mail Editor Rob Rose talks about his book, “Steinheist: Markus Jooste, Steinhoff and SA’s biggest corporate fraud”.

Wife of Nathan Ganas speaks out over Momentum's refusal to pay up

Wife of Nathan Ganas speaks out over Momentum's refusal to pay up

Momentum has refused to pay a R2.4 million policy payout citing a non-disclosure breach

School fees for 2019 higher than inflation rate

School fees for 2019 higher than inflation rate

Bad news for parents as school fees for 2019 are set to increase way above inflation.

6 dumbest things people in their 20s do with money

6 dumbest things people in their 20s do with money

Sam Beckbessinger, the author of “Manage Your Money like a F*cking Grownup,” has some tips, so you don’t have to live with regret.

[LISTEN] 'We will not pay out the insurance claim', MMI CEO tells Eusebius

[LISTEN] 'We will not pay out the insurance claim', MMI CEO tells Eusebius

Eusebius McKaiser engages MMI CEO in a fiery debate about why they won't pay gunshot victim's R2.4 million policy claim.

VW vehicle nightmare to cost customer R23 000  after third engine fails

VW vehicle nightmare to cost customer R23 000 after third engine fails

A brand new Touran that's had three new engines since 2012 is about to cost the customer R23 000 for a fourth engine.