Streaming issues? Report here
The Money Show with Bruce Whitfield
18:00 - 20:00

Up Next: Tonight with Lester Kiewit
See full line-up
The Money Show with Bruce Whitfield
18:00 - 20:00


World Cup is reminding South Africans that sport is still divided

World Cup is reminding South Africans that sport is still divided

Guest : Francois Cleophas

As South Africa’s Springbok rugby team vies for victory in the 2019 Rugby World Cup
tournament, it is worthwhile to reflect on the historical substance of sports unity since
South Africa held its first democratic elections in 1994. In mainstream history and
school textbooks this represented a turning point that brought unity to South African
society. But the danger of honing in on a single event blurs the broader social and
political landscape that led up to the 1994 moment and subsequent developments.
More directly, Walter Mignolo, a prominent scholar of decolonial theory, reminded his
audience at a recent conference that when the colonised take over the state, past
complexities can be reproduced without question. The result is that power relations that
favour the privileged remain intact.
Since 1994 South Africans have been constantly bombarded with the much publicised
words of Nelson Mandela:
"Sport has the power to change the world; it has the power to inspire. It has the power to
unite like little else does. It speaks to youth in a language they understand. Sport can
create hope where once there only was despair."
But criticism against the notion that “sport has the power to unite like little else does”
has become unpopular and has, to borrow from Neville Alexander,
"scored a duck or very low innings in post-Apartheid society."
South Africans no longer, as they did prior to 1994, dare speak truth to power. Instead
there is silence about racism and class divides in sport and almost a denial that there
was vicious racism in sport prior to 1994.
This raises the question: Does the nature, basis and purpose of unity in the pre-1990
anti-apartheid sports movement correspond with developments after 1994?
To answer these questions it’s useful to consider two types of unity – principled and ad
hoc. Principled unity endeavours to unite people around a common outlook and how
they intend achieving their common goal. Clarity of ideas and practice is crucial. With
ad hoc unity one may discard their allies once the short term goals have been achieved.
I argue that the sports unity that was achieved in South Africa during the last decade of
the 20th century was an ad hoc or temporary tactical unity.
The history
After the unbanning of the anti-apartheid political organisations in 1990 a new sport
political elite emerged. It was made up of the apartheid sport federations and
individuals from within the sport liberation movement. Despite rhetoric to the contrary,
the new elite favoured the establishment or apartheid sports federations. Lured by the
prospects of jobs, and the high life, former outspoken anti-apartheid sports critics began
promoting unity while side-lining the South African Council on Sport. This was the
internal non-racial anti-Apartheid sports organisation.
And when some officials of the South African Non-Racial Olympic Committee returned
to South Africa from exile, they sought the political support of the establishment sports
federations, ignoring the South African Council on Sport. Not surprisingly, the sports
moratorium was lifted without the South African Council on Sport’s consent.
What followed was a scenario of extraordinary unity sports ventures. For example,
South Africa participated in the 1992 Olympic Games and organised a cricket tour to
India with the Apartheid government still in power.
In this period (1992-1994), the country was represented solely by players from apartheid
sport federations. National and provincial non-racial school sport federations were
abandoned while white school sport derbies continued and thrived.
Although it was clear to many, nobody dared to state that the unified sports teams were
nothing more than apartheid teams playing under the banner of a yet to be democratic
sport structure.
Many South Africans were lulled into believing that white people, who had benefited
from apartheid sport, would be willing to share their gains in meaningful ways with
sports structures of the non-racial movement.
What the South African Council on Sport demanded was a moratorium on international
sports contacts until development at grassroots level had reached a satisfactory level.
But many activists capitulated and gave in to the demands of the new sport political
elite for international participation under new unified sports federations.
Bitter fruit
South Africans are reaping the effects of this ad-hoc sports unity. School sports in the
townships, the historically racially segregated areas of black working classes, are either
non-existent or at an extremely low level, while middle to high fee-paying schools offer
learners a variety of sports opportunities. For black students to achieve sport success,
they have to attend middle to high fee-paying schools.
It is therefore not surprising that the vast majority of first team players (black and white)
in the Protea cricket and netball teams come from these schools. The same applies to
the Springbok rugby team.
There is no sports organisation outside government that speaks on behalf of the poor
and marginalised communities and their sports structures and organisations.
The type of unity that was forged between sports organisations in the 1990s has
inevitably meant that there’s no urgency about addressing social inequality in society.
It is wasteful energy to seek out opportunistic racist culprits and collaborators to blame
for the current state of inertia in sport within the country’s economically poor areas.
What is needed now is a principled sports unity that is forged from grassroots upwards
to national level. Sports clubs need to be formed for purposes of healthy participation,
enjoyment and competition at all levels.
In addition, sports clubs need to become part of critically-minded social movements
that deliberately downplay virtues of excessive monetary gain and the ‘win at all costs’
approach. This is nothing less than a call for a new progressive sports movement that
works for equality and peace based on mass participation and social justice.
Otherwise, 25 years down the line South Africans will still be in search of a sports unity
that is both principled and practical.
The Conversation
- Francois Cleophas is a senior lecturer in Sport History at Stellenbosch University.
021 808 4724//084 444 6004

More episodes from Tonight With Lester Podcast

Older women preying on young boys (19:53)

15 October 2019 9:59 PM

Guest : David Bruce | writer and researcher specialising in the field of policing, criminal                                           justice, violence and crime.
            Tony Lawrence | from the the Child Protection Collaborative

According to reports more than 1 boy was involved in sexual relations with a Bishops
teacher, school principal Guy Pearson said in a statement on that several boys were
involved over a number of years.
The teacher left school when the story broke and her father David Mallet has issued a
statement in connection with the incident.
It's also been reported that the boy tried to break off the relationship but the teacher
refused, the school has also called on other pupils that have information to come

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Cars with Melinda Ferguson (11:14)

15 October 2019 9:32 PM

Guest : Melinda Ferguson

Mazda CX 3

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Dr Paulo de Valdoleiros (18:31)

15 October 2019 9:05 PM

Guest : Dr Paulo de Valdoleiros

Doctor Paulo de Valdoleiros doesn’t just attend to health problems. He restores people’s
faith in humanity. For many, the high cost of medical services derails their treatment.
But at De Valdoleiros’ clinic in Bloemfontein, patients are welcome to pay as much as
they can afford. This approach often prompts people to open up about their financial
hardships. De Valdoleiros listens earnestly, as they each echo his own background.
Though De Valdoleiros always yearned to be a doctor, his family didn’t have the funds
for his education. So he went straight to work, toiling in different careers for most of his
life. By the age of 45, De Valdoleiros couldn’t ignore his lifelong passion any longer. But
it wasn’t a simple endeavour. De Valdoleiros contacted every medical faculty in South
Africa, receiving the same response every time – his matric certificate was outdated. So
De Valdoleiros enrolled in a Bachelor of Science degree, proved that he could maintain
high results, and was finally selected to study Medicine. He graduated one month
before turning 51.
In June 2019, De Valdoleiros opened his clinic with the intention to place humanity
before business. De Valdoleiros’ novel practice has attracted attention throughout
South Africa, and he’s a regular guest on a televised health show. Despite his fame, De
Valdoleiros remains focused on helping others. No matter what patients pay, he’s
always giving more. The gift of kindness is priceless.

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Beautiful News (6:10)

14 October 2019 10:01 PM

Guests : Joy Cronje 
              Judy Strickland
              Joshua Swarts

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Apartheid Era Spies (33:)

14 October 2019 9:49 PM

Guests : Jonathon Ancer
               Glenn Bowes

The author of Spy : Uncovering Craig Williamson, Jonathon Ancer's new book "Betrayal : The Secret Lives of Apartheid Spies"  looks at the roles of spies in the Apartheid era, from a navy super spy working for Mother Russia to the young students that were approached by security police to spy on activists at Tertiary institutions. 

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

150 Years of Traffic Lights (12:39)

14 October 2019 9:09 PM

Guest : Maxine Bezuidenhout

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Lane Sharing Outlawed (26:1)

14 October 2019 8:43 PM

Guest : Billy De Beer

Motorcyclists are revved-up over a City traffic by-law amendment they say will outlaw lane sharing with cars or riding between cars (lane-splitting).

Bikers have accused the City of trying to ban them from riding between motor vehicles and making motorcycles behave like cars.

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Susanna Kennedy (39:20)

13 October 2019 11:02 PM

Guests : Susanna Kennedy
               Catherine van Heerden

Joining Susanna is :
A successful business and life coach, entrepreneur, and author, Catherine van Heerden
has used her expertise and experience to benefit various organisations and individuals
across the globe.
Through Catherine’s coaching, support, and life success products, you will have the tools
to finally take hold of your vision/dreams and transform them into reality.

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Chantelle Goliath (10:25)

13 October 2019 10:20 PM

Guest : Chantelle Goliath

Meet Chantelle Goliath is a businesswoman and entrepreneur who was born and raised
in Klipfontein and today she currently owns an import and export company called Milli
Chantelle also heads up New Heritage Foundation in the Western Cape, which provides
remodelled, clean and healthy infrastructures and enhance the internal and external
aesthetics for learning environments like Educare Centres and Primary Schools.
Chantelle is on the show this evening to talk about the work that she does but also what
inspires her to give back in these ways to her community.

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward

Philippi Horticultural Area (40:21)

13 October 2019 9:57 PM

Guests : Nazeer Sonday
               Susanna Coleman

In an open letter to the Mayor of Cape Town, Nazeer Sonday wrote that “ 3000 Phillipa
Horticultural Area farm workers will…lose their jobs” if their organisation’s bid to stop
Oakland City developer Wentzel Oaker – from going ahead with their planned
development of the land that is the Philippi Horticultural Area (PHA) Sonday also makes
the point that most of the people who will be affected by this development are women
and the youth and that Another 3000 who work in support services will also lose their
jobs. All of this rests on the outcome of a court case which will commence on October
15 in the Western Cape High Court.

LISTEN TO PODCAST arrow_forward